Dwayne McDuffie's Estate Sues Over Milestone Media Revival

Drayonis

Thedogyears.com
BGOL Investor
dwayne-mcduffie.jpg

http://variety.com/2017/biz/news/dwayne-mcduffie-reginald-hudlin-milestone-media-1202512743/

Dwayne McDuffie, a pioneer of comic books with African-American heroes, died in 2011. Following his death, veteran producer Reginald Hudlin teamed with McDuffie’s former business partners to relaunch his company, Milestone Media, in tribute to the trailblazing artist.

But in a lawsuit filed Monday in L.A. Superior Court, the artist’s widow alleges that his estate was excluded from the revived company.

McDuffie wrote for Marvel and DC before launching Milestone Media in 1992 in an effort to bring greater representation of black heroes to comics. Milestone had a publishing agreement with DC Comics. McDuffie developed the characters Icon and Static, and produced a TV show, “Static Shock,” which aired on the WB network.

McDuffie died of complications from heart surgery at the age of 49. In 2015, Hudlin announced that he and McDuffie’s original partners would revive Milestone Media for a new generation of comics fans. Hudlin, who produced “Django Unchained” and directed the forthcoming Thurgood Marshall biopic “Marshall,” told the Washington Post that he and partners Derek Dingle and Denys Cowan hatched the idea to relaunch Milestone while gathered at McDuffie’s wake.

McDuffie’s widow, Charlotte McDuffie, alleges that his estate was excluded from the revived venture. At the time of his death, McDuffie owned 50% of Milestone Media, with Dingle owning the other half, the suit contends.

The three partners did not buy out McDuffie’s share of the company. Instead, they formed a new company called Milestone Media Company LLC, also referred to as “Milestone 2.0,” which took control of Milestone’s intellectual property, the suit alleges.

Charlotte McDuffie alleges that her inquiries about the new company have been met with “stalling and stonewalling tactics.” According to the suit, the new company is seeking to expand Milestone’s relationship with DC Comics, and is talking to other publishers about new projects, “all the while utilizing the intellectual property rightfully owned by Milestone, without compensation to Milestone or McDuffie’s estate, and without the consent of the Plaintiff or McDuffie’s heirs.”

The parties entered into a tolling agreement in April as they sought to settle the dispute. However, those talks appear to have broken down with the filing of the suit. In the agreement, Milestone’s partners issued a denial of the estate’s allegations.

Milestone’s attorney did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

His wife is right, I got love for Hudlin and the rest but you can't use the man's work without compensation to his estate.
 
Dwayne McDuffie’s Estate Sues Over Milestone Revival
24 hours agoby Tim Adamsin Comic NewsComment

Charlotte McDuffie, the widow of the late comic creator Dwayne McDuffie, has filed a lawsuit against the revived Milestone Media for neglecting to include McDuffie’s estate in the new venture.

According to Variety, the lawsuit alleges that at the time of his death in 2011 after complications from heart surgery, McDuffie owned 50% of Milestone Media, with Derek Dingle the owner of the other half. Instead of buying out McDuffie’s shares of the company, Dingle — along with Reginald Hudlin and Denys Cowan — formed Milestone Media Company LLC. Dubbed Milestone 2.0, the company planned to use characters that McDuffie and his partners made famous, like Static Shock and Icon. According to Hudlin, the idea for a Milestone relaunch originated when he met Dingle and Cowan at the former Marvel and DC writer’s wake.

Charlotte McDuffie claims she has met “stalling and stonewalling tactics” after inquiring about Milestone 2.0. The new company is working with DC Comics to launch an imprint with the Milestone heroes, while also negotiating with other publishers “all the while utilizing the intellectual property rightfully owned by Milestone, without compensation to Milestone or McDuffie’s estate, and without the consent of the Plaintiff or McDuffie’s heirs.”

RELATED: SDCC: DC Comics’ Milestone Update: “Still Moving Forward”

A tolling agreement was reached in April that sought to settle the dispute, but — with the filing of the lawsuit — those talks look to be off the table for the moment. In response, Milestone’s partners issued its own denial of the suit’s allegations.

Two years ago at Comic-Con International in San Diego, DC Comics announced plans for a revival of Milestone characterssuch as Static Shock and Icon, who represented a major push towards increase diversity in the 1990s. This followed a few months later after the initial announcement of Milestone 2.0. It’s been quiet on that front since, with virtually no updates in the interim.

“We’re still talking with Reggie [Hudlin],” DC Co-Publisher Jim Lee told CBR News at a press event last year, citing the busy schedule of Hudlin — in a leadership position of the new Milestone — as part of what’s affected the revival’s progress. “First off, he was a producer on the Academy Awards, he’s directing a movie based on a former Supreme Court member [Thurgood Marshall]. He just finished that up. We talk like once a week or so. It’s still moving forward, albeit at a slightly slower pace.”

Milestone’s comics debuted in the 1990s as part of a unique publishing partnership with DC. Milestone was a separate company, but its comics were published and distributed by DC, who shared the profits while Milestone retained creative control. Though the Milestone characters were originally depicted as existing in their own separate fictional universe, a later revival starting in 2008 saw them integrated into mainstream DC continuity. It’s not yet clear if the new material will interact with DC’s mainline titles.

