I answered your question in the first sentence of my comment. I'd appreciate if you answered mine. I didn't ask your opinion about swaps. I asked 2 specific questions and even included sex in it to avoid the predictable deflection to things that happened decades ago(which were foul as fuck). So like I did for you, just answer my 2 questions.The swap thing the other way argument never works.
Blame racist cacs for decades of abuse and misrepresentation and disenfranchisement. We don't even have that many characters to swap out. They used to color black characters white in comics for years "by accident". The caricatures stereotypes racist tropes. Trust me I've had to hear that garbage take since I started collecting and writing
So that's bullsh*t.
that being said Ariel ain't white she is a mermaid.
Her race or ethnicity has no agency to who she is.
But I ain't looking at money.
That sh*t is just dumb
Why make Mario black though? he is Italian and they knew better than to keep the accent RIGHT? It doesn't make sense to switch him.
a black Ken would have worked if it fit the story.
I still haven't seen it but there was every kind. But according to the story a white Ken fit best. Apparently it mattered.
I'm for the STORY.
Whatever fits.
Folks HATED Miles Morales at one time John Stewart too.
I don't believe in enabling racism and ignorance even for profit.
Now the point you and vicious made about change JUST FOR CHANGE SAKE?
is difficult for me.
It's case by case.
I generally agree don't just change it to change it.
But especially Ariel it shouldn't have been a big deal.
I don't consider it a GOOD thing it flopped because they cast a black girl.
I'll even make the first question easier for you. If your favorite IP character was SEX swapped, how would you feel? Again, I'll provide my answer. I'd be pissed.
And if one can make a nordic Mermaid black(the non-fish part since we acting like her being a mermaid had no human racial component) why can't they make an Italian black(mario)? Say he was sicilian and call it a day.

So does black Mario and black barbie/ken make $1 billion? Yes or no? And I'll provide my answer first. No they do not. Not even close. Don't care if the ghost of Homer wrote that shit. Greatest story ever and folks won't show up because they don't recognize it.
What this comes down to is simply respecting IPs and source material. If folks want new characters(which is what swaps do), just make new characters. I hate lazy shit. And even though we all hypocrites to a degree, shit is ridiculously hypocritical.
And unlike most here, I keep the same energy. If they did a terminator and sex swapped Sara conner or sex swapped Ripley in Aliens, I'd call bullshit. Make Conan black. I call bullshit. Make Mace an Asian. Fuckery. What about 2023 heathcliff as a girl cat? Bullshit. And so on and so on. Green smurfs? FOH. Call me anything but a hypocrite when it comes to this shit.
So do I hate men because I don't want sara conner, Ripley, Tomb Raider, or any prominent women characters sex swapped? See how ridiculous this swap shit is? That's why none of the pro-swap arguments hold up and that's why all the shit flops.
The only reason this movie sticks out so much and I'm using it as an example is the same-year success of Barbie/Mario. This movie should have been up there. It was a fucking layup.