If They Don't Get Injured, Who Has The Better Career: G. Hill or Penny?

[Better]

Title explains the thread. Don't forget to vote.

 

[Mr. Met]

Grant Hill.

 

[34real]

G.Hill

 

[crazyace718]

Hill by a landslide.

 

[4 Dimensional]

Hill was great talent and a stat filler. Without injury he may have put up Lebron like numbers. Hill by a landslide.

 

[DWBass]

Hill was on his way to being a G.O.A.T. Penny may have been there too.

 

[yaBoi]

yall crazy

penny had all time great talent

grant would have been scotty pipen

 

[Powerforwardofthesquad]

Hill clearly didn't want to play for Detroit, and it showed. For that, his name is mud in my book...except for fine ass Tamia.

 

[playahaitian]

Grant Hill

 

[spider705]

hill was an absolute MONSTER!

 

[Coldchi]

Grant Hill.....

 

[tonydons2]

Only one of these dudes had a reputation of being great and clutch in the playoffs

 

[APOPHIS]

Grant had the potential to be one of the greatest of all time.
Injuries robbed him of a legendary NBA career for a slightly above decent one.

What could have been...

 

[Amajorfucup]

grant would have been scotty pipen

Stop posting.

 

[Mr. Bizkits]

Penny was at his pinnacle when he had Shaq. If Shaq stayed in Orlando, Penny could've been greater than Magic Johnson.

Penny.

 

[daking181]

yall crazy

penny had all time great talent

grant would have been scotty pipen

And Pippen is top 50. So your point is.......

 

[mozartte]

IMO, Penny Hardaway. Dude created all kinds of mismatches.

 

[Built4Life]

Penny was at his pinnacle when he had Shaq. If Shaq stayed in Orlando, Penny could've been greater than Magic Johnson.

Penny.

People forget how great Penny was. Both would have been all time greats if injury didn't hit them. Shaq and Penny would have won multiple chips easily.
I call it a push.

 

[yaBoi]

And Pippen is top 50. So your point is.......

did say he wasn't

penny would have been magic or Jordan level..........hell even Jordan said it. i'll take his opinion over y'all

grant would not have been...y'all need to watch some highlights

 

[theteacher]

I say Grant, cuz being young and healthy
Penny still couldn't get a ring
LOL​

 

[fwillia]

Hard to say.

 

[Mr. Bizkits]

We could all make the same argument for Latrell Sprewell.

 

[Ill Paragraph]

Peace,

People forget how great Penny was. Both would have been all time greats if injury didn't hit them. Shaq and Penny would have won multiple chips easily. I call it a push.

This. Cats must be out of their minds, acting as if Grant was easily better than Penny. Shit is close.

 

[IT IS WHAT IT IS]

Grant Hill. More complete player

 

[Better]

Grant Hill. More complete player

How?

Penny was one of those rare players who was a big-time scorer, who was a true PG.

 

[JimJones]

Afernee

 

[Amajorfucup]

We could all make the same argument for Latrell Sprewell.

Stop posting.

 

[Mr. Bizkits]

Stop posting.

He was all-NBA also... He was never the same after Golden State

 

[Better]

Sprewell had one dunk, and that nigga tried to take out all his personal problems on the rim with the same dunk.

 

[Spectrum]

How?

Penny was one of those rare players who was a big-time scorer, who was a true PG.

Do this. Go back and look at Penny's stats. Forget about his name and just go look at his stats.

 

[Spectrum]

Penny was at his pinnacle when he had Shaq. If Shaq stayed in Orlando, Penny could've been greater than Magic Johnson.

Penny.

In his best season, he averaged 7.2 assists per game. Magic averaged more than DOUBLE the amount of assists per game as Penny.

 

[Spectrum]

How?

Penny was one of those rare players who was a big-time scorer, who was a true PG.

Better scorer, rebounder, and defender...and actually his best year is higher than Penny's best year for assists.

 

[Spectrum]

Grant was an SG who nearly averaged 10 boards per game in a season. He was a mini-Lebron.

 

[Mr. Bizkits]

In his best season, he averaged 7.2 assists per game. Magic averaged more than DOUBLE the amount of assists per game as Penny.

Agreed.

There's no telling how high Penny could've advanced if Shaq stayed in Orlando.

 

[World B Free]