So this discussion just popped up on my facebook feed. Comments:
Multiple posters for this, not just two.
I think that’s a very reasonable proposal he presented. They are not married and while trying to help her he is trying to further his goals. If the relationship ends, they both are further in their goals. If the relationship flourishes, then they start making goals together and the proposed plan will change to support their goals as a couple on their way to marriage. Which after marriage, she should still be helping with bills if they are really in this together.
-all of this!!!
I am in a similar situation although because he lives in another city I opted to rent out my place to pay the mortgage (I didn’t rent I owned but I still have a mortgage) and I pay rent to him which is less than what I was paying but gives us both the ability to save since we aren’t married. What is the issue really???
--
people think men are supposed to be providers. Naturally they are, but we don’t know how long they’ve been in the relationship, it just says a while, and we don’t know how much his property tax is, repairs that need to be done, and if she wants to move there and eventually become his wife, why is this difficult to help with your potential future home? If they break up, you still saved way more money than at the old place.
I don’t see the problem. I shared expenses with my spouse.
--- the issue is I don’t sleep with my roommate! I can see splitting bills but why would I pay my man rent money when he has no mortgage? So he’s gonna stack his coins off of his woman?
----
he still has to pay property tax and keep the house up. We don’t know what all needs to be done. And even if that man is stacking the $800, she’s still saving from not being in her old place. She can stack too.
-----she can help with property taxes and repairs but to charge a rental amount and we are sleeping in the same bed
that’s a no for me. What happens when he gets pissed and puts her out? She loses and has no recourse while his bank account is stacked
------she would be saving nearly $2000 a month and he would be saving only half on the utilities.....he probably averaged it out so they could save the same each month (that’s what me and my man did) which I still don’t see the problem....win or lose every one wins!
-------
so maybe he said rent, but if that’s what it’s going towards what’s the issue? No one in or out of a relationship can just put someone out, there is a legal process and at that point, with all the money she’s saving from not living in the high rise at $2 k a month, she will be able to find something. I assume she’s good with money if she can afford that much a month lol. It’s sad we’re all in the mindset of them breaking up, but here’s the thing, the post says they think this is the logical next step for their relationship, so they weren’t thinking of breaking up, until this impass came. I’m all for being prepared for anything, but she can do this with him, keep up her savings, and like I said earlier, if they break up, she’s further in her goals and has something to fall back on, if they work, she helped take care of this home, and if they get married, maybe he puts her name on the deed. They’re are so many outcomes, and we’re only thinking about the one with them breaking up. It puts a limit on some many relationships and that ain’t right.
--------legal process or not! I’m not sleeping with someone who expects me to pay him rent on a paid off house! Let’s create a lease and I become your roommate and we can both save that way. But hey that’s why I’m not living with anyone that I’m not married to but that’s just me
--------
- He would be living free and saving at the same time...yes she would be saving money as well... to me she would be the man of the house with no security.
----------Now, you can’t live anywhere for free but to pay rent to your boyfriend when there is no mortgage I think it’s crazy... for all that she can downsize and save money.
-----------and she would be paying considerably less and saving as well....this way they are working together to both improve and that could do nothing but improve their relationship but if you have a single mindset then downsize and keep everything status quo.....it said they were progressing in their relationship so either progress or separate....
Pay it. She's saving a lot of money. Her rent was increasing to 2k alone. That doesn't include utilities.
- I totally agree. If she was to live in her high rise she would be paying double + some. That request is not unreasonable. She is not his wife they are living together.
She still saves and be with a man she loves and moving forward. I think she just lost a good man. You can't live anywhere free.
-but does he love her?
--maybe, idk. I would offer to pay even if he didn't ask but to each its own.
---what does love have to do with it? I see nothing wrong with what he is asking. She has to pay someone rent either way. If she moves in rent free, and they get married and buy a new home, would she also balk at splitting the mortgage and expenses?
Also more than two people:
If a man im DATING expects me to pay rent for HIS home that is paid off in addition to splitting bill, then I'll simply stay in my own space. If he was still paying a mortgage, different story. That's essentially paying him. I don't have a problem with splitting bills, I have a problem with my man, making a profit off of me.
- he is not her man and she is not his woman. I hope she realizes that now.
--that's my point. Don't hustle me like I'm somebody you just met in these streets. Like we not sleeping together.
---First line said they are dating
----I mean reverse the roles. If you were the owner of the house , will you let him live for FREE?. Remember you are not MARRIED.
----- agreed!
------not saying anything about staying for free But paying $800 and half utilities is BS!!!
-----
-- married people cheat, so what does dating or in a relationship actually mean? I don't think they've had that discussion. They are obviously not on the same page.
--------If that's my man, yes. House is paid for, so there's no need. There are plenty other bills he can pay for...like my car note
. If he OFFERS, I wouldn't turn it down, but I wouldn't charge him for it. If I sense that he wants to move in because has a hidden agenda to come up off me, I wouldn't even offer my home as an option. At the end of the day, he would save quicker to put that ring on my finger...which would be my preference and obviously the end goal.
She needs to pay. I would never (clutching my pearls) not offer something when I’m about to save some $. And I have too much pride to just take from someone I’m not married to. Pay up sis or better yet, get your own spot. That way- you don’t
get kicked out later. Lol
Y'all wild to think bc his mortgage is paid off that he shouldn't charge her rent. She's saying @least $1200 on rent alone. I don't know what her utilities are or what his are, but unless his egregious this is an acceptable/sensible proposal. This is why you don't tell ppl what position you're in.
There is also misunderstanding there about whether it is 800 total or 800+ expenses.
We are not married. We are dating, we are helping each other out by sharing the bills. There is nothing wrong in his proposal.
-except not only is he getting help with the bills he is also coming up off $800 from his girlfriend not his roommate whom is not gonna allow her to just do and bring whoever in his house but wants to treat like a tenant.
---But she is also saving $1000 each month. He won't be able to bring whoever he wants either out of respect. At the end the day they are still dating. And if he ever says the famous line "this is my house," that's her clue to break up the relationship and move out.
First her name isn't on the house so he will always have to pay taxes whether she's there or not in my opinion she should only contribute to utilities and subscribed entertainment bills.
-Exactly!!!! Is he going to pay her to clean up behind him. He he going to pay her to prepare his meals? What about coochie calls? All that costs money in the real world!!! Call Mollie Maid Service and look at that bill. Call a in home Chef that will go to the store and bring home to prepare in your kitchen. Oh he would pay royally. Not to mention the booty call stays in your bed? Oh hell no.
The majority of the women see no issue with it, yet BGOL would have y'all believe all the women want to do is take advantage of the man. There are almost 800 comments on this post and it says it was posted 3 hours ago...