Where Does Lebron Rank All-Time For You As Of Today?

Where does Lebron Rank?


  • Total voters
    132
  • Poll closed .
1. Jordan
2. Kareem
3. Magic
4. Wilt
5. Larry
6. Dream
7. Shaq
8. Lebron
9. Kobe
10. Somebody great, but I'm too tired to think.
 
I'm giving him top 5 after what he accomplished in the playoffs. No player has ever led in every category. That's leaving your mark.
 
Because he saved a struggling town, fuck the rings, he is GOAT. He didnt need the money. He wanted to put his city on the map. Jordan aint from Chi. Lebron paying for college tuition and Jordan investing in prisons. He carried a team and be the best team and came from a deficit no team has done.

I definitely understand what you're saying... but Michael Jordan never invested in prisons.
 
People act like Kareem which JUST ANOTHER NBA legend. That's because the NBA hype machine didn't chose him to push. But as they say, men and women lie ... but them numbers and accolades do not....
Why isn't Russell on your list then
 
1. Jordan
2. Kareem
3. Magic
4. Wilt
5. Larry
6. Dream
7. Shaq
8. Lebron
9. Kobe
10. Somebody great, but I'm too tired to think.

The Dream and Shaq ahead of LeBron? Really?

You wrote alot about stat stuffing but you got Wilt at 4?

Im too tired to list all these dudes weaknesses... maybe tomorrow.
 
....and while Kobe is my favorite player ever, I picked Lebron over him for no reason other than efficiency. Kobe fired very indiscriminately and very frequently. Be it one minute into the first quarter, or one minute left in the 4th, Kobe would take a fall-away, triple pump fake jumper over two defender like it was a good shot. Like I tell people, I'm surprised his FG% was what it was. Too erratic, tho'.. Also, I feel he was a very underrated passer, but Kobe didn't help himself with that perception of him with his gunning.

I wish I could give Kobe's Lebron concern for efficiency. Maybe not to that same extreme, because the one thing that endeared Kobe to me was his unpredictable nature - but there was a way to dial it down and still be exciting.
 
Last edited:
Do you realize that James actually plays the point, not some fake point like Irving and Curry, but a true point.... Now tell me in the history of the sport how many points have scored as much as he has, win as many games, MVP's, championships, have his rebounds, while playing for as little talent as he has played in his career????
He's always played the point because he is a control freak who refuses to relinquish control of the point position. Now, Kyrie is a too short 2 guard, not a point guard. He has the handles for the position, but not the desire to assist. LeBron plays the point in Cleveland largely because Kyrie is inept at handling the task (never seen a GOOD PG with as many 1-2 assist complete games as Kyrie). Since HS he's always had the ball in his hands. Always.

It takes balls and skill to say, "LeBron, this is my position. I got you. Go over there." I've seen Mo Williams do it, but haven't seen any other PG he played with do it, and believe me, if Mo had the talent that Kyrie has LeBron either would not be playing point or he'd be pouting like a bitch.
 
Russell played with the most stacked teams ever, and shot 44 percent from the FG as a post player. Those rings, to me, are very overrated because he had way more help than anybody else, and a legendary post-player should never have the same FG percentage for the career as Kobe: A guard, with little to no concern for efficiency.
 
1. Jordan
2. Kareem
3. Magic
4. Wilt
5. Larry
6. Dream
7. Shaq
8. Lebron
9. Kobe
10. Somebody great, but I'm too tired to think.
No way Larry is better than LeBron, Magic is great but he played on some of the best teams in the history of the NBA, and other than assist his personal numbers are no where near James, Wilt track record vs Russel is disturbing and had most of his numbers padded playing in a era filled of women, Dream had two great seasons, same two years Jordan was out, coincident, tell me, Shaq got housed by a smaller Piston team while he played on a team full of superstars... My top ten is Jordan, Russel, LeBron, Magic, Kareem, Wilt, Duncan, Oscar, Kobe and Bird...
 
