This Is The Most Plausible Theory For The Plane's Disappearance

Spectrum

Elite Poster
BGOL Investor
http://www.businessinsider.com/malaysia-plane-fire-2014-3

Over the past 10 days, investigators and observers have come up with ever-more elaborate theories for what might have happened to Malaysia Airways Flight 370.

What was originally assumed to have been a tragic mid-air explosion or mechanical problem soon bloomed into a criminal investigation of a meticulously planned hijacking, commandeering, or otherwise stealing of a fully loaded commercial 777 in mid-air.

The perpetrator(s) knew the plane so well, one of the latest theories goes, that they climbed through a trap door outside the cockpit to reach circuit breakers necessary to shut down one of the communication's systems. They shut down the transponder. They made the plane disappear and fooled the world into thinking it had crashed. They flew one of two "arcs" for 7 hours — a "southern route" over the Indian Ocean on which, eventually, they crashed the plane in the ocean in a complicated suicide, and a "northern route" in which, perhaps, they slipped past land-based radar, flew to a destination in central Asia, and landed, perhaps preparing to use the plane again soon for a terrorist attack or other mission. This latter plan was executed so flawlessly, one observer theorized, that Flight 370 slipped in behind another commercial airliner for much of the route so as not to be noticed on radar.

The pilots' houses have been searched. Terrorist connections have been probed. Passenger backgrounds and possible motives have been scrutinized. And still, 10 days after the plane disappeared, we know nothing.

Perhaps that's because we're overthinking it.

A few days ago, a former pilot named Chris Goodfellow articulated an entirely different theory on Google+.

This theory fits the facts.

And it's one of the most plausible yet:

Shortly after takeoff, as Malaysia 370 was flying out over the ocean, just after the co-pilot gave his final "Good night" sign-off to Malaysia air traffic control, smoke began filling the cockpit, perhaps from a tire on the front landing gear that had ignited on takeoff
The captain immediately did exactly what he had been trained to do: Turn the plane toward the closest airport so he could land.
The closest appropriate airport was called Pulau Langkawi. It had a massive 13,000-foot runway. The captain programmed the destination into the flight computer. The auto-pilot turned the plane west and put it on a course right for the runway (the same heading the plane turned to)
The captain and co-pilot tried to find the source of the smoke and fire. They switched off electrical "busses" to try to isolate it, in the process turning off systems like the transponder and ACARs automated update system (but not, presumably, the auto-pilot, which was flying the plane). They did not issue a distress call, because in a mid-air emergency your priorities are "aviate, navigate, communicate" — in that order. But smoke soon filled the cockpit and overwhelmed them (a tire fire could do this). The pilots passed out or died.
Smoke filled the cabin and overwhelmed and distracted the passengers and cabin crew... or the cockpit door was locked and/or the cockpit was filled with smoke, so no one could enter the cockpit to try to figure out where the plane was, how the pilots were, or how the plane might be successfully landed. (This would be a complicated task, even if one knew the pilots were unconscious and had access to the cockpit, especially if most of the plane's electrical systems were switched off or damaged)
With no one awake to instruct the auto-pilot to land, the plane kept flying on its last programmed course... right over Pulau Langkawi and out over the Indian Ocean. The engine-update system kept "pinging" the satellite. Eventually, 6 or 7 hours after the incident, the plane ran out of fuel and crashed.
This theory fits the facts. It makes sense. It explains the manual course change as well as the "pings" that a satellite kept hearing from the plane. It requires no fantastically brilliant pre-planning or execution or motives.

Here's Chris Goodfellow:

A lot of speculation about MH370. Terrorism, hijack, meteors. I cannot believe the analysis on CNN - almost disturbing. I tend to look for a more simple explanation of this event.

Loaded 777 departs midnight from Kuala to Beijing. Hot night. Heavy aircraft. About an hour out across the gulf towards Vietnam the plane goes dark meaning the transponder goes off and secondary radar tracking goes off.

Two days later we hear of reports that Malaysian military radar (which is a primary radar meaning the plane is being tracked by reflection rather than by transponder interrogation response) has tracked the plane on a southwesterly course back across the Malay Peninsula into the straits of Malacca.

When I heard this I immediately brought up Google Earth and I searched for airports in proximity to the track towards southwest.

The left turn is the key here. This was a very experienced senior Captain with 18,000 hours. Maybe some of the younger pilots interviewed on CNN didn't pick up on this left turn. We old pilots were always drilled to always know the closest airport of safe harbor while in cruise. Airports behind us, airports abeam us and airports ahead of us. Always in our head. Always. Because if something happens you don't want to be thinking what are you going to do - you already know what you are going to do. Instinctively when I saw that left turn with a direct heading I knew he was heading for an airport. Actually he was taking a direct route to Palau Langkawi a 13,000 foot strip with an approach over water at night with no obstacles. He did not turn back to Kuala Lampur because he knew he had 8,000 foot ridges to cross. He knew the terrain was friendlier towards Langkawi and also a shorter distance.

