J.R. SMITH IS #ALLINCLE
J.R. Smith should be re-signed.
There, I said it. Unrelented ribbing may commence.
Yes, he declined his $6.5 million player option. Yes, he was an abysmal 24-for-77 in the Finals. Yes, he was suspended for whacking Jae Crowder in the first round. Yes, he committed countless other ignorant fouls throughout the regular season and in the playoffs. And yes, he may still have the court vision of a young Kobe Bryant.
But @teamswish deserves another chance in Cleveland, and the Cavs need to pay him.
J.R. Smith is not a bigger priority than Tristan Thompson. However, I’m certain that Thompson’s continued lobbying for a max deal is drawing attention away from another important cog on last year’s Eastern Conference champions, and it’s not Delly.
Now, let’s get this out of the way. J.R. Smith is not changing any time soon. He will always be a high-volume scorer. At his best, he’s the 2012-2013 NBA Sixth Man of the Year, knocking down contested threes and electrifying the rest of his team with instant energy off the bench.
At his worst, well, you saw him at his worst in the Finals, complete with all the negative attention that a longtime media punching bag commands.
I’m not naive enough to think that a half-season playing alongside LeBron has changed J.R. But I know for a fact that a half-season playing with Smith has changed the Cavs — for the better.
First off, he had some of the best 46 games of his regular season career as a Cav. He averaged 12.7 points, a 1.8-point increase from his 24 games with the Knicks, and he shot his best percentage from the field since 2010. His assists went down to 2.5 a game, but the figure is deceiving because he was largely camped out beyond the arc in the Cavs’ spacing-oriented offense, waiting for the pass that would lead to an open three.
Speaking of playing beyond the arc, Smith excelled for the Cavs as a knockdown shooter. For the season, he shot 40.5 percent on catch-and-shoot threes, and that number soars to 45.8 percent after the All-Star break, once he finally settled into the Cavs’ offense. This may come as a surprise, but he was at his best in the fourth quarter, splashing 47.6 percent of assisted threes.
As far as his contributions to the team are concerned, J.R. proved to be one of the most valuable players on the Cavs roster. With Smith on the court, they put up an offensive efficiency rating of 113.0, better than the marks of Kevin Love (112.7) and Tristan Thompson (112.6). Meanwhile, on the defensive end, opponents posted a 104.9 offensive rating with Smith on the court and a 107.3 mark with him off of it. He accumulated a 1.8 value over replacement player (VORP) in 46 games, a figure he reached just twice in his career during full seasons.
3-and-D players have cashed in this summer as the concept of the “new NBA” permeates the league. J.R. isn’t competent enough on defense to be considered in that class, but he’s a great shooter and for the price, the Cavs won’t find a better deal.
Now, about the playoffs…
There’s absolutely no question that J.R.’s play in the Finals was atrocious and he may very well have cost the Cavs the chance to at least take the Warriors to seven games. However, with that said, it’s time to look at the facts:
1. In terms of the entirety of the playoffs, Smith was not terrible. He shot 40.3 percent from the field and a touch under 36 percent on his threes, on par with his career averages. And if you take away the Finals, Smith shot 45.7 percent on field goals and 39.6 percent on threes. At that rate, he would’ve been on pace for arguably his best playoffs ever.
2. For the three series’ in which he came off the bench, including the Finals, he shot 38.4 percent from downtown and averaged 13.7 points, an upgrade over his regular season mark.
3. Throughout the Finals, Smith was harassed by extremely long wing defenders on the NBA’s best defense. Shaun Livingston, Klay Thompson and others completely stonewalled his attempts to gain space one-on-one, and Draymond Green’s max-contract-worthy quick feet and solid frame prevented him from creating off the pick-and-roll. These are truths. There is no other way to explain it.
4. People forget Smith absolutely shamed the Bulls throughout an extremely physical Eastern Conference semifinal series. Not only did he shoot 44.4 percent from 3-point range against them, he also hit the game-tying 3-pointer in Game 3 to knot it all up at 96 before Derrick Rose’s good karma finally caught up to him.
5. Let’s be real about the Jae Crowder thing. The Cavs were playing a pesky Celtics team that knew they were about to get swept but kept playing handsy anyways, Kelly Olynyk had just cut the Cavs title hopes in half with one rip of a shoulder and quite frankly, J.R. had eaten some Subway that day and his tummy was bothering him. Give the guy a break.
Moving on. As far as the Cavs’ immediate needs go, J.R. is still the best option available to fill the void of wing shooter. Yes, Mo Williams is fine and dandy from range, but he’s at his best with the ball in his hands, coming off of the pick-and-roll and firing. The Cavs have indicated they’re interested in the Clippers Jamal Crawford, but again, he plays best with the ball in his hands and would be a major liability to “fit out” as LeBron so lovingly phrased the phenomenon.
The Cavs need another spot-up shooter to space the floor around the LeBron-Kyrie tandem. J.R. fits that role as has been established above, and already has familiarity with the offense. He also provides some pop off the bench and actually began to show some chemistry with Timofey Mozgov, especially on pick-and-rolls, towards the end of last season.
J.R. will probably be looking for a deal in the $5-6 million range. That’s much cheaper than rumored alternative Joe Johnson ($24 million). Even if Dan Gilbert continues to flip the bird at the luxury tax, the extra $18 million he would save by signing Smith instead of trading for Johnson would help lower his bill next year when the cap explodes.
The subtext behind all of this is that J.R. Smith is a Cav. He’s never stopped praising the Cavaliers organization for prying him out of NYC, making it very apparent in a letter he wrote on the Cauldron.
“With 45 games games in the rearview mirror since the trade, I’ve been able to reflect on things, and now see it as a blessing in disguise,” Smith wrote. “For me, being away from New York, my hometown, has led to far fewer distractions. In Cleveland, there just isn’t much to do after 9 p.m., so the days of fashion shows, shopping, and the nights out have been replaced by one thing and one thing only: Basketball.”
Aside from the slight Noah-esque dig, Smith wears his appreciation for the city of Cleveland and the Cavs on his sleeve. It’s much too laissez-faire to assume that Smith has suddenly put winning above himself, but going into his age-30 season and playing alongside the best player in the world may be the kick in the pants he needs to start getting introspective about his career.
One last argument.
Everyone remembers the fateful early January days when LeBron had finally grown weary of trying to bear the burden of an entire team’s worth of egos and had shown signs of disillusionment with the Cavs’ commitment to winning and their 19-20 record. Cavs GM David Griffin felt it was time to make a change and dealt Dion Waiters to the Thunder in a deal that netted him Smith and Iman Shumpert. Two days later, he added Mozgov and the makeover was complete.
But actually it wasn’t. What really keyed the Cavs’ midseason turnaround wasn’t the trades themselves, it was the new sense of chemistry the trades had created. And at the head of this new band of brothers was none other than J.R. Smith.
Don’t believe me? These Insta’s speak for themselves.
#JustSaying
A photo posted by JR Smith (@teamswish) on May 26, 2015 at 9:23pm PDT
LeBron has always relished playing alongside teammates who work hard and cherish winning. But another characteristic he looks for is “fun.” If we learned nothing else from his tenure from Miami, we learned that he loves to have fun with his crew. J.R. brings the fun factor and as long as he’s locked in, he brings the wins.
Will he be locked in?
Only time will tell.