I AGREE with EVERY POINT...
but too say that the show is becoming wack because it centers on the main character makes no sense...
The reason ALL of these shows were considered great and classic is because of the anchors of the show, these anti-heroes...
And the OUTSTANDING ACTORS who portray them...
The sopranos become "wack" because the writers got bored and were reading so much of their own press and tried to make it "deeper"" then it was ..
and OBVIOUSLY never thought of an ending.
The Wire is one of the best (if not the best) because it was TRULY a novel and had a beginning and a middle and end with shifting leads and story arcs that were extraordinarily well thought out and performed.
Breaking Bad much like Mad Men, the Shield, The Wire touched a nerve with the public because at there core we can identify with the message ...
EVERY MAN who has been out of work or is stuck in a shitty job can identify with Walt...
We all WANT to be GUS but we identify with Walt...
We all wish secretly were were Vic in The Shield and cool like Don Draper...
but we identify with their weaknesses and darkness.
I actually cheered for Walt and was disappointed in JESSE for not being more loyal...
Because I can identify with Walt's plights with the economy and family and cancer and not Jesse a privileged white kid who squandered it on meth.
But I STILL agree with all your points...
And although I loved it Sopranos WAS OUTSTANDING...
but doesn't age well and is overrated.
I think Deadwood will be more appreciated over time as a MUCH slept on series.
I gotta finish
Deadwood. It lost me a bit after they killed Wild Bill. That was my favorite character. I also hear they didn't give
Deadwood a proper ending. Show got canceled. They said they would give it a movie or something to end it. And it hasn't happened yet.
So far for me I see the shows I've watched as follows
The Sopranos: Great first three seasons. Last two fell off a bit. They brought in Furio as a total badass. Then he leaves for a stupid reason. Tony does his dumb dream sequences.
The Wire: First three seasons I rate as the best television I've ever watched. The way they moved from the cops, to the politicians, to the port and the unions was great. The school system and journalism wasn't bad. But I like Avon and Stringer much better than Marlo and his crew. Stringer Bell was one of the best villains on television. Avon I actually liked. He was a dealer, but he had some morals. Marlon was a mad dog and mad dog's get put down quick, even by other dealers. They don't walk away clean like Marlo. I gotta give them props for making a gay anti-hero I actually liked in Omar.
The Shield: I thought this show did the best job of creating a cohesive storyline that carried from the first episode of season 1 to the last episode of season 7. No series tied everything together better than
The Shield. All the shit the Strike Team had done from the first epsiode season one to everything inbetween like robbing the Armenian money train, Shane killing Lem, Shane trying to sell Vic out, Aceveda sucking dick, and the like were all tied together in the last season and the last few episodes. The Strike Team fell hard for their corruption with Vic selling everyone out to save his own ass and losing his family, Shane cracking and doing himself and his family, and Ronnie heading to prison. That was the type of ending you believe even though it wasn't happy at all.
Breaking Bad: Interesting character study seeing how a regular guy like Walt goes from cancer stricken, desperate man to ruthless, cruel, do anything to survive drug dealer.
Breaking Bad is
Scarface with a suburban white male as the lead and his cancer, rather than abject poverty, being the reason he goes down the path he does. But he's still acting just like
Scarface. Looking at his situation like some kind of game of him versus his enemies to see who is king of the hill and who can survive. There's certain moral lines he won't cross and he's utterly loyal to his family and Jesse like
Scarface was loyal to his sister and Manny until Manny fucked his sister.
So I'm going to keep watching. I hope the writers stick with the plan and Walt goes down like Scarface. That's how it's gotta happen. It doesn't have to go down exactly like Scarface. But as far as the overall effect where a bunch of people are brutally destroyed including Walt and his family is how I see this shit going down. I hope the writers pay off my time. I don't want no happy, sitting in the diner, there might be a movie ending. That'll be weak.