I get what you're saying. The world was a bit too real and kinda clashed with the innate campiness of Batman.I didnt have a problem per se with the storyline. A noir Batman flick...ok ok. But the nigga didnt feel like Batman. He felt like a nigga in a Batsuit with some gadgets. Even the Batmobile. I'm like, this nigga got a armored Hellcat for a Batmobile?
You can't make Penguin a Godfather type gangster but still have a dude walking around in a batsuit. It makes Batman look ridiculous. There's no room in that world for villains like Killer Croc or Clayface either.