Take a look on Google Earth at this airport. This pilot did all the right things. He was confronted by some major event onboard that made him make that immediate turn back to the closest safe airport.
For me the loss of transponders and communications makes perfect sense if a fire. There was most likely a fire or electrical fire. In the case of fire the first response if to pull all the main busses and restore circuits one by one until you have isolated the bad one.

If they pulled the busses the plane indeed would go silent. It was probably a serious event and they simply were occupied with controlling the plane and trying to fight the fire. Aviate, Navigate and lastly communicate. There are two types of fires. Electrical might not be as fast and furious and there might or might not be incapacitating smoke. However there is the possibility given the timeline that perhaps there was an overheat on one of the front landing gear tires and it blew on takeoff and started slowly burning. Yes this happens with underinflated tires. Remember heavy plane, hot night, sea level, long run takeoff. There was a well known accident in Nigeria of a DC8 that had a landing gear fire on takeoff. A tire fire once going would produce horrific incapacitating smoke. Yes, pilots have access to oxygen masks but this is a no no with fire. Most have access to a smoke hood with a filter but this will only last for a few minutes depending on the smoke level. (I used to carry one of my own in a flight bag and I still carry one in my briefcase today when I fly).

What I think happened is that they were overcome by smoke and the plane just continued on the heading probably on George (autopilot) until either fuel exhaustion or fire destroyed the control surfaces and it crashed. I said four days ago you will find it along that route - looking elsewhere was pointless.

This pilot, as I say, was a hero struggling with an impossible situation trying to get that plane to Langkawi. No doubt in my mind. That's the reason for the turn and direct route. A hijack would not have made that deliberate left turn with a direct heading for Langkawi. It would probably have weaved around a bit until the hijackers decided on where they were taking it...

Chris Goodfellow's full explanation for his theory is here. It's the simplest and most compelling I've heard yet.
 
?!?

But they have oxygen masks on an isolated system, the FIRST step taken @ ANYTHING that could compromise the plane's height or their own consciousness would be to put these masks on, wouldn't it?!?
 
So if the plane kept flying on the updated course they investigators can pinpoint how long the plane flew and how much fuel it had upon take off and where it crashed...

Hell air traffic control would have saw smoke from the wheels when the plane took off and the pilots would have gotten indication immediately of such a thing..

Those Boeing 777 are brand new planes
 
no no no, the illuminati hired those trained actors to masquerade as pilots and passengers to distract the sheeple from the situation in the ukraine. just to be sure the sheeple stay distracted, they used haarp in la to cause a minor earthquake.:yes:
 
Wrong! The person who wrote that piece need to be dropped from 1000 feet.

All commercial airline are equip with full facial gas mask.
oxygen-mask.jpg
 
here's where the theory gets dismissed....

The satellite that picked up it's last signal ~7 hours later, put it one of those two arcs (the satellite could tell how FAR away the plane was from the satellite's vision, but NOT which direction. If autopilot was heading to towards Pulua and kept going beyond, it would be far away from those arcs

2) If it was incapacitating smoke/fire...would would the plane fly for an additional 7 hours WHILE switching navigational waypoints?
--you mean to tell me SkyNet took over and flew a wounded airplane with possibly an active fire on it?

--- theory fried.
 
This theory does seem to fit the facts released so far...however, it doesn't address the 45k altitude. My assumption would be to starve the fire of oxygen.
 
This theory does seem to fit the facts released so far...however, it doesn't address the 45k altitude. My assumption would be to starve the fire of oxygen.

Still more than enough oxygen for a fire @ that level, while it is indeed thinner it is not absent.
 
Dude may not be that far off with his theory. Maybe with the smoke, the plane also became depressurized and they didn't know it trying to figure out the fire. 20 secs without good oxygen and they pass out. The flight remains on auto pilot until it falls into the sea.
 
Dude may not be that far off with his theory. Maybe with the smoke, the plane also became depressurized and they didn't know it trying to figure out the fire. 20 secs without good oxygen and they pass out. The flight remains on auto pilot until it falls into the sea.

It makes sense. It might not have happened that way but it definitely makes sense...and it's not surprising that a pilot could piece this together.
 
