who is the greatest black quarterback in the nfl so far? THREAD FROM 2011... WHATS YOUR ANSWER NOW??

Was it 42-10 or 55-10...I seen this game...pops still got it on VHS...damn I getting up their in age...niggas in this thread never seen Moon or Cunningham play


I saw it too..brought tears to my eyes....will never forget that game.

Not just black, but set record after record and was from a Black college too...shiiiiiiiiiiit....Grambling (Eddie Robinson)

At that time, AT THAT TIME.......:eek::eek::eek:
 
How can anybody put any other black QB above Doug Williams? Dude did something no other black QB has done and will not do for the next 5 years.
 
no love for this dude? first black qb to lead his team to a superbowl victory in a time where the ability for a black man to lead a team at the qb position was still debated by ofays :smh:



doug-williams-250x250.jpg




edit:geechidan beat me to it

:yes:
 
Warren Moon is a top 5 NFL QB not just black QB


Doug Williams that Super bowl man had Black men and White men across the country in unity.

Randall Cunningham was Vick before Micheal vick. Just crazy breathtaking plays every game.
 
Moon
McNabb
Cunningham
McNair
Williams
Vick

......all have good to great numbers and all lead teams deep into playoffs;)

My humble opinion
 
MOOOOOOOOOOON> all black QBs...

One of the BEST QBs ANY race!! His CFL & NFL numbers combined are crazy!

Doug would prolly get 2nd on the strength of the SB season...don't remember him lighting the league up the way Moon did, beside that...:hmm:

I'd have to think hard after that. I love McNabb, but it's like his skills didn't decrease...they just fell off, like a table..:smh: I don't get it.

this ain't easy to call..
 
Y'all young cats sleeping on Doug Williams

From wikipedia

The Bucs, who had never been to the playoffs before Williams arrived, went to the playoffs three times in four years and played in the 1979 NFC Championship Game. Williams improved his completion percentage each year with the Bucs, but was regarded as the heart and soul of the team, and the driving force behind the winning.
However, during his tenure in Tampa, Williams was only paid $120,000 a year—far and away the lowest salary for a starting quarterback in the league, and behind 12 backups.​
 
:yes::yes:I agree with this assessment...who's the one in the Hall?

Cam may re-write what being a QB is...kinda like a Randall 2.0.

Vick???....he is what he is,a highlight film...all sizzle,no steak.

This is the problem with a lot of people today, they like style over substance.

Slight correction, Moon is in BOTH Halls of Fame, CFL and NFL.

How can Williams be higher than a man voted into the Hall vs. White QBs?
 
Warren Moon makes my 10 ten list All-Time. He didn't do to bad for a guy who went undrafted and was told he should play tight end.
 
MOOOOOOOOOOON> all black QBs...

One of the BEST QBs ANY race!! His CFL & NFL numbers combined are crazy!

Doug would prolly get 2nd on the strength of the SB season...don't remember him lighting the league up the way Moon did, beside that...:hmm:

winning the Superbowl and mvp is a pretty big light up don't you think?? especially considering the long careers moon, cunningham and mcnair had they never accomplished that themselves.
 
How can anybody put any other black QB above Doug Williams? Dude did something no other black QB has done and will not do for the next 5 years.

You Must be Young.
Doug Williams Didn't Even START that Year
He played cause Jay Schroeder got Hurt. Just
so happens they won the Super Bowl with His great play
That Don't make Him the greatest Black QB of All Time...:hmm:
 
You Must be Young.
Doug Williams Didn't Even START that Year
He played cause Jay Schroeder got Hurt. Just
so happens they won the Super Bowl with His great play
That Don't make Him the greatest Black QB of All Time...:hmm:

youre right he shouldn't be number one...but he definitely deserves to be on the list (IMO top two)
 
youre right he shouldn't be number one...but he definitely deserves to be on the list (IMO top two)

Top Two? :lol:
So The First White Player to Win a Super
Bowl Should Be top two as well????
Doug Wiiliams Had Suspect Career Numbers
He is at best Top 10 Black QB's of all time
 
Top Two? :lol:
So The First White Player to Win a Super
Bowl Should Be top two as well????
Doug Wiiliams Had Suspect Career Numbers
He is at best Top 10 Black QB's of all time

show me another black QB with a ring?

williams has done what mnabb, mcnair, moon and every other black QB couldn't do and hasn't done so far and they didn't have the pressure of being the first to have to do it.

I mean at the end of the day winning a championship has to account for something. Think about it if Lebron never wins a championship would he or should be be considered in the same breath as Jordan, Kobe and Magic?
 
Randall cunningham by a very long shot.
Doug williams
and i have to hold judgement on the third, right now.
 
Of all time: moon

Doug Williams wasn't great, he just didn't fuck up that year.

Currently its Cam Newton. Vick fell off, Garrard aint in the league, Josh Freeman regressed, Jason Campbell was never good, Tavarris Jackson? pitiful. McNabb? shameful. Its been a really shitty year for black QBs
 
warren moon 5 straight cfl championships...most combine yards cfl/nfl b4 favre and dis other dude broke it...if bills don't make the greatest comeback ever in a afc championship moon mite have gotten dat nfl ring
 
Of all time: moon

Doug Williams wasn't great, he just didn't fuck up that year.

Currently its Cam Newton. Vick fell off, Garrard aint in the league, Josh Freeman regressed, Jason Campbell was never good, Tavarris Jackson? pitiful. McNabb? shameful. Its been a really shitty year for black QBs

come dude.."he just didn't fuck up that year.":rolleyes::rolleyes:

a person who just didn't fuck up that year doesn't win MVP..or perform one of the best halfs of a superbowl EVER. :rolleyes::rolleyes:
 
Back
Top