Why do women feel that they shouldn't be hit?

Machete

Rising Star
Registered
Another Chis / Rihanna based thread. ( Sorry, my computer crapped out on me and I can't do any work so ya'll just have to suffer. this is not colin friendly )

Been lurking on the board, reading the different posts regarding violence against women. And, I'm surprised at the amount of people who say that women should NEVER be hit. And the mindset that a man who's prepared to defend himself against ANY attacker is a bitch, weak, etc.

I'm not condoning ABUSE of any kind, specially against women ( and children ). Simply because they are the weaker sex ( physically ), in most cases and because abuse of any kind is just wrong.

This question is for the women ( and men ) who feel that a woman should never, ever, ever be hit. No matter what the circumstances are. Can you please explain why? Don't you think that there are life threatening situations that may warrant some sort of violence? ( A late dinner doesn't qualify as a life threatening situation) For those that advocate the "holding her down" theory, don't you feel that it's the same as hitting a woman? Or the wrist lock? Or the "squeezing of the fist"?

I'm asking for you to justify your opinion. Of course you should avoid the situation at all costs, but that doesn't always happen. I'm actually caught between both opinions myself, and I was in a situation where I was with a female who got physical. We started arguing, I don't even remember what we were arguing about. But she started pulling on me, pulling my hair, hitting me, biting me, kicking me. The whole time this is going on, I'm not saying anything just trying to get out of the apt before I did somethign stupid. We were 12 floors up, and of course there was only one door. She's blocking the door, and when I tried to lift her out the way, she would grab onto the door knob. When I tried to pull her out the way, she would start with the hitting. I managed to get out the door once, she grabbed my glasses and runs back into the apt ( I'm blind w/o them and I still had to get home). I go back in, wrestle the glasses from her, without hurting her, and go thru the same struggle to get back out. This goes on for an hour, and she's hitting me the whole time, I manage to get out the apt the second time. When she realizes this, she starts punching and pounding on me as hard as she can, I snapped and lashed out. She gives me this "I can't believe you hit me look" and goes back into the apt. This happened years ago, damn near a decade. And I still feel sick to stomach that I did something out of my character. But at the same time, I wonder if I took the hits for too long. I wonder if I'm following my societal ( word? ) conditioning by feeling guilty about hitting her.

Please answer the question, and help with my boredom.
 
I may be a hypocrite on this issue....
If I hit my dude knowing he can kick my ass, I cant cry and call the police because I he did....Here in Indiana if a woman hits and he hits her back..If the police come, both parties go to jail.
Having said that...I feel that it is morally wrong for a man to hit a woman. Told you I was a hypocrite:dunno:
 
I may be a hypocrite on this issue....
If I hit my dude knowing he can kick my ass, I cant cry and call the police because I he did....Here in Indiana if a woman hits and he hits her back..If the police come, both parties go to jail.
Having said that...I feel that it is morally wrong for a man to hit a woman. Told you I was a hypocrite:dunno:

Might be hypocritical, but I feel the same way. But it doesn't mean that I won't do it, just that I'll try to find other options first. Why do you feel that way?
 
Last edited:
I changed my opinion on this a long time ago ... I do feel it's justified now if a man hits a woman in self defence ... I do however still feel just cuz the majority of the time the man is physically stronger that he should try not to use excessive force ... i.e If Rihanna did hit Chris (which I think she might have) he was justified in hitting her back ... but looking at that pic of her battered face makes me think he took it too far ... IMO

And I'd like to add (cuz I KNOW somebody will bring it up:rolleyes:) if it turns into some sort of movie style wild west free for all gun play knives everywhere to the death then of course the man should do whatever it takes to stay alive
 
Might be hypocritical, but I feel the same way. But it doesn't mean that I won't do it, just that I'll try to find other options first. Why do you feel that way?

