Tourist Jailed For Forgetting Wallet @ Ny Steakhouse

Does he have a case?


  • Total voters
    28

RoomService

Dinner is now being served.
BGOL Investor
Italian tourist busted at posh East Side steakhouse for forgetting wallet, even after offering iPhone as collateral until he could return with cash

'I forgot my wallet,' Graziano Graziussi, a 43-year-old lawyer from Naples, told a waiter before he was arrested under orders of management at Smith and Wollensky. Though a regular at the restaurant when he visits New York, he was not allowed to return to his friend's place to bring back payment.






smith-wollensky-2.jpg
Andrew Savulich/New York Daily News

Graziano Graziussi , an Italian tourist on vacation, offered his iPhone as collateral until he could retrieve his wallet to pay his $208 bill at Smith and Wollensky's. Management of the steakhouse had him arrested and charged with theft of services beside the offer.



front25n-1-copy.jpg


Welcome to New York, pal — now go to jail.
An Italian tourist spent his second night in the city behind bars after staff at an upscale East Side steakhouse called cops when he claimed he left his wallet at a friend’s place.
Graziano Graziussi, a 43-year-old lawyer from Naples, is a regular at Smith & Wollensky — but this time, barely 24 hours into his latest two-week stay in New York, he realized he didn’t have his wallet on him when a waiter presented him with the $208 bill Monday night.
“I forgot my wallet,” the clean-cut Graziussi told the waiter — but the staff at the Third Ave. eatery wasn’t buying it, even after Graziussi offered some pricey collateral while he went to get the cash about 30 blocks uptown.
“I was going to leave my iPhone,” he said. “I suggested they bring a bus boy with me. . . . It would have been an easy trip.”
But the general manager called police instead.

Cops showed up and declined to help Graziussi get out of the cashless chaos — even though he told them he’d prove he had the money if they’d only drive him uptown.
“They replied that they were not a taxi service,” Graziussi said. “The next thing I know, I was put in handcuffs.”




smith-wollensky.jpg
Andrew Savulich/New York Daily News

Graziano Graziussi, an Italian lawyer on vacation, was arrested last Monday at Smith and Wollensky's steakhouse, 3rd Ave. and E. 49 S., because he forgot his wallet and could not pay for his dinner.


The cops hauled him over to the 17th Precinct stationhouse on E. 51st St., where Graziussi was placed in a holding cell and charged with theft of services.
One police veteran told the Daily News he wasn’t surprised to hear that the restaurant wouldn’t take the phone as collateral.
“How do they know that iPhone was his? It could have come from anywhere,” the cop said.
Smith & Wollensky management declined to comment. But diners said the staff could have been more understanding.

“You never know,” said one customer, who declined to give his name. “I’ve got my own business, and I give people the benefit of the doubt. They probably should have given him a time scale. If he didn’t come back in an hour, they’d call the cops.”
The problem is there really isn’t any protocol for handling well-meaning, but empty-pocketed customers, another police source said.
“If you can’t pay — sorry, but you’re going to jail,” the source said.
And restaurateurs say dining-and-dashing is rampant.
large-menu-steakhouse.jpg
RMcdyer

The menu of the upscale steakhouse Smith and Wollensky's on Manhattan's East Side, where an Italian tourist was arrested after forgetting his wallet.


In the latest example, in early January, cops busted a one-time food blogger who stiffed three restaurants using the excuse that she left her credit card at home.
“There are more cons than ever in this economy we’re in,” said Rick Passarelli, owner of Bobby Van’s Steakhouse on Park Ave. “It’s just a sign of the times. Maybe they (Smith & Wollensky) just put their foot down.”

Graziussi’s night in jail — which was first chronicled by the blog Honest Cooking — was “horrible,” the tourist said.
But he admitted the ordeal was still somewhat entertaining.
“The people (in custody) I met were actually quite civilized,” he said. “It was like a movie. It was quite an experience.”
A judge tossed the case Tuesday morning, after Graziussi — who had never been arrested before — promised to return to court next week and pay the check.
But the whole experience has soured Graziussi on Smith & Wollensky.
“Do you know of any other good steakhouses around here?” he asked.
With Shane Dixon Kavanaugh, Christina Boyle and Shayna Jacobs
 
This is America,Pal...common sense or courtesy is not used,especially if the police are involved.