He's always played the point because he is a control freak who refuses to relinquish control of the point position. Now, Kyrie is a too short 2 guard, not a point guard. He has the handles for the position, but not the desire to assist. LeBron plays the point in Cleveland largely because Kyrie is inept at handling the task (never seen a GOOD PG with as many 1-2 assist complete games as Kyrie). Since HS he's always had the ball in his hands. Always.

It takes balls and skill to say, "LeBron, this is my position. I got you. Go over there." I've seen Mo Williams do it, but haven't seen any other PG he played with do it, and believe me, if Mo had the talent that Kyrie has LeBron either would not be playing point or he'd be pouting like a bitch.
Who would you rather play point??? Wade, Chalmers, Irving, JR, Shumpert, Allen, help me give me some names.....
 
Nobody in the history of the NBA has ever done more with less than LeBron....#NoDebatingFact
 
1. Jordan
2. Kareem
3. Magic
4. Wilt
5. Larry
6. Dream
7. Shaq
8. Lebron
9. Kobe
10. Somebody great, but I'm too tired to think.

The Dream and Shaq ahead of LeBron? Really?

You wrote alot about stat stuffing but you got Wilt at 4?

Im too tired to list all these dudes weaknesses... maybe tomorrow.
If Shaq had shot the paltry numbers that LeBron does from the line, 73%, he would have been un-fucking-stopable. IDK how much it knocks him down in my eyes, but it does knock him down a peg or two.

I'm spoiled. I grew up in Cleveland with Mark Price. He said, "My dad always told me, 'It's just you and the rim. That's it. Nobody else in the gym matters. Not the players, not the fans'." Price shot 90% and I think his brother did, too, or close. It's the easiest part of the game that Shaq never eally seemed to want to. I bet you that if Jordan had a Grand Canyon-sized hole in his game like that it would be fixed by the 2nd summer if not the first summer after it was pointed out. But Jordan was dat dude. That motherfucker would make the Titanic impervious to water AND icebergs.
 
You can call that motherfucker all you want, I ain't getting into a debate with that nigga about no damn Lebron James. Fuck all the way outta here.
You know how retarded this sounds coming from the person who created this topic in the first place...:smh:
 
Who would you rather play point??? Wade, Chalmers, Irving, JR, Shumpert, Allen, help me give me some names.....
You are right. He didn't HAVE anybody...but maybe he wanted it that way. Motherfuckers don't like to invite competition to their position. I know it's another sport, but one football player said he only looked at ONE THING after the NFL Draft..."did they draft someone in my position. No? Then I don't give a shit."
 
I didn't address this thread to KingT - I addressed it to BGOL. He can comment, and vote, but I have no interest in debating Lebron James with anyone who gave Lebron his own unique nickname.

I'm not even interested in debating you. I remember you neglecting to go to sleep that night the Heat lost Game 1 of the Finals that year against the Spurs. You were like a crazed man trying to convince us that the A/C going out was a conspiracy to slow down Lebron. You was in that motherfucker defending Lebron looong after everyone had gone to sleep. I got up 6 or something, and you was still at it.

It may be outside the realm of your ability to understand why I wouldn't want to engage in a debate with you about Lebron, but some things just don't make sense to do.
 
You are right. He didn't HAVE anybody...but maybe he wanted it that way. Motherfuckers don't like to invite competition to their position. I know it's another sport, but one football player said he only looked at ONE THING after the NFL Draft..."did they draft someone in my position. No? Then I don't give a shit."
Do you know how wild what you just typed sounds??? Even if he didn't want talent around him so that he could shine, were true, for him to win as many games as he did, with that little talent and still get it done, would make him even better than where I placed him...
Dude trust me, he nor anyone who has ever played is that great...
Don't believe me next time you play pick up ball, delibratly choose the biggest scrubs on your squad, and try to be the start at everything, then tell me how that works out for you..
 
Question, why are threads like this always started by LeBron haters who get upset when things don't turn out the way they wanted to... Especially when actual stats and numbers get thrown around..
 
