I Know I might Get Banned For This But BGOL....Is this Guy The GOAT?

[Blunt]

You basically just described Dan Marino. And while he's in the discussion people always list the Montana's and Elway's above him.

Favre's had a better career than Marino.

 

[AwwSchitt]

Favre's had a better career than Marino.

Maybe. Buy there's no question that Marino was much more feared with the football in his hands than Farve.

 

[Ashy Larry]

Observe

 

[tuckdog]

ESPN's constant dick riding has created a nation of Favre haters, but it's not dudes fault. He is definitely in the convo no matter how many rings he has. Shit the dude that gets my vote doesn't have ANY rings, but have I ever seen a better QB.....NO!

 

[Les W]

Maybe. Buy there's no question that Marino was much more feared with the football in his hands than Farve.

ESPN's constant dick riding has created a nation of Favre haters, but it's not dudes fault. He is definitely in the convo no matter how many rings he has. Shit the dude that gets my vote doesn't have ANY rings, but have I ever seen a better QB.....NO!

You won't get any arguments from me

 

[D-TOWN REP]

 

[merce77]

 

[godofwine]

1 ring and a ton of bad interceptions

That 'bout sums it up. Manning only has one ring, too, but he was more consistant of a QB than Favre ever was.