Michael Wilbon: Kobe or Michael? Manning or Elway?(And yes, the Cubs really

Ben threw the game winning touchdown in the Superbowl against Arizona. HE WON THE GAME ON HIS ARM WHILE PLAYING WITH A BROKEN RIB.

Tom Brady get's his knee fucked up on a legitimate play. What does the league do? Invent "the brady Rule". You know a QB is soft as baby shit when the league has to invent a rule NAMED AFTER HIM to protect him.
they won off James Harrison.

don't act like Kurt Warner didn't come back on they ass.
 
montana is easily the goat

brady is a system qb....he isnt that great the system is outstanding

proof?

bledsoe and cassel did just as well in that system

and i think that kids should get paid after high school if they have the talent

only americans want to hold kids back
 
Ben threw the game winning touchdown in the Superbowl against Arizona. HE WON THE GAME ON HIS ARM WHILE PLAYING WITH A BROKEN RIB.

Tom Brady get's his knee fucked up on a legitimate play. What does the league do? Invent "the brady Rule". You know a QB is soft as baby shit when the league has to invent a rule NAMED AFTER HIM to protect him.
they won off James Harrison.

don't act like Kurt Warner didn't come back on they ass.
 
And again, you clowns fail to address that TOM BRADY CHOKED IN THE BIGGEST GAME IN NFL HISTORY.

How did he choke? The Defense choked. not him. He played extrmely well considering all the pressure the Giants Put on Him. He didnt even throw an Int.

You got to look at each super bowl in a situational matter. Who said Brady COULDNT lead the down for the TD. He didnt have to. I think every QB in history would have did the same thing. If Montana just need a FG to win he would put them in position for the FG. Its Common sense. holding that against Brady who who was excellent though all those games is insane.who put Venitari is position? Rothlesberger had a team basically drag him to his first ring.(he only threw what 5 passes in the second half of his super bowl wtf). Brady's playoff record destroys Peyton's. so to me league wise its Brady>Peyton>Brees>
 
montana is easily the goat

brady is a system qb....he isnt that great the system is outstanding

proof?

bledsoe and cassel did just as well in that system

and i think that kids should get paid after high school if they have the talent

only americans want to hold kids back

Hoow is that Proof. Your act like Bledsoe didnt perform well any where else or Cassel isnt performing well now....

Brady is outstanding
 
who isn't a system qb?
ben is, same scheme same run first complete the pass later system
peyton has had the same system since he came into the nfl
cassell is playing in the same system he played in new england more or less remember weiss is the coordinator there
who isn't a system qb...since you want that to be a knock on tom brady.

did tom not destroy the steelers and now the jets? or am i mistaken
 
How did he choke? The Defense choked. not him. He played extrmely well considering all the pressure the Giants Put on Him. He didnt even throw an Int.

You got to look at each super bowl in a situational matter. Who said Brady COULDNT lead the down for the TD. He didnt have to. I think every QB in history would have did the same thing. If Montana just need a FG to win...

Let me stop you right there. Montana never relied on a kicker to win pivitol games. Back in the day kickers got NO RESPECT. In the '89 Superbowl against the Bunguls, the 9ers were down 13-16 with ~30 seconds left on the clock at the 18 yard line. Any other bitch ass coach TODAY would have paraded his field goal kicker on the filed to kick for the tie. Montana? Fuck that. Game winning strike to John Taylor for the win. This is after leading his team 80 yards down the field.

And Elway relying on a kicker to win games? :lol:

In critical 4th quarter moments you couldn't drag Montana, Elway, Young, Marino and Kelly off the field with tractor trailer. Montana was not listening to Walsh about kicking a field goal.