Arrivederci:lol:
 
Overkill and definitely fucked up. But I don't think he has a case to sue.

Nope.

Bottom line, could he pay what he owed?

No?

Then you go directly to jail, do not pass go, do not collect $200!

Mofos think an Iphone is gold or some ish, what do I look like as a restaurant owner trying to sell a used phone?!?
 
This shit is funny. the reason its funny to me is that for years Grey Advertising was located right across the street at 777 Third Ave. Man if I told you how many broke ass assistant media planners eat at Smith & Wollenski's on a regular basis. Man I remember making all of $23.5k a year and eating at S&W twice a week.


Oh......and yeah while harsh people do eat and run all the time. Wife and I watched some white couple nxt to us do it 2 months ago.
 
It used to be that f you used a credit card in Italy and it was declined, you went straight to jail charged with theft. IJS
 
Nope.

Bottom line, could he pay what he owed?

No?

Then you go directly to jail, do not pass go, do not collect $200!

Mofos think an Iphone is gold or some ish, what do I look like as a restaurant owner trying to sell a used phone?!?

Thank you for the first sensible reply.

The title is off


"Tourist Jailed For Forgetting Wallet @ Ny Steakhouse"


that should be


"Tourist Jailed For not paying for an expensive NY Steakhouse dinner"


When he sat down and began ordering whatever the fuck he wanted, he should have known his wallet was not in his pocket.
 
Look.....We all get it, if the guy was Black, he would not have gotten any consideration at all.

But this is a complete waste of officer resources and time if the guy offered his iphone and was a regular on top of that.

To get the police involved was ridiculous.


I don't think he has a case to sue though.
 
Last edited:
I remember many years ago, I went with 3 other people to a pretty nice restaurant, I was treating. When it came time to pay the bill, I pull out my Amex card and the waitress says they don't take credit cards. Then she said to give her my drivers license and she would take down the information an mail me the bill. When the bill came in the mail, I paid it.
 
Thank you for the first sensible reply.

The title is off


"Tourist Jailed For Forgetting Wallet @ Ny Steakhouse"


that should be


"Tourist Jailed For not paying for an expensive NY Steakhouse dinner"


When he sat down and began ordering whatever the fuck he wanted, he should have known his wallet was not in his pocket.

:yes::yes:
 
HuffPo has THE REST OF THE STORY:

:bullshit:

On Thursday afternoon, when we read the story of a 43-year-old Italian tourist name Graziano Graziussi being arrested and jailed after forgetting his wallet before going out to dine at upscale steakhouse Smith & Wollensky in New York, we were frankly a little dubious.

The story, as reported by Honest Cooking, the New York Daily News and the New York Post, was coherent and relatively plausible. Graziussi claimed that he'd forgotten his wallet at the hotel and that he offered to retrieve the wallet and leave his iPhone as collateral, but the restaurant refused, and instead called the cops on him. He was sent to jail over night before his case was dismissed by a judge the next morning.

We didn't know what, precisely, a restaurant manager would normally do in this situation -- though we were pretty sure that they wouldn't ask a customer to work the tab off by washing dishes, as they do on TV. Skipping out on a restaurant tab is punishable by a year in jail under New York law, so it didn't seem like such a far-fetched story.

The problem was that none of these first three reports included comment from Smith & Wollensky or any verification from onlookers at the scene. So they essentially took Graziussi at his word about how the whole incident happened.