You know how retarded this sounds coming from the person who created this topic in the first place...:smh:

I didn't address this thread to KingT - I addressed it to BGOL. He can comment, and vote, but I have no interest in debating Lebron James with anyone who gave Lebron his own unique nickname.

I'm not even interested in debating you. I remember you neglecting to go to sleep that night the Heat lost Game 1 of the Finals that year against the Spurs. You were like a crazed man trying to convince us that the A/C going out was a conspiracy to slow down Lebron. You was in that motherfucker defending Lebron looong after everyone had gone to sleep. I got up 6 or something, and you was still at it.

It may be outside the realm of your ability to understand why I wouldn't want to engage in a debate with you about Lebron, but some things just don't make sense to do.

:popcorn:
 
I didn't address this thread to KingT - I addressed it to BGOL. He can comment, and vote, but I have no interest in debating Lebron James with anyone who gave Lebron his own unique nickname.

I'm not even interested in debating you. I remember you neglecting to go to sleep that night the Heat lost Game 1 of the Finals that year against the Spurs. You were like a crazed man trying to convince us that the A/C going out was a conspiracy to slow down Lebron. You was in that motherfucker defending Lebron looong after everyone had gone to sleep. I got up 6 or something, and you was still at it.

It may be outside the realm of your ability to understand why I wouldn't want to engage in a debate with you about Lebron, but some things just don't make sense to do.
The only thing I pointed about about the A.C. was that it was a old Boston Celtic trick, that they used to beat the Lakers,.. Folks here, especially the younger ones doubted me assuming I was lying when in actuality the Cetlics admitted to doing it... I never said it was done on purpose, I said, go back to the tread and read again, that the only other time I can recall this shit happening was that Boston game, where the home team wound up slowing down the quicker Lakers team with the old A.C. trick...
I just said it was suspicious especially knowing it happened before...
Say what you want, every thing I said that day was 100% facts..
 
Do you know how wild what you just typed sounds??? Even if he didn't want talent around him so that he could shine, were true, for him to win as many games as he did, with that little talent and still get it done, would make him even better than where I placed him...
Dude trust me, he nor anyone who has ever played is that great...
Don't believe me next time you play pick up ball, delibratly choose the biggest scrubs on your squad, and try to be the start at everything, then tell me how that works out for you..
Honestly, bruh. I'm a football guy. You ask me to diagram a zone blitz, a post corner route, or the Jerry Rice slant and I got you all day. Basketball I don't always understand what I am seeing. I know he dribbles the air out of the ball waving everybody off, which causes his teammates to stand around half the time with their thumb up their asses. I know he's not a great jump shooter, or 3 point shooter, but he wants to be REAALLY really bad. I also know that he doesn't submit to coaching because thinks he knows every damned thing. Maybe he did know more than a coach or two in his past, but as Iverson said as he was doing the HOF rounds, "I wish I would have listened to Larry Brown." LeBron, if he's honest will have a similar revelation.

He's a great player. I am not doubting that. But he could be so much greater, like Shaq if he's learned to shoot 70% from the line. Jordan was an above average player with Legendary work ethic. That turned a skinny boy into a player who would not be denied. Not saying he's Rudy, but what he had was HONED, it wasn't natural (I'm gonna get a lot of flack, but the logic is sound if you think about it).

 
If Shaq had shot the paltry numbers that LeBron does from the line, 73%, he would have been un-fucking-stopable. IDK how much it knocks him down in my eyes, but it does knock him down a peg or two.

I'm spoiled. I grew up in Cleveland with Mark Price. He said, "My dad always told me, 'It's just you and the rim. That's it. Nobody else in the gym matters. Not the players, not the fans'." Price shot 90% and I think his brother did, too, or close. It's the easiest part of the game that Shaq never eally seemed to want to. I bet you that if Jordan had a Grand Canyon-sized hole in his game like that it would be fixed by the 2nd summer if not the first summer after it was pointed out. But Jordan was dat dude. That motherfucker would make the Titanic impervious to water AND icebergs.