That game winning drive by Eli against the Pats IS THE WAY THE GAME IS SUPPOSE TO BE WON. That game winning drive by Cheeseburger, who played with a broken rib BTW IS THE WAY THE GAME IS SUPPOSED TO BE WON.
 
who isn't a system qb?
ben is, same scheme same run first complete the pass later system
peyton has had the same system since he came into the nfl
cassell is playing in the same system he played in new england more or less remember weiss is the coordinator there
who isn't a system qb...since you want that to be a knock on tom brady.

did tom not destroy the steelers and now the jets? or am i mistaken

The system is dependent on the QB and vice versa. For example the last QBs to run Bill Walsh's system to perfection was Montana and Steve Young. Favre to a bastardized extent. It takes a special type of QB to run that system. Vick is one of those QBs but with that said Andy Reid still isn't running the system to get the most out of Vick.

Brady is in a easy ass run & shoot a.k.a "spread" offense. Does he study? yeah, I'll give him that. But his success is due to a soft ass cupcake league. The spread is nothing new. The spread offense failed in the 80s and 90s because defenses had more latitude. Now we have the bitch ass "Brady Rule" and players getting fined every week because they looked at an offensive player wrong.
 
The system is dependent on the QB and vice versa. For example the last QBs to run Bill Walsh's system to perfection was Montana and Steve Young. Favre to a bastardized extent. It takes a special type of QB to run that system. Vick is one of those QBs but with that said Andy Reid still isn't running the system to get the most out of Vick.

Brady is in a easy ass run & shoot a.k.a "spread" offense. Does he study? yeah, I'll give him that. But his success is due to a soft ass cupcake league. The spread is nothing new. The spread offense failed in the 80s and 90s because defenses had more latitude. Now we have the bitch ass "Brady Rule" and players getting fined every week because they looked at an offensive player wrong.

that all might be true BUT you have to remove the system from your argument simply because EVERY qb that succeeds succeeded because of the system they were in. that's all im saying
 
that all might be true BUT you have to remove the system from your argument simply because EVERY qb that succeeds succeeded because of the system they were in. that's all im saying

I think what alexw really meant was that Brady isn't special. And he really isn't. Cassel proved that. Now were Joe and Steve special? YES. Because no one else has ran Bill Walsh's offense like they did since up until Vick this year. But like I said, Andy Ried doesn't know what to do with a talent like Vick. Vick could easily be on some Steve Young type shit game in and game out if he played for Shanahan.
 
Let me stop you right there. Montana never relied on a kicker to win pivitol games. Back in the day kickers got NO RESPECT. In the '89 Superbowl against the Bunguls, the 9ers were down 13-16 with ~30 seconds left on the clock at the 18 yard line. Any other bitch ass coach TODAY would have paraded his field goal kicker on the filed to kick for the tie. Montana? Fuck that. Game winning strike to John Taylor for the win. This is after leading his team 80 yards down the field.

And Elway relying on a kicker to win games? :lol:

In critical 4th quarter moments you couldn't drag Montana, Elway, Young, Marino and Kelly off the field with tractor trailer. Montana was not listening to Walsh about kicking a field goal.

That game winning drive by Eli against the Pats IS THE WAY THE GAME IS SUPPOSE TO BE WON. That game winning drive by Cheeseburger, who played with a broken rib BTW IS THE WAY THE GAME IS SUPPOSED TO BE WON.

The game is won one the score board. Brady did what he needed to do. period. Montana is the GOAT to me. Elway is definitely up there. I can see Peyton imitating him at the end of his career. Brady plays careful and smart. he got to position. hes about team not his legacy
 
I think what alexw really meant was that Brady isn't special. And he really isn't. Cassel proved that. Now were Joe and Steve special? YES. Because no one else has ran Bill Walsh's offense like they did since up until Vick this year. But like I said, Andy Ried doesn't know what to do with a talent like Vick. Vick could easily be on some Steve Young type shit game in and game out if he played for Shanahan.

Why people keep using Cassel as a proving point. Cassel is playing well with the Chiefs also. Brady has performed great under 4 different coordinators. thats like saying Young was a system QB. Brady is special and a top five all time QB
 
How did he choke? The Defense choked. not him. He played extrmely well considering all the pressure the Giants Put on Him. He didnt even throw an Int.