Perhaps its escaped this "experts" notice that the Malysian minister for defence has already admitted that an unidentfied plane with its transponders switched off, practically flew the length and breadth of his country, alledgedly zig-zagging from east to west coast, and not a single one of the FOUR air defense stations whose job it is to identfy these sorts of situations actually spotted the plane (alledgedly)

Its not much of a "cover up" when you send your top man out to a press conference to tell the world "our air defenses are piss poor, I think the guys might have been asleep or something"

Thats call misdirection, not a cover up....
 
Dude may not be that far off with his theory. Maybe with the smoke, the plane also became depressurized and they didn't know it trying to figure out the fire. 20 secs without good oxygen and they pass out. The flight remains on auto pilot until it falls into the sea.

MULTIPLE alarms go off INSTANTLY in the cockpit if and when the plane becomes depressurized.

For ANY of the above scenarios to happen @ least one of the pilots had to be incapacitated FIRST, or in on it to begin with, for BOTH pilots to go unconscious on a commercial plane is almost impossible, but in the end it just might be that type of impossibility happening that actually makes this so hard to comprehend.

IF there is no foul play, then you'd have to consider multiple cascading failures on the plane's & the pilots' parts, that not only its ACARS system went out, but the radio as well, but one thing still stands out, if the passengers knew the plane was going down, how come absolutely NO phone calls or texts to friends or family?!?

I've also heard reports that there's a line of thinking that the plane was flying as low as 5,000 feet to avoid radar, although another line of reasoning could be that they went this low to put out a tire fire of some sort.
 
This vid simplifies how investigators used successive sat' pings to narrow search to arc corridors...

 
but one thing still stands out, if the passengers knew the plane was going down, how come absolutely NO phone calls or texts to friends or family?!?
.

I'm assuming what the other poster mentioned happened. Maybe the rise to 45,000 + decompression put the passengers out. Thus, no phone calls were made after the descent. Rising to 45,000 does make sense as a last ditch effort to put a fire out too (low oxygen).

It all seems kind of far-fetched...but I don't think it's anymore far-fetched than the pilot taking over the flight. Also, it's been released that those two pilots did not arrange to fly together.

Shit man...i don't know...i'm trying to make sense of the shit. It's really bizarre.
 
possibly what happened to this plane could be similar to what happened with the one that Payne Stewart died on. if it was indeed hijacked and flew toward the southern Indian Ocean, something could have happened to cause everyone to pass out or become incapacitated due to a loss of cabin pressurization. After the transponder was turned off, a mechanical failure had to happen on that plane. It is likely that everybody on that plane and may have lost consciousness due to hypoxia, or a lack of oxygen...(just like the case with everyone onboard Payne Stewart's plane). This would explain none of the passengers texting, calling loved ones, updating facebook, twitter, etc. Plane probably just ran out of fuel and crashed into the Indian Ocean somewhere.

They are searching the wrong parts of the ocean. Thats my theory anyway.....its plausible.
 
possibly what happened to this plane could be similar to what happened with the one that Payne Stewart died on. if it was indeed hijacked and flew toward the southern Indian Ocean, something could have happened to cause everyone to pass out or become incapacitated due to a loss of cabin pressurization. After the transponder was turned off, a mechanical failure had to happen on that plane. It is likely that everybody on that plane and may have lost consciousness due to hypoxia, or a lack of oxygen...(just like the case with everyone onboard Payne Stewart's plane). This would explain none of the passengers texting, calling loved ones, updating facebook, twitter, etc. Plane probably just ran out of fuel and crashed into the Indian Ocean somewhere.

They are searching the wrong parts of the ocean. Thats my theory anyway.....its plausible.



Diego Garcia Islands....
 
Diego Garcia Islands....

Only two options there:

You're saying it was a coordinated event involving the U.S. government.

or

The pilot tried to land the distressed plane there and the U.S. military shot it down. (if communications systems were down they shot that down over the Indian ocean).

Both are definitely possible.
 
I'm assuming what the other poster mentioned happened. Maybe the rise to 45,000 + decompression put the passengers out. Thus, no phone calls were made after the descent. Rising to 45,000 does make sense as a last ditch effort to put a fire out too (low oxygen).

It all seems kind of far-fetched...but I don't think it's anymore far-fetched than the pilot taking over the flight. Also, it's been released that those two pilots did not arrange to fly together.

Shit man...i don't know...i'm trying to make sense of the shit. It's really bizarre.

there are 2 reasons that would explain such deviations in altitude. The first being the aircraft was experiencing mechanical difficulties in which the pilots were having a hard time controlling. Or, the cockpit crew was no longer a part of the equation and some one else was in charge.
 
eewwll said:
Shit man...i don't know...i'm trying to make sense of the shit. It's really bizarre.


Although it played out a bit differently, this all reminds me a bit of Helios 522...which turned out to be cabin pressure related and completely avoidable.
 