With me its not his free throw shooting. Its the laziness. Phil got Shaq right for a few years. Beyond that Shaq didnt give a fuck. Him and Kobe should have had ten rings together. Shaq could have had more MVPs then Kareem. He just didnt care. ALL of his numbers SHOULD have been better.

Hakeem is my favorite center of all time. He missed the playoffs in his prime. Think about that. Hakeem was a beast one on one but he couldnt pass so offensively he was a black hole for a majority of his career. He peaked at the perfect time (MJ retired) and he could claim he was the best center of his era, but his career just doesnt match up. The Rockets were not consistently contenders and often got embarrassed in the playoffs.In the same number of years, forgetting team accomplishments, Hakeem has 6 all-nba first team and James has 10.
 
Because he saved a struggling town, fuck the rings, he is GOAT. He didnt need the money. He wanted to put his city on the map. Jordan aint from Chi. Lebron paying for college tuition and Jordan investing in prisons. He carried a team and be the best team and came from a deficit no team has done.

This post is so ridiculous its hilarious..... Saved a city :roflmao:
 
With me its not his free throw shooting. Its the laziness. Phil got Shaq right for a few years. Beyond that Shaq didnt give a fuck. Him and Kobe should have had ten rings together. Shaq could have had more MVPs then Kareem. He just didnt care. ALL of his numbers SHOULD have been better.

Hakeem is my favorite center of all time. He missed the playoffs in his prime. Think about that. Hakeem was a beast one on one but he couldnt pass so offensively he was a black hole for a majority of his career. He peaked at the perfect time (MJ retired) and he could claim he was the best center of his era, but his career just doesnt match up. The Rockets were not consistently contenders and often got embarrassed in the playoffs.In the same number of years, forgetting team accomplishments, Hakeem has 6 all-nba first team and James has 10.
I totally agree with you about Shaq's laziness. That's the main thing that pissed off Kobe. Like, "Motherfucker TRY." You are right, he should have been better. Shaq with 80% from the line? Oh My FUCKING GAWD!
 
Hakeem Olajuwon made it to the Finals very early in his career, then years later when Mike retired.

What does that tell me? If he had been surrounded with the right pieces, he would have contended more. Those two rings mean a lot, even if Mike wasn't around. He wasn't teamed up with multiple All-Stars, yet did a back to back? Look at how competitive the West was back then when he was winning and when he wasn't.

All rings are not created equal in my world.

That's to say nothing of the fact that, he retired top 10 in points, rebounds, blocks, and STEALS. Nobody has EVER done that. EVER. Not only that, but dude offensive skills were ridiculous.

I remember a session of Open Court, and the way the players talked about him, you could tell that they regarded him more highly than most fans did, and thats because they actually had to play him. No one can do it alone, but what all he brought to the table individually, we ain't gon' see that again for awhile.
 
Russell played with the most stacked teams ever, and shot 44 percent from the FG as a post player. Those rings, to me, are very overrated because he had way more help than anybody else, and a legendary post-player should never have the same FG percentage for the career as Kobe: A guard, with little to no concern for efficiency.
Russell is the most overrated player EVER. I get that he helped to break through racial barriers, and that should be applauded. But damn if his offensive game wasn't horrible by any standards. At 6'9" and with his length, he should have been shooting 60 percent back then(especially before Wilt came on the scene). Watching him play on the offensive side of the floor will make your eyes bleed. :smh:

He has some nice numbers because of PACE. Players were just chucking up shots back then and weren't nearly as good as shooters(on average) as today's players. Damn, he was shooting 45 percent in the late 50s before Wilt came into the league playing against slow cacs.:smh: Seriously, what big man shoots 45 percent and gets to be all-time great?

In the NBA of the 80s through today, Bill Russell probably averages 10-12 pts per game and somewhere around 12 rebounds. He's a great defensive player, but is lack of offense disqualifies him from being up there with a lot of other players.

Bill just has a lot of respeck on his name from the great Celtic squads Red put together. Red only cared about winning and helped break racial barriers. Celtics had the first black starting five. That was in the age of racial quotas.