You got to look at each super bowl in a situational matter. Who said Brady COULDNT lead the down for the TD. He didnt have to. I think every QB in history would have did the same thing. If Montana just need a FG to win he would put them in position for the FG. Its Common sense. holding that against Brady who who was excellent though all those games is insane.who put Venitari is position? Rothlesberger had a team basically drag him to his first ring.(he only threw what 5 passes in the second half of his super bowl wtf). Brady's playoff record destroys Peyton's. so to me league wise its Brady>Peyton>Brees>

Had that Been Montana or Young on the verge of an undefeated season they would have made sure the game wasn't even close.

That patriots team margin of victory in the playoffs was beyond pathetic for a supposed "GOAT Team". Barely beating the Chargers by 3 points? GTFO.

The 89 9ers left absolutely no doubt in anyone's mind that they were GOAT. They had the largest margin of victory in the playoffs, destroyed a Viking team that tied the 85 Bears single season sack total and set the record for points scored in a Superbowl and largest margin of Victory in a Superbowl. Montana threw 5 touchdowns in that Superbowl. Why didn't Brady do the same? What's Brady's excuse for not matching that feat in today's soft ass offensive friendly NFL? After all, y'all muthafuckas were trying to anoint him GOAT. Brady CHOKED, bottom line.
 
The game is won one the score board. Brady did what he needed to do. period. Montana is the GOAT to me. Elway is definitely up there. I can see Peyton imitating him at the end of his career. Brady plays careful and smart. he got to position. hes about team not his legacy

Oh, now it went from Brady being GOAT to Brady just doing what he had to do. Well let me tell you what Brady didn't do:

He didn't kick a 45 yard game winning field goal IN A BLIZZARD to advance his team to the AFC Championship game.

He didn't win the AFC Championship game to advance his team to the Superbowl.

He didn't kick a 48 yard field goal to win the Superbowl against the Lambs.

He didn't kick the game winning field goal against the Panthers in the Superbowl.

I'll tell you what Brady did do; he choked in the biggest game in NFL history.

If you break down the playoff games, Brady really hasn't done shit. He just got really really lucky.


Why people keep using Cassel as a proving point. Cassel is playing well with the Chiefs also. Brady has performed great under 4 different coordinators. thats like saying Young was a system QB. Brady is special and a top five all time QB

GTFOH with that top 5 shit. You're man crushing on Brady and that's it. :smh:
 
Does Bledsoe or Matt cAssell have 3 rings?

Does Eli have another playoff win?

If I was Baltimore I would make a strong pitch and Philip rivers
 
Oh, now it went from Brady being GOAT to Brady just doing what he had to do. Well let me tell you what Brady didn't do:

He didn't kick a 45 yard game winning field goal IN A BLIZZARD to advance his team to the AFC Championship game.

He didn't win the AFC Championship game to advance his team to the Superbowl.

He didn't kick a 48 yard field goal to win the Superbowl against the Lambs.

He didn't kick the game winning field goal against the Panthers in the Superbowl.

I'll tell you what Brady did do; he choked in the biggest game in NFL history.

If you break down the playoff games, Brady really hasn't done shit. He just got really really lucky.




GTFOH with that top 5 shit. You're man crushing on Brady and that's it. :smh:
Brady wins games. that what hes supposed to do. Thats what a QB supposed to do. because he doesnt have that many spectacular playoff heroics to your liking doesnt make him one of the top of all time.

Brady DID win those games. Brady got hurt in that AFC championship game. Brady didnt choke in the superbowl. he was composed. His O-line and defense choked.

Whether you like it or not Brady will be in GOAT convo if he wins a 4th superbowl;)
 
rady DID win those games.

BRADY DID NOT WIN THE GAMES LISTED. THIS ISN'T BASEBALL.


Brady got hurt in that AFC championship game.

HE DIDN'T WINT THAT GAME EITHER.

Brady didnt choke in the superbowl. he was composed. His O-line and defense choked.

TOM BRADY CHOKED AND STRAHAN KICKED HIS ASS.

Whether you like it or not Brady will be in GOAT convo if he wins a 4th superbowl;)

How can he be GOAT with a Superbowl defeat?

Terry Bradshaw > Tom Brady

You niggas just have a man crush on Brady, plain and simple.
 
Back
Top