Hypothetical: Would Knicks management/fans trade Amare & Melo for LeBron?

nah...amar'e is a gamechanger at pf... imagine if the heat had signed him instead of bosh, they'd be impossible to beat. And melo is the best natural scorer in the game, with lebron u need expensive parts to make a successful run with melo and amar'e we get a solid center and solid pg play and keep the bench ok we can do some damage.
 
yeah I would. its been proven over and over again that the best player in the NBA tends to win the most. Kobe, Shaq, Jordan, Magic, etc. Wilt is probably the only exception and some would argue Russell was better.
 
yeah I would. its been proven over and over again that the best player in the NBA tends to win the most. Kobe, Shaq, Jordan, Magic, etc. Wilt is probably the only exception and some would argue Russell was better.

those best players teams were also loaded with all star help
 
"with lebron u need expensive parts to make a successful run"???????
did u see that cavs team?
and no two great players are better than one exceptional one.
 
No but I would take 3 Knick starters named Gallo, Chandler and Felton for Melo any day of the week.:cool:
 
Peace,

The Knicks need another coach. That run and gun shit isn't going to win you any championships.

Now that that's out of the way, why would anyone trade two all stars for one? LeBron hasn't won anything yet.
 
"with lebron u need expensive parts to make a successful run"???????
did u see that cavs team?
and no two great players are better than one exceptional one.

do u see the cavs after lebron left? overpriced low value players and history making failure.

did u see the cavs with lebron tryin to desperately get everyone and still not winning a title.
i'll take 2 superstars over 1, even if its lebron
 
based on what?

based on his comments after a losing streak....

his play on the court.....

and I remember the game Mozgov came off the bench....Amare was talking to him trying to build his confidence....

Mozgov drop a double double that night.....he has been a good leader so far.....

and with Anthony now on the team I still see him as the leader of the team....
 
As great as Lebron is, amare and Melo as a team is better.

However I would trade amare and Melo for Lebron and Bosh.
 
man...amare is a fucking problem. after watching this game I think this cat might come out of this generation as the #1 big man. Dwight is a beast but he can't dominate the end of games like Amare can. I haaaate the knicks but I can see the team with Amare + Melo + Billups winning a championship.
 
Lebron > melo and amare

Knock it off man

Lebron been to the finals and back to back best records in the league.

Them other 2 niggas ain't seen none of that.

Hell melo been out the first round once.

Donnie walsh would do that in a heartbeat
 
I wouldn't trade Both of those dudes for Lebron but niggas getting out of hand talking about Amare better than Bron... Now thats a dude that literally hasn't done shit on multiple talented teams. Niggas let one game hype them up.
 
I wouldn't trade Both of those dudes for Lebron but niggas getting out of hand talking about Amare better than Bron... Now thats a dude that literally hasn't done shit on multiple talented teams. Niggas let one game hype them up.
FJP, you're losing it man.

Who in this thread said Amare was a better player?

One person said Amare is a better LEADER. And most everyone else saying Melo and Amare TOGETHER is better than Lebron alone- which isn't an over the top comment.
 
Hell no. 'Melo is a top 5 player, the best closer in the NBA besides Kobe, and has the best in and out game in the NBA. Amare is a top 10 player and one of the best finishers in the NBA. Lebron with all his hype has the same amount of rings as everyone on this board and he's been in the NBA 8 years. Even with D Wade and Bosh on his team the Heat have a worse record than his Cavs had at the same point last year. They can't beat any of the elite teams in the NBA consistently. I'll take Melo and Amare because they have a better shot winning a chip than just Lebron and scrubs. Bron might be the best player in the NBA skills wise but he has proven time and time again that he chokes in the clutch and lacks leadership skills.
 
nah...amar'e is a gamechanger at pf... imagine if the heat had signed him instead of bosh, they'd be impossible to beat. And melo is the best natural scorer in the game, with lebron u need expensive parts to make a successful run with melo and amar'e we get a solid center and solid pg play and keep the bench ok we can do some damage.

Peace,

Bron took a bunch of absolute scrubs to the Finals. Melo has never come close to that with much better supporting casts. :cool:
 
Back
Top