Hey my fellow hypocrite! lolol :D
Just want to be clear, why do I feel which way?
If you mean why do I feel it is morally wrong? Because most men are physically stronger than women, you are the stronger gender.
:dunno:
 
I do feel it's justified now if a man hits a woman in self defence ... I do however still feel just cuz the majority of the time the man is physically stronger that he should try not to use excessive force ... i.e If Rihanna did hit Chris (which I think she might have) he was justified in hitting her back ... but looking at that pic of her battered face makes me think he took it too far ... IMO

My dear it's simple.

Me and my boys used to play a game. Chestize. Men have different names for it around the country.

You hit me in the chest with all your might, THEN I hit you back with all my might, and we see who breaks.

A man and a woman playing chestize. Who's going to win?

:hmm:

No justification.
 
You didnt click out on her like you did me:(
Not that I want you to, because I do agree w/ her...
I'm just saying.
You know whats crazy my boy was locked up for fighting his girl.
Me and my dude argued about this very subject. Everything you said in this thread and the other is exactly what he said.
Not that I dont agree...I just have my own thoughts on some domestic violence issues.
My dear it's simple.

Me and my boys used to play a game. Chestize. Men have different names for it around the country.

You hit me in the chest with all your might, THEN I hit you back with all my might, and we see who breaks.

A man and a woman playing chestize. Who's going to win?

:hmm:

No justification.
 
Just like stocks ...you gotta get out of there when you see signs.

Many of these dudes self esteem is just as low as the girls.

You not supposed to be there long enough for that shit to pop off.:smh:
 
My dear it's simple.

Me and my boys used to play a game. Chestize. Men have different names for it around the country.

You hit me in the chest with all your might, THEN I hit you back with all my might, and we see who breaks.

A man and a woman playing chestize. Who's going to win?

:hmm:

No justification.

If you pull a knife on the police and they shoot you, are they wrong?

Who would win? The knife or the gun?

If you know the other person has a gun, why attack them with the knife?
 
Because people like to simplify things. Generally speaking, a man is stronger than a woman (even though there are some big and tall females out there), so he shouldn't hit a woman. There are instances where you might have to go all out though. But for the most part, it's going to be too much on the man's part.

I've been trying to hold out on saying anything until the whole story comes out about Chris Brown and Rhianna. While I feel what he did was excessive, I'm still wondering what set him off like that? So what I'm saying here is, there's always a shade of grey. Some women play around in that shade of grey. It sounds like that chick was playing around in that shade of grey with you.
 
I've been trying to hold out on saying anything until the whole story comes out about Chris Brown and Rhianna. While I feel what he did was excessive, I'm still wondering what set him off like that?

Just "excessive?"
 
My dear it's simple.

Me and my boys used to play a game. Chestize. Men have different names for it around the country.

You hit me in the chest with all your might, THEN I hit you back with all my might, and we see who breaks.

A man and a woman playing chestize. Who's going to win?

:hmm:

No justification.

Gotta agree with Shane on this one.

As a dude, if you let a situation get to the point where a women goes at you physically then you've fucked up for starters which makes you a double loser.

The most (self) respectable thing you could do is to leave. Retaliating is a bitch move. Unless she comes at you with lethal force, in which case you have to defend yourself. Obviously.

But if it's just a weak ass female slap or punch or whatever ... big fucking deal. Now if a female slap fucks you up then you're a bitch anyway.

Remember that "how can she slap?" video. Dude slapped her back right after and i'm sure many of you were like "hell yeah!" But shortly after he got fucked the fuck up and his bitch side was exposed when he started crying like a bitch.

For you women on this thread advocating this justified dude hitting a woman shit I'm pretty sure you've never been fucked up by a dude before so pause with that academic shit.


1
 
If you pull a knife on the police and they shoot you, are they wrong?

Who would win? The knife or the gun?