HuffPost Food phoned Smith & Wollensky New York and the manager who answered the phone (who said his name was "John" but refused to give his last name) claimed not to have heard anything about the Graziussi incident at all, despite the fact that he was on duty at the steakhouse on Monday night until 11 p.m. When we did a little intensive Googling of the name "Graziano Graziussi," we found that he had gotten a PhD at Columbia in economics with a specialty "the unpaid care economy." Graziussi didn't necessarily strike us as a wanton dine-and-dasher who would outright lie to the press, but the whole thing didn't add up.

Yet Smith & Wollensky New York's corporate owners Fourth Wall Restaurants refused to comment on the situation, despite numerous requests from HuffPost Food -- at least until Friday around 5:30 p.m..

Then the company issued a statement that indicated that, at the very least, there was another side to the story. Here's the full text:
We have been in business in New York City for over 35 years and normally, it is our policy to maintain our guests’ privacy on all matters. We do not contact the police in any matter involving our customers without significant cause. NYPD Commissioner Ray Kelly commented on the situation in his press conference this afternoon:

“Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly said the 43-year-old lawyer from Naples did have a wallet with $118, but refused to hand it over. Graziussi claimed not to speak English, but a patrol supervisor who responded to the scene was fluent in Italian and was able to translate. He conducted the interview and determined that the individual simply did not want to pay.”
The idea that Graziussi would have claimed not to speak English -- despite having gotten a doctorate at an American university and conducting extensive interviews with multiple press outlets in English -- is particularly damning, and sounds just strange enough to be true.

We don't doubt that Graziussi's stay in jail was, as he told the Daily News, "horrible." We just aren't convinced that a man whom Ray Kelly said refused to pay for his steakhouse dinner, despite ample means, deserves a ton of sympathy.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/25/graziano-graziussi-43-year-old_n_2553857.html
 
HuffPo has THE REST OF THE STORY:

:bullshit:

On Thursday afternoon, when we read the story of a 43-year-old Italian tourist name Graziano Graziussi being arrested and jailed after forgetting his wallet before going out to dine at upscale steakhouse Smith & Wollensky in New York, we were frankly a little dubious.

The story, as reported by Honest Cooking, the New York Daily News and the New York Post, was coherent and relatively plausible. Graziussi claimed that he'd forgotten his wallet at the hotel and that he offered to retrieve the wallet and leave his iPhone as collateral, but the restaurant refused, and instead called the cops on him. He was sent to jail over night before his case was dismissed by a judge the next morning.

We didn't know what, precisely, a restaurant manager would normally do in this situation -- though we were pretty sure that they wouldn't ask a customer to work the tab off by washing dishes, as they do on TV. Skipping out on a restaurant tab is punishable by a year in jail under New York law, so it didn't seem like such a far-fetched story.

The problem was that none of these first three reports included comment from Smith & Wollensky or any verification from onlookers at the scene. So they essentially took Graziussi at his word about how the whole incident happened.

HuffPost Food phoned Smith & Wollensky New York and the manager who answered the phone (who said his name was "John" but refused to give his last name) claimed not to have heard anything about the Graziussi incident at all, despite the fact that he was on duty at the steakhouse on Monday night until 11 p.m. When we did a little intensive Googling of the name "Graziano Graziussi," we found that he had gotten a PhD at Columbia in economics with a specialty "the unpaid care economy." Graziussi didn't necessarily strike us as a wanton dine-and-dasher who would outright lie to the press, but the whole thing didn't add up.

Yet Smith & Wollensky New York's corporate owners Fourth Wall Restaurants refused to comment on the situation, despite numerous requests from HuffPost Food -- at least until Friday around 5:30 p.m..

Then the company issued a statement that indicated that, at the very least, there was another side to the story. Here's the full text:
We have been in business in New York City for over 35 years and normally, it is our policy to maintain our guests’ privacy on all matters. We do not contact the police in any matter involving our customers without significant cause. NYPD Commissioner Ray Kelly commented on the situation in his press conference this afternoon:

“Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly said the 43-year-old lawyer from Naples did have a wallet with $118, but refused to hand it over. Graziussi claimed not to speak English, but a patrol supervisor who responded to the scene was fluent in Italian and was able to translate. He conducted the interview and determined that the individual simply did not want to pay.”
The idea that Graziussi would have claimed not to speak English -- despite having gotten a doctorate at an American university and conducting extensive interviews with multiple press outlets in English -- is particularly damning, and sounds just strange enough to be true.