As for Lebron, he is top 5 right now. Not only has he lead 2 final winning teams(the heat teams) in points, rebounds, and assists. He came back with the Cavs and lead BOTH teams in every major category. Sheer fucking dominance. :eek:
 
I have him Top 10 based on accomplishments, stats, and unique size and strength at his position.

He will have never be top 5 to me, because he lacks a lot of basic skills, no go-to moves, and no killer instinct. His basketball IQ is overrated. If he was not one of the most athletic players ever, and did not have his height and strength, he would be considered an average to below average player.

He really does not do anything, skill-wise, very well. He has not mastered anything on the offensive end.


hows your new gig going skip?
 
Top 10 to 15, though I can live with top 10.

Lebron is a great physical talent, but I noticed some things about him over the years that makes it impossible for me to put him above other players all-time.

1. When teams close the lanes on Lebron, he falls apart offensively. Unless he has confidence in his jumper - which he often doesn't have enough of - if he can't drive, he has nothing to offer scoring wise, outside of transition baskets. GS made it difficult for him to drive in the earlier part of their series, and he looked like an average offensive player. The moment they laxed on defense, and those lanes opened him, he ate them for lunch.

I've seen other teams do this as well, and it was the same results. Every now and again, he'll get into 'Fuck it' mode, and take that jumper, and if he's hitting it, then you're pretty fucked up. But, more often than not, that just doesn't seem to be the case.

You can't be a top 5 player, as a perimeter player, if closing lanes is enough to make you a nobody on the court offensively.

2. Lebron compiles stats in other areas, but that doesn't impress me, because all that takes from a talented player is effort. Westbrook, for instance, suddenly started playing that same style and now his numbers have jumped. I always thought he was an overrated passer, though he is a good passer. He rebounds well, but nothing unusual for a player his height. For instance, Larry Bird averaged double-digit rebounds for the career, but Lebron, despite being around the same height, and faaaar more athletic, never averaged double-digit rebounds for a season. But, Lebron runs around the court, doing everything .... all the while, he'll completely disappear near the end of games. I've seen it a hundred and one times: Lebron will have 39, 15, and 12 ... not show-up at all - meaning, not even take a damn shot in some cases- they lose, and his fans will say, 'It wasn't his fault, look at his stats!"

Lebron to me is a stat stuffer. Its almost as if he feels, if he piles up a bunch of stats, but don't show up when he needs to, people will overlook him not showing up at the end of the game, because he was so statistically productive.

I see you, Lebron. Yes, it takes a very talented player to put up numbers, but I've seen players who aren't considered all-around like Lebron, put up all-around numbers very similar to him when they chose to. Michael Jordan had a 32, 8, and 8 season, despite his career rebound and assist numbers not being close to that. Jordan had back to back 120-plus block seasons, despite never crossing 100 again. It was during the time he wanted to prove he could play great defense. As I said, effort.

3. You picked your teammates, and yet you aren't' running the table? You beat OKC. Cool. You almost lost to the Spurs TWICE. Lost to a Dallas time that he shouldn't have. Lost to GS, but I can overlook that. Point is, for someone who has picked his teams, thinking it'd give him the overwhelming advantage - i.e. Not 1, not 2, not 3, not 4, not 5, not 6 - his winning percentage in the Finals just ain't cutting it.

Furthermore, if you're going to pick your All-Star teammates, you shouldn't be barely winning. You should be killing motherfuckers. Isn't your greatest attribute that you make your teammates better, but you've had two All-Stars as third options - Bosh and Love - and yet all thwo were less effective playing with you? Maybe they can't put up the same numbers with you and the second option, but they certainly shouldn't become shell's of themselves.


So, yeah ... to me, Lebron is a lot of smoke and mirrors. If you take him at face value, he can look top 5. But, its just ..... I don't take his shit at face value. There hasn't been a top 5 player in the NBA since Jordan retired.
who do you have over him and have all of them been to six straight finals and carry a bum team to the NBA Finals by themselves?
 
Back
Top