If you know the other person has a gun, why attack them with the knife?


i don't want to intellectualize this, but that is a fitting analogy...
 
she hits u...u remove urself from the situation

she comes at u w/ somethin lethal...defend urself

defend urself does NOT mean pummel her...it means disarm or w/e and then bounce

and ppl laugh when i say this, call the cops on her ass. she wouldn't hesitate to have yo ass locked up...maybe she will keep her hands to herself next time

-but that varies from place to place...where i'm from, i've seen chics get locked up a lot for DV
 
she hits u...u remove urself from the situation

she comes at u w/ somethin lethal...defend urself

defend urself does NOT mean pummel her...it means disarm or w/e and then bounce

and ppl laugh when i say this, call the cops on her ass. she wouldn't hesitate to have yo ass locked up...maybe she will keep her hands to herself next time

-but that varies from place to place...where i'm from, i've seen chics get locked up a lot for DV


NO..

NO. DO NOT CALL THE POLICE...you do not have the upper hand EVER in a situation with a woman. I HAVE BEEN THERE...just leave. IF YOU CAN...just leave...There is a reason the police will tell the man of HIS house to go for a walk if he and his spouse are involved in a heated debate. Trust me, you will not be the happy party if you decide to trust the law, it is not on your side...


Y'all have GOT to stop talking out the side of your neck about situations like this...
 
The problem is because of the double standard that exists in our society, where we tend to value our girls more than our boys, especially our black boys. We teach boys not hit, but we sure don't teach girls not to hit boys either. We teach our boys to take it, walk away, but this is ABUSE if your woman constantly hits, she is manipulating the situation, and using the double standard to her advantage.

Men have less of an option, especially black men. How many brothas you know are going to tell anyone let alone the police that they are getting the shit beat of them by a woman? I know none. Mot men, especially black men, are not going to call the damn police, because they know, historically, what can potentially happen.

Yes men tend to be physically stronger than women, but women also tend to use more objects in an altercation than a male. And there are big tall gym going weight-lifting women out there, just as they are men who smaller and weaker in stature. I work at a domestic violence shelter, and yes most of the people we see are women, but there are statistics out there that say greater than 65% of domestic violence cases are initiated by WOMEN. Men get in trouble because they tend to use their fists as opposed to objects, consequently doing more visable damage. Yes 1 in 4 women get abused, and that is a problem, but there are abusive women, we just don't see it that way culturally. We will never know how many men are getting slapped kicked and punched, no matter how hard it might hurt it is still ABUSE, because there is a stigma that suggests if a man reports or complains of violence, he is a punk, should just walk away, or just take it. Yes, if you keep telling a man to just take and walk away, one day he might just flip out and go to town on your ass.

This is a systemic problem that needs to be addressed from both sides. Rihanna and Chris are both abusers in my eyes, and both need help
 
Last edited:
NO..

NO. DO NOT CALL THE POLICE...you do not have the upper hand EVER in a situation with a woman. I HAVE BEEN THERE...just leave. IF YOU CAN...just leave...There is a reason the police will tell the man of HIS house to go for a walk if he and his spouse are involved in a heated debate. Trust me, you will not be the happy party if you decide to trust the law, it is not on your side...


Y'all have GOT to stop talking out the side of your neck about situations like this...

umm guy...YOUR talking out the side of your neck about things you don't know about...take your own advice.

i said where I'M AT...we are NOT in the same place, not even in the same time zone, so kill that.

i have witnessed it personally in the streets and in academia so like i said in my original post, it VARIES due to location. :hmm: :rolleyes:
 
she hits u...u remove urself from the situation

she comes at u w/ somethin lethal...defend urself

defend urself does NOT mean pummel her...it means disarm or w/e and then bounce

and ppl laugh when i say this, call the cops on her ass. she wouldn't hesitate to have yo ass locked up...maybe she will keep her hands to herself next time

-but that varies from place to place...where i'm from, i've seen chics get locked up a lot for DV


just 4 da record...
 
No, the real question should be why do women feel they have the right to hit? Most females are hypocrites and they always seems to be able to justify hitting a guy who has not hit them. If a woman hits, she should be prepared to get hit. Hitting is pure disrespect anyways, now i am not saying you gotta hulk smash her, but be real:hmm:
 

As a dude, if you let a situation get to the point where a women goes at you physically then you've fucked up for starters which makes you a double loser.