We don't doubt that Graziussi's stay in jail was, as he told the Daily News, "horrible." We just aren't convinced that a man whom Ray Kelly said refused to pay for his steakhouse dinner, despite ample means, deserves a ton of sympathy.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/25/graziano-graziussi-43-year-old_n_2553857.html


I already knew it crackers do what crackers do everyday b.
 
yeah that was stupid on the restaurants behalf, all they had to do was log on to the phone to prove it was his..

and then hold it untill he came back.. if he couldnt log on then I could understand their beef or if he didnt have collateral..

I wouldve just told him to have a bus boy accompany him he would have to pick up his wage and predicted tips for the day.. to go outside his job scope should be compensated..

that couldve easily been handled... damn shame they cant tell repeat customers in 2013..

oh well.. personally I wouldve just called my bank on the celly and explained to them the situation and have them resolve it..

if you got the money and in good standing, his bank shouldve had no problem getting him out of that...

then again.. he is probably a mobster lawyer and only has cash...
 
Because the cracker probably showed his ass and they HAD to call the cops.

hmmmm never considered that angle.. you just might have a point..

attitude if everything.. he probably thought he had right not to have the money and have the restaurant provide company while he retrieved it....
 
HuffPo has THE REST OF THE STORY:

:bullshit:

On Thursday afternoon, when we read the story of a 43-year-old Italian tourist name Graziano Graziussi being arrested and jailed after forgetting his wallet before going out to dine at upscale steakhouse Smith & Wollensky in New York, we were frankly a little dubious.

The story, as reported by Honest Cooking, the New York Daily News and the New York Post, was coherent and relatively plausible. Graziussi claimed that he'd forgotten his wallet at the hotel and that he offered to retrieve the wallet and leave his iPhone as collateral, but the restaurant refused, and instead called the cops on him. He was sent to jail over night before his case was dismissed by a judge the next morning.

We didn't know what, precisely, a restaurant manager would normally do in this situation -- though we were pretty sure that they wouldn't ask a customer to work the tab off by washing dishes, as they do on TV. Skipping out on a restaurant tab is punishable by a year in jail under New York law, so it didn't seem like such a far-fetched story.

The problem was that none of these first three reports included comment from Smith & Wollensky or any verification from onlookers at the scene. So they essentially took Graziussi at his word about how the whole incident happened.

HuffPost Food phoned Smith & Wollensky New York and the manager who answered the phone (who said his name was "John" but refused to give his last name) claimed not to have heard anything about the Graziussi incident at all, despite the fact that he was on duty at the steakhouse on Monday night until 11 p.m. When we did a little intensive Googling of the name "Graziano Graziussi," we found that he had gotten a PhD at Columbia in economics with a specialty "the unpaid care economy." Graziussi didn't necessarily strike us as a wanton dine-and-dasher who would outright lie to the press, but the whole thing didn't add up.

Yet Smith & Wollensky New York's corporate owners Fourth Wall Restaurants refused to comment on the situation, despite numerous requests from HuffPost Food -- at least until Friday around 5:30 p.m..

Then the company issued a statement that indicated that, at the very least, there was another side to the story. Here's the full text:
We have been in business in New York City for over 35 years and normally, it is our policy to maintain our guests’ privacy on all matters. We do not contact the police in any matter involving our customers without significant cause. NYPD Commissioner Ray Kelly commented on the situation in his press conference this afternoon:

“Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly said the 43-year-old lawyer from Naples did have a wallet with $118, but refused to hand it over. Graziussi claimed not to speak English, but a patrol supervisor who responded to the scene was fluent in Italian and was able to translate. He conducted the interview and determined that the individual simply did not want to pay.”
The idea that Graziussi would have claimed not to speak English -- despite having gotten a doctorate at an American university and conducting extensive interviews with multiple press outlets in English -- is particularly damning, and sounds just strange enough to be true.

