His lead is slim? Says who? Is this a fact or your opinion, fam. I'm leaning toward the latter. The first and foremost criteria in P4P ranking is W's & L's. I can live with the argument that Fedor MAY rank above Silva, but GSP? C'mon, son. Silva wouldn't finish his opponent, even though he clearly could have. GSP couldn't finish his opponent, even though he tried his best, to no avail. Those are two different things all together. And Fedor would need stiffer competition for me to just hand him the crown, easily. Although, there's no questioning his dominance over the competition he's faced, so far. As for Manny & Floyd: To be the man, you gotta beat the man.
Word? So you haven’t heard any discussion about who is MMA P4P champ? Will let me help you out fam. Visit these sites and then holla at me.
http://sports.yahoo.com/mma/news;_ylt=Ak5sgdBSvzcXEbXk8rfXzIE9Eo14?slug=dd-mmaranks040110
http://www.profighting-fans.com/rankings/mma-pound-for-pound.html
http://www.sherdog.com/news/rankings/Sherdogcoms-Pound-for-Pound-Top-10-23629
http://www.mmaplayground.com/top-10-mma-fighters.aspx
http://www.mmanews.com/rankings
And I’m not saying that Silva isn’t the P4P king. I’m merely pointing out that several people don’t have him at the top of the list and that those that do have him at the top don’t have him ahead by much. That’s a fact. Not my opinion. If anything, it’s a fact about other people’s opinion if that makes you feel any better. Either way, you don’t have to agree with it, but you can’t deny that its out there.
Also, the P4P ranking isn’t simply about wins. It’s about wins against quality opposition. Anderson is a beast, but lets keep it real, 3 out of his last 4 fights have been hard to watch. His matches against Cote, Leites, and now Maia were WACK. And none of those dudes are considered elite middleweights. He KO’d Forrest in spectacular fashion and deserves credit for it, especially for fluctuating between weight classes while doing. But Forrest has been KO’d by lesser competition (Keith Jardine) and his limited stand-up was tailor made for Silva. All in all, Forrest isn’t the most talented fighter. He’s just a tough scrapper with good skills that caught a break by getting a bullshit decision against Rampage.
Again, I think Anderson deserves recognition as P4P king, but a legitimate argument can be made against him.
Dana White just don't like or respect black fighters. Never before has a so called promoter on many occations just try everything in his power to make a fighter loose. If any of you guys are fighters you should see this. He makes Anderson fight at a different weight every fight...His last 4 fights 180, 190, 205, and back to 185. You cannot perform well doing this..I. E. the end of Roy Jones going up and down. You can go up and stay up but up and down just don't work... B J Penn another example. I know that I am ramblling a bit but it makes me mad when us brothers don't see this UFC bullshit for what it is. Dana don't want no black face to be the face of the sport.... I like GSP but his last fight was just as bad a Silvas.. all he did was takedown and control the action the way he knew how...when silva controls the fight the way he knows how Dana has issues....The same with his bad talk about Rampage... I could go on and on...
Dog, sorry but Dana stays giving Anderson props in a way that contradicts what you’re saying here. Dana has consistently said that Silva is the best fighter in the world, even when asked about GSP. If what you’re saying were true, Dana would label white boy GSP as the P4P king. GSP would actually be easier to promote as the P4P best considering that he is a white boy, speaks English, and is the poster boy of the modern day respectful martial artist. Yet, Dana is quick to say that Silva is the better P4P fighter. Also, Silva is the one who has decided to go from one weight class to another, which I give him credit for. He has pretty much wiped out the middleweight division and has decided to try lightheavy weights in search for better challengers. That said, Anderson has made that call, not Dana. Its also worth pointing out that Dana is just a dick to everyone regardless of race. He has had issues with top white fighters. Just look at his fall out with UFC legend/golden boy Randy “Captain America” Couture.
dude ...you wildin. Silva destroyed Forrest (the fuckin golden boy of the UFC) without breaking a fuckin sweat. son didnt even try. he fought half assed and still koed him. in my opinion that is wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy more impressive than runnin in the octagon on some tyson shit and knockin him out in 20sec.
I already addressed this above but I’ll add one thing…Forrest was never the UFC’s golden boy. That person’s name is Randy Couture, maybe Chuck Lidell. Anyway, Anderson certainly whooped Forrest but his other recent matches have left people wanting a lot more. Plus, its not like Anderson did that to a Rampage Jackson, Rashard Evans, Maricio Rua, or Lyoto Machida so lets put that victory in perspective.
one more thing.....It takes 2 fighters to fight....Nobody is made at UCONN for beating the shit out of everyone. Is it UCONN's fault that they can BS around and still win by 30, no it is the other MF's fault for not being able to make the shit a fight. fuck Dana White and anybody who thinks that when he stands up there whinning that he is talking for the good of the sport. Chuck leddell ain't beat nobody in years and can still get fights...Let's see what Dana is gonna have for Rashad 2 years from now!!!!
First off, let’s hope that Rashard isn’t in Chuck’s current position 2 years from now. Dude should have a long career ahead. That said, I hope you realize that there is a HUGE difference in the careers of Chuck Lidell and Rashard Evans. Chuck is an MMA legend and was the face of the UFC for a few years. Few people have accomplished what he has in the sport so he’s earned the right to continue to fight if he so chooses. Rashard is a top fighter but is far from a legend so there is no way he should be granted the same consideration if his career were winding down at this point.