The most (self) respectable thing you could do is to leave. Retaliating is a bitch move. Unless she comes at you with lethal force, in which case you have to defend yourself. Obviously.

But if it's just a weak ass female slap or punch or whatever ... big fucking deal. Now if a female slap fucks you up then you're a bitch anyway.

Remember that "how can she slap?" video. Dude slapped her back right after and i'm sure many of you were like "hell yeah!" But shortly after he got fucked the fuck up and his bitch side was exposed when he started crying like a bitch.

For you women on this thread advocating this justified dude hitting a woman shit I'm pretty sure you've never been fucked up by a dude before so pause with that academic shit.


1

This makes 100% sense to me

I hope I didn't sound like I was justifying a woman being hit ... I was only trying to be fair cuz some of these dudes make it seem like women comin' at them with knives every fuckin' day:smh:

I'm truly turned on by this post ... sexually ... seriously ... this is the sort of man mentallity I like
 
she hits u...u remove urself from the situation

she comes at u w/ somethin lethal...defend urself

defend urself does NOT mean pummel her...it means disarm or w/e and then bounce

and ppl laugh when i say this, call the cops on her ass. she wouldn't hesitate to have yo ass locked up...maybe she will keep her hands to herself next time

-but that varies from place to place...where i'm from, i've seen chics get locked up a lot for DV
NO..

NO. DO NOT CALL THE POLICE...you do not have the upper hand EVER in a situation with a woman. I HAVE BEEN THERE...just leave. IF YOU CAN...just leave...There is a reason the police will tell the man of HIS house to go for a walk if he and his spouse are involved in a heated debate. Trust me, you will not be the happy party if you decide to trust the law, it is not on your side...


Y'all have GOT to stop talking out the side of your neck about situations like this...

umm guy...YOUR talking out the side of your neck about things you don't know about...take your own advice.

i said where I'M AT...we are NOT in the same place, not even in the same time zone, so kill that.

i have witnessed it personally in the streets and in academia so like i said in my original post, it VARIES due to location. :hmm: :rolleyes:

just 4 da record...

yeah reading is fundamental...oh yeah just for the record :rolleyes:
 
yeah reading is fundamental...oh yeah just for the record :rolleyes:


You know what...i want to say you are right.


i have been a very painful situation, where i thought that calling the police would alleviate my problem, but it only caused it to escalate. i feel that men, especially black men, need to be very cautious of their dependence on the law. In some instances, it could be better for them to handle the situation on their own.
 
You know what...i want to say you are right.


i have been a very painful situation, where i thought that calling the police would alleviate my problem, but it only caused it to escalate. i feel that men, especially black men, need to be very cautious of their dependence on the law. In some instances, it could be better for them to handle the situation on their own.

Agreed 100%.

Black male in the United States hinging on the cops for support in any situation not to mention one pertaining to domestic violence ... not a good look.


If not immediately, you will eventually own yourself.

Until you're in a situation you will never truly know.

And no. Women aren't qualified to speak on this other than on some rhetorical academic shit.
 
Gotta agree with Shane on this one.

As a dude, if you let a situation get to the point where a women goes at you physically then you've fucked up for starters which makes you a double loser.

The most (self) respectable thing you could do is to leave. Retaliating is a bitch move. Unless she comes at you with lethal force, in which case you have to defend yourself. Obviously.

But if it's just a weak ass female slap or punch or whatever ... big fucking deal. Now if a female slap fucks you up then you're a bitch anyway.

Remember that "how can she slap?" video. Dude slapped her back right after and i'm sure many of you were like "hell yeah!" But shortly after he got fucked the fuck up and his bitch side was exposed when he started crying like a bitch.

For you women on this thread advocating this justified dude hitting a woman shit I'm pretty sure you've never been fucked up by a dude before so pause with that academic shit.


1


LOL @THE POLITICAL CORRECTNESS...

I bet Chris Brown was saying the same shit months ago or he would have answered the question the same way months ago.
 
are you an idiot?

633553695829349661-mad.jpg
 
If someone hits someone they are liable to be hit back. Period. Every action has a reaction. I belive a dude name newton spoke on it a while back. Something about it being a law.