We don't doubt that Graziussi's stay in jail was, as he told the Daily News, "horrible." We just aren't convinced that a man whom Ray Kelly said refused to pay for his steakhouse dinner, despite ample means, deserves a ton of sympathy.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/25/graziano-graziussi-43-year-old_n_2553857.html

Shouldn't we be much more concerned that lately ON-LINE NEWS sites have been more accurate and much more diligent in finding the TRUTH then ACTUAL decade old news outlets???
 
my question is if he was by himself how did he rack up a $208 bill from this menu?

large-menu-steakhouse.jpg


Unless he was washing down that meal with some expensive booze. Dude was probably drunk
 
Here is an "iphone"

fake1.jpg


Why should the restaurant be in the business of sending people with customers when they need to be on the job.. Or holding something that could be worth $0?

And not to find out more of the truth, the judge should have not thrown it out.
 
HuffPo has THE REST OF THE STORY:

:bullshit:

On Thursday afternoon, when we read the story of a 43-year-old Italian tourist name Graziano Graziussi being arrested and jailed after forgetting his wallet before going out to dine at upscale steakhouse Smith & Wollensky in New York, we were frankly a little dubious.

The story, as reported by Honest Cooking, the New York Daily News and the New York Post, was coherent and relatively plausible. Graziussi claimed that he'd forgotten his wallet at the hotel and that he offered to retrieve the wallet and leave his iPhone as collateral, but the restaurant refused, and instead called the cops on him. He was sent to jail over night before his case was dismissed by a judge the next morning.

We didn't know what, precisely, a restaurant manager would normally do in this situation -- though we were pretty sure that they wouldn't ask a customer to work the tab off by washing dishes, as they do on TV. Skipping out on a restaurant tab is punishable by a year in jail under New York law, so it didn't seem like such a far-fetched story.

The problem was that none of these first three reports included comment from Smith & Wollensky or any verification from onlookers at the scene. So they essentially took Graziussi at his word about how the whole incident happened.

HuffPost Food phoned Smith & Wollensky New York and the manager who answered the phone (who said his name was "John" but refused to give his last name) claimed not to have heard anything about the Graziussi incident at all, despite the fact that he was on duty at the steakhouse on Monday night until 11 p.m. When we did a little intensive Googling of the name "Graziano Graziussi," we found that he had gotten a PhD at Columbia in economics with a specialty "the unpaid care economy." Graziussi didn't necessarily strike us as a wanton dine-and-dasher who would outright lie to the press, but the whole thing didn't add up.

Yet Smith & Wollensky New York's corporate owners Fourth Wall Restaurants refused to comment on the situation, despite numerous requests from HuffPost Food -- at least until Friday around 5:30 p.m..

Then the company issued a statement that indicated that, at the very least, there was another side to the story. Here's the full text:
We have been in business in New York City for over 35 years and normally, it is our policy to maintain our guests’ privacy on all matters. We do not contact the police in any matter involving our customers without significant cause. NYPD Commissioner Ray Kelly commented on the situation in his press conference this afternoon:

“Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly said the 43-year-old lawyer from Naples did have a wallet with $118, but refused to hand it over. Graziussi claimed not to speak English, but a patrol supervisor who responded to the scene was fluent in Italian and was able to translate. He conducted the interview and determined that the individual simply did not want to pay.”
The idea that Graziussi would have claimed not to speak English -- despite having gotten a doctorate at an American university and conducting extensive interviews with multiple press outlets in English -- is particularly damning, and sounds just strange enough to be true.

We don't doubt that Graziussi's stay in jail was, as he told the Daily News, "horrible." We just aren't convinced that a man whom Ray Kelly said refused to pay for his steakhouse dinner, despite ample means, deserves a ton of sympathy.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/25/graziano-graziussi-43-year-old_n_2553857.html
props on the find
 
Back
Top