The Bulls made a strong presentation and Anthony was intrigued, but it always was considered a long shot. Even after Anthony was hosted by the Bulls, associates close to him estimated the Bulls chances less than 50/50.
That’s because of the substantial difference in potential salary between the Knicks’ ability to offer about $125 million over five years and the Bulls closer to $75 million over four. Though the narrative was depicted as Anthony going for on court success or off court riches, Anthony was said to be equally concerned about making a long term commitment to the Bulls given the injury histories of Derrick Rose and Noah. Anthony saw his chances with the Knicks limited with injury to Amar’e Stoudemire. Plus, the addition of Phil Jackson to the front office, some recent personnel moves and the chance for substantial salary cap space next summer helped persuade Anthony the risk was too large to leave New York, where his family preferred to live. And Anthony was having second thoughts of not having a legacy city and going to a third team after LeBron James returned to Cleveland.
There always has to be intrigue in these things. And there may have been in the James/Anthony recruitments as well because of the timing. There was some question about why the decision making lasted so long given, especially James, seemed to know weeks ago what he wanted to do.
The talk around James supposedly was that James wanted to try to avoid a repeat of what he did in 2010. Not the TV show or rally, but the uniting of too strong a force. James wanted to remain in Cleveland in 2010, but he failed in several efforts to attract free agents, including Chris Bosh. So James understood he had to leave to win a championship, but he wanted to do it as quickly as possible. Thus, the merging of the three All-Stars with Dwyane Wade. They’d get to the Finals the first season and win twice.
James understood going back to Cleveland was no such uniting even with the talented Kyrie Irving. Though he also knew that roster still was better than Miami’s with the injury decline of Wade. So, the rumors go, James held out as long as he could to try to have as many teams and players make prior commitments. Thus, it would be too difficult for teams to do sign and trade deals or have multiple players form alliances with one team like he did in Miami. That’s why that uniting went more quickly back in 2010. The scenario is perhaps apocryphal, though with Anthony returning to New York and Houston losing out on Bosh, there are no so called super teams left that could be a formidable roadblock to a Finals return for James.