*sidenote*
This " excessive" arguement is laughable. Its called the consequences of ones actions. If I put my hand on a stove, and it burns my hand do I blame the stove? Was the stove being excessive? No, the stove works fine. The real question is why the fuck did I put my hand on the stove if I'm old enough to know it could burn my ass! Women need to remember that.
*sidenote*


And the whole " any man who put his hands on a woman is a bitch and need to watch out for another dude to beat him up for it" is a pipe dream... There are men out there who will fuck you up (if physically provoked) and then fuck up the next man in a cape coming to save your ass from some shit YOU started. I have seen it first hand. Don't put to much stock in that "how can she slap" video.



In fact... Any woman who gets into a physicall altercation with a man and then BANK on another man to save her from some shit she started is a fool.



Morality what women are BANKING on doesn't always match reality. Everyone doesn't play by the "don't hit women rule"




Best bet would be to keep your hands to yourself... Ladies.


*two cents*
 
Last edited:
This makes 100% sense to me

I hope I didn't sound like I was justifying a woman being hit ... I was only trying to be fair cuz some of these dudes make it seem like women comin' at them with knives every fuckin' day:smh:

I'm truly turned on by this post ... sexually ... seriously ... this is the sort of man mentality I like

Ooooh, is Lonestar in e-love?!? I'm e-instigating... :lol::lol:
 
Gotta agree with Shane on this one.

As a dude, if you let a situation get to the point where a women goes at you physically then you've fucked up for starters which makes you a double loser.

The most (self) respectable thing you could do is to leave. Retaliating is a bitch move. Unless she comes at you with lethal force, in which case you have to defend yourself. Obviously.

But if it's just a weak ass female slap or punch or whatever ... big fucking deal. Now if a female slap fucks you up then you're a bitch anyway.

Remember that "how can she slap?" video. Dude slapped her back right after and i'm sure many of you were like "hell yeah!" But shortly after he got fucked the fuck up and his bitch side was exposed when he started crying like a bitch.



If someone hits someone they are liable to be hit back. Period. Every action has a reaction. I belive a dude name newton spoke on it a while back. Something about it being a law.

*sidenote*
This " excessive" arguement is laughable. Its called the consequences of ones actions. If I put my hand on a stove, and it burns my hand do I blame the stove? Was the stove being excessive? No, the stove works fine. The real question is why the fuck did I put my hand on the stove if I'm old enough to know it could burn my ass! Women need to remember that.
*sidenote*


And the whole " any man who put his hands on a women is a bitch and need to watch out for another dude to beat him up for it" is a pipe dream... There are men out there who will fuck you up (if physically provoked) and then fuck up the next man in a cape coming to save your ass from some shit YOU started. I have seen it first hand. Don't put to much stock in that "how can she slap" video.

In fact... Any women who gets into a physicall altercation with a man and then BANK on another man to save her from some shit she started is a fool.


Morality you women are BANKING on doesn't always match reality. Everyone doesn't play by the "don't hit women rule"

Best bet would be to keep your hands to yourself... Ladies.


*two cents*


I agree. For every action there's a reaction.

CB is still reacting ...

Your stove analogy is elementary.

A human interacting with an inanimate object. How novel. :hmm:

Obviously, a female that hits a dude does not know any better regardless of age or experience. That's why she hit the dude in the first place Einstein. People tend to do dumb shit. The gift and curse of free will.

And all i said was that the native quiescent bitchassness of dude that said "how can she slap?" was exposed upon his getting fucked the fuck up.

Fuck all this analysis. Simple experiment in reality. Start a fight with a woman and hit her ...
 
I agree. For every action there's a reaction.

CB is still reacting ...

Your stove analogy is elementary.

A human interacting with an inanimate object. How novel. :hmm:

Obviously, a female that hits a dude does not know any better regardless of age or experience. That's why she hit the dude in the first place Einstein. People tend to do dumb shit. The gift and curse of free will.

