who is the greatest black quarterback in the nfl so far? THREAD FROM 2011... WHATS YOUR ANSWER NOW??

[Salty Nuts]

Warren Moon

 

[Black A. Camus]

wtf is that from?

I don't know, they were on ebaumsworld. I didn't mean to post those here--I forgot they were on my clipboard. I meant to add them to my photo book on another website.

 

[Jman23]

Doug Williams will always be one of my heroes no matter what list folks put him on. But if we're going to rank them behind Moon, how are we going to leave out the second black QB to win NFL (co) MVP?

Steve McNair
RIP#9

An Alcorn State (I-AA) legend who nearly won the damn Heisman! People don't understand how significant of an achievement that was. I absolutely HATED how Jeff Fisher neutered this man's game for so long with the Titans. Any other coach or team and Mac might have thrown for 40000 yards and won a ring. Still managed to take a team to the Super Bowl and led them to another AFC title game in 2002. Fisher hasn't won a playoff game since Mac left. And if I'm not mistaken, he has more playoff wins than any other black QB in history (5). Four time Pro Bowler.

Mac was the toughest QB in the NFL. Even Favre stated this. That man was beat up like a '74 Bonneville every week and played. He was quiet and that's why he never got the national love he deserved. And yes I recognize that people are going to judge him based on the terrible way he died, but they shouldn't. Loved what Williams, Cunningham, McNabb and others accomplished, but #9 gets the second spot.

And shout out to owner Bud Adams who wasn't afraid to have a black QB lead his team on multiple occasions (Moon, McNair, and even Vince Young).

Fisher is the most overrated piece of shit uneventive coach ever - run run and pass on third - as you said McNair and young...what could have been...he will be out of a job soon going against great minds in Carroll and harbaugh.

 

[silentking]

Fisher is the most overrated piece of shit uneventive coach ever - run run and pass on third - as you said McNair and young...what could have been...he will be out of a job soon going against great minds in Carroll and harbaugh.

 

[rltaz]

Doug Williams should be number 2 behind Warren Moon. What must people don’t know Williams was the only black starting quarterback in the league back in 1978. He took Tampa Bay from a non playoff team to the playoffs 3 years in a roll starting his second season. The owner did want to pay him and let him go and as everyone knows they never made it to the playoff again till 1997 over 14 years after Williams left the team. Back them being a black QB you couldn’t get a second start in the league.
1. Warren Moon
2. Doug Williams
3. Randal Cunningham
4. Steve McNair
5. Donavon McNabb

 

[geechiedan]

bump

 

[uptown93]

Can we gawtdamn see a football game? My famly has 7000 plus in ticket money for games we may not see...And I aint going if they aint got no Bands at that mofo....

 

[darius_janus]

I say Randal Cunningham fam. Man was a beast with the Eagles and Vikings.