Only two options there:

You're saying it was a coordinated event involving the U.S. government.

or

The pilot tried to land the distressed plane there and the U.S. military shot it down.

Both are definitely possible.

absolutely.....

1. They brought down 3 buildings on 9/11 killing 3 thousand people...then created a fake war on terror

If they can do this to their own people, they can do ANYTHING!


2.

 
I'm assuming what the other poster mentioned happened. Maybe the rise to 45,000 + decompression put the passengers out. Thus, no phone calls were made after the descent.

It all seems kind of far-fetched...but I don't think it's anymore far-fetched than the pilot taking over the flight. Also, it's been released that those two pilots did not arrange to fly together.

Shit man...i don't know...i'm trying to make sense of the shit. It's really bizarre.

But again, if the plane rose to 45,000 feet, the oxygen masks automatically drop down above 10,000 feet, how could everyone be rendered unconscious unless again, a cascading series of events took place, the ENTIRE electrical system PLUS its back-up systems, which kept the oxygen masks from dropping, and also took out the radio & ACARS set up, but for both the pilot & co-pilot to be taken out is rare.

SOMETHING went egregiously wrong here, on BOTH the plane AND on the tracking side, whether it's on the civilian or military or both remains to be seen.
 
there are 2 reasons that would explain such deviations in altitude. The first being the aircraft was experiencing mechanical difficulties in which the pilots were having a hard time controlling. Or, the cockpit crew was no longer a part of the equation and some one else was in charge.

Yep. Because it wouldn't have even be necessary for the crew to take the plane up to 45,000 feet to knock everyone out. If they had done it at 25,000 slowly, people would have never recognized it until it was too late anyway. And they would know that. Although, people can't tell the difference between 25,000 and 45,000 feet with a slow ascent and doing it at that height just makes the process fast... still doesnt seem like a move that a pilot would make because that pushes you to the absolute limit of managing the plane. It's easy to lose control of that plane at that altitude. A professional would know that it's unnecessary to take that risk.
 
absolutely.....

1. They brought down 3 buildings on 9/11 killing 3 thousand people...then created a fake war on terror

If they can do this to their own people, they can do ANYTHING!

More like allowed an attack that killed 3,000, and then extended a "war on terror" to carry on their own missives. (make $$$, blah, blah, blah!)
 
But again, if the plane rose to 45,000 feet, the oxygen masks automatically drop down above 10,000 feet, .

You must mean above 35,000 feet or something because most international flight over oceans go in the 20,000 feet range. So I'm positive masks don't automatically drop when you pass 10,000 feet.
 
If they can do this to their own people, they can do ANYTHING!

So if we take option one as the possibility, what's the payoff? I certainly don't put it out of the realm of possibility...but I'm not seeing the clear payoffs. 9/11 was a pretty clear payoff. We don't need to re-hash that. I'm not seeing the play here on this one. Unless, the act has only begun.
 
semights an might ofs but no one is thinking about the fact that nobody called on there cell phones to warn or say goodbye to there familys...smoke in the cabin equals someone calling to report it etc.
 
Yep. Because it wouldn't have even be necessary for the crew to take the plane up to 45,000 feet to knock everyone out. If they had done it at 25,000 slowly, people would have never recognized it until it was too late anyway. And they would know that. Although, people can't tell the difference between 25,000 and 45,000 feet with a slow ascent and doing it at that height just makes the process fast... still doesnt seem like a move that a pilot would make because that pushes you to the absolute limit of managing the plane. It's easy to lose control of that plane at that altitude. A professional would know that it's unnecessary to take that risk.

I swear the longer it takes to find the plane, the more it reminds me of that movie "Airport '77" where authorities looked & looked for the plane, but couldn't find it until a search plane flew over it in the daytime, the ENTIRE plane was intact, UNDERWATER!!!

Airport77-PosterArt.jpg


airport77.jpg
​
 
You must mean above 35,000 feet or something because most international flight over oceans go in the 20,000 feet range. So I'm positive masks don't automatically drop when you pass 10,000 feet.

LOL, not when the plane goes above 10,00 feet, I mean when cabin depressurization happens above 10,000 feet, 10,000 feet & below is regular, breathable air, sorry I wasn't clear!

Even in-flight air (pressurized) is actually like being in Denver, NOT @ sea level, it would put undue stress on the body of the airplane to pressurize it that high for each flight.

:cool:
 
semights an might ofs but no one is thinking about the fact that nobody called on there cell phones to warn or say goodbye to there familys...smoke in the cabin equals someone calling to report it etc.

If they were above 25,000 feet already and over the ocean, my assumption is that they wouldn't have been in the coverage range to make a phone call.
 
Back
Top