And all i said was that the native quiescent bitchassness of dude that said "how can she slap?" was exposed upon his getting fucked the fuck up.

Fuck all this analysis. Simple experiment in reality. Start a fight with a woman and hit her ...




1. Thank you for responding.:)

2. I know the stove analogy is elementary. That was the point. Don't hit anyone and then cry foul when they knock your ass out. Simple, like elementary. :hmm:

3. I am not supporting hit a woman. Im not in support of hitting ANYONE. I just refuse to side with anyone who refuses to be accountable for one's actions. You hit someone, they fuck you up, IT'S ON YOU.:hmm:

They teach that in elementary...


Once again, thank you for responding.


*two cents*
 
I'm not sure the infamous how can she slap model is totally scientific for this model. I believe she got what she deserved. Yes, he was kind of acting like a bitch afterwards, BUT there were also like 20 dudes jumping him.

Women are not stupid. They know that most men will not hit them back or that the law is on their side and they use this to their advantage. I will agree that if you got to go at a woman physically, then you shouldn't even deal with them. I have had a few women get out of pocket with me way back in high school and I wasn't even dating them or anything. They were having bad days. One of them I was even cool with and we were joking around and then she slapped me in the face on some punk shit.......well, Sir Isaac Newton happen to be near by and he told me about his law.
First off F=MA.....then
There was an opposite reaction
A small amount of energy was lost due to heat and exhaust
lasty.....she never tried to style on me like that ever again:p
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure the infamous how can she slap model is totally scientific for this model. I believe she got what she deserved. Yes, he was kind of acting like a bitch afterwards, BUT there were also like 20 dudes jumping him.

Women are not stupid. They know that most men will not hit them back or that the law is on their side and they use this to their advantage. I will agree that if you got to go at a woman physically, then you shouldn't even deal with them. I have had a few women get out of pocket with me way back in high school and I wasn't even dating them or anything. They were having bad days. One of them I was even cool with and we were joking around and then she slapped me in the face on some punk shit.......well, Sir Isaac Newton happen to be near by and he told me about his law.
First off F=MA.....then
There was an opposite reaction
A small amount of energy was lost due to heat and exhaust
lasty.....she never tried to style on me like that ever again:p



:lol:






Knowledge is power.:hmm:



*two cents*
 
.......well, Sir Isaac Newton happen to be near by and he told me about his law.
First off F=MA.....then
There was an opposite reaction
A small amount of energy was lost due to heat and exhaust
lasty.....she never tried to style on me like that ever again:p

:lol::lol::lol::lol:

Hilarious!

However, the force of the slap, F, must have been in an adiabatic environment since there was suppression of any chain reactions whereby the acceleration due to the gravity of your slap, A, wasn't transferred to the acceleration of yo ass, A', to jail by the police.

To satisfy Newtonian mechanics, it follows that M must have been negligible.

So to speak ...
 
I got a real life scenario on this one.

I know a dude. Pretty strong dude. Former linebacker in high school.

He had a girl. Really small girl. Like maybe 5'5" or something.

This girl used to BEAT THE SHIT out of this dude all the time. I mean she hit him with any and everything she could find. Pots, pans, broomsticks, mop handles...I think she picked up a tv one time (13") and slammed that shit on his head. She broke dudes arm with that damn TV. He NEVER hit her back. :smh:

His excuse. She was a woman. Her excuse. He's so much bigger than me that if I just hit him it won't hurt him so I need leverage. LEVERAGE. :smh:

One night she hit his ass square in the back of the head with a frying pan and while he was dazed she put a knife to his throat and told him she would kill him. I know because I was there when she did it. I grabbed her little ass before I could even think straight and flung her across the damn room. This nigga came to and was pissed off at ME! :eek:

I begged this nigga to leave that girl alone but all he would tell me was that she is a girl and it don't really hurt. I allow it because she is so much smaller than me. :angry:

Fuck that. I'm sorry. I used to think the same way as ya'll but... :smh: This is personal for me though because I knew about it but to be sitting there when it happened gave me a whole new perspective on that shit. :smh:
 
Back
Top