Milestone Media was founded in 1993 by Denys Cowan, Derek T. Dingle, Michael Davis and the late Dwayne McDuffie, with the goal of promoting diversity in the comics industry through both its characters and behind-the-scenes talent, along with an emphasis on social issues.


http://www.cbr.com/dwayne-mcduffie-estate-milestone-revival/
 
DWAYNE MCDUFFIE's Widow Sues MILESTONE MEDIA Over Being 'Cut Out' Of Revival
By Chris Arrant, EditorAugust 1, 2017 03:32pm ET
aHR0cDovL3d3dy5uZXdzYXJhbWEuY29tL2ltYWdlcy9pLzAwMC8xODAvMjY3L2kwMi9NaWxlc3RvbmUtTWVkaWEtY2xhc3NpYy1wb3N0ZXIuanBn

Credit: Milestone Media
aHR0cDovL3d3dy5uZXdzYXJhbWEuY29tL2ltYWdlcy9pLzAwMC8xNDIvMDgzL2kzMDAvTWlsZXN0b25lX2xvZ28uanBnPzE0MjE4NTE0MjE=

Milestone Media logo
Credit: Milestone Media

Milestone Media is being sued by Charlotte McDuffie, the widow of the late co-founder Dwayne McDuffie. According to Los Angeles county court filings obtained by Variety, the widow is suing the company and its officers for "Breach of Fiduciary Duty," "Aiding and Abetting Breach of Fiduciary Duty," "Intentional Interference with Prospective Economic Relations," "Fraudulent Conveyance," "Civil Conspiracy To Commit Fraudulent Conveyance," and "Accounting."

McDuffie passed away as a result of complications from heart surgery in 2011 at the age of 49. In 2015, Hudlin joined Milestone Media to sprearhead a revival of the company - and announced a partnership with DC Entertainment soon after. According to Hudlin, the idea for Milestone's revival came out of a conversation which occurred during McDuffie's wake.

According to McDuffie's suit, the deceased owned a 50% stake in Milestone Media with co-founder Derek Dingle owning the other half. Court documents say that Dingle, Hudlin, and and co-founder Denys Cowan founded a new company - Milestone Media Company LLC - and began using the original Milestone Media's intellectual properties.

"The individual defendants here - Reginald Hudlin, Denys Cowan, and Derek Dingle - have engaged in reprehensible conduct following Dwayne McDuffie's untimely death," reads the lawsuit. "The beneficiaries of McDuffie's estate are his wife, Charlotte, and his 78-year-old mother, Edna. Hudlin, Cowan, and Dingle have literally stolen from McDuffie's widow and elderly mother, while pretending to downplay their theft as just 'two years of legal paperwork.'"

The suit alleges that the McDuffie estate entered a formal tolling agreement with Milestone in April as a means to settle the dispute, but the filing of this lawsuit infers that was unfruitful.

Here is the full lawsuit filing:



https://www.newsarama.com/35770-dwa...tone-media-over-being-cut-out-of-revival.html
 
Robert Kirkman’s Secret History of ComicsQ&A – Denys Cowan (Comic Artist and Milestone Comics Co-Founder)


Posted by Ashleen Wicklow

17 hours ago

secret-history-of-comics-shoc-105-denys-cowan-1200x707.jpg

Denys Cowan, comic artist and co-founder of Milestone Comics, discusses creating the creator-owned African-American comic imprint, what he would change from that time, and he teases new material for Milestone fans.

Q: In the episode, you talk about how you got the idea for Milestone, for creating these new black heroes, almost like a bolt of lightning. What was it like building this business from the ground up?

A: The whole “let’s create a comic book company that does these kinds of characters and we could do it independently” — that was a bolt of lightning. But the content of what we were talking about was just years of thinking about this kind of stuff. The actual process took about a year, and it was a year of trial and error — of writing things down, a lot of meetings, a lot of discussion whenever we had time to do it because we were all working full-time, so it was a lot of late nights ’til 12, 1 a.m. in the morning.

I think the hardest thing was keeping the whole thing a secret. It had to be a secret. We were young black professionals in the industry and here’s the thing — you start talking about stuff with different people outside of what you’re doing, and people come up with all kinds of reasons why you shouldn’t do it or why it’s a bad idea. “Nah, nah, man, that sucks, they’ll never let you do that.” We could have heard a lot of that while we were putting this together, but one of the things we did was swore each other to secrecy. We didn’t even speak about it if we were out in public, because we were that paranoid that either someone else would do it or that we would just hear stuff that was not going to help us. So, you create an atmosphere of relentless positivity that this is going to work because you’re not listening to anyone who says that it wouldn’t, who would stop you from doing what you’re doing. … So, when we gave it to Paul [Levitz, former President of DC Comics], it was as a total surprise. No one had any idea that any of us were working on anything like this. It was stunning to them – and completely blind naiveté by us that it would actually work.

Q: Were you surprised that Milestone resonated with so many fans?

A: We were very happy about it. In the middle of it, you don’t realize just how good it is. You’re just so busy working and trying to survive that you’re not even thinking of being particularly revolutionary. You’re just kind of doing it and getting through it. … We got all the responses that you might imagine because something like this hadn’t existed. The other thing I should emphasize is this: Milestone was not about black people. It was black people who founded it, but our main thrust was multiculturalism. It was not Black Power. Transgender people, gay people, women, minorities, with a focus on what we really knew — [multiculturalism] was our goal. That’s what Milestone was. So we got reactions not only from black people, but we got reactions from a whole spectrum of people who had been under-represented, or felt that they were.

Q: Is there something you’re most proud of that you accomplished at Milestone?

A: Probably I’m proudest of introducing this multicultural approach in comics where it had not existed before. That multicultural approach, I think, changed the face of comics. It would be awfully hard to create stereotypical black characters or a stereotypical anything because you’re kind of going backwards. It’s not a good look. A lot of things that have come out after Milestone trying to do what we did have failed, because it’s a particular blend of things, it’s a particular approach to things.

Q: The Milestone story is filled with many stranger-than-fiction movie moments and reconnections. Do you think Milestone could have been born without the initial relationship between you all, especially between you and Derek Dingle?

A: No. I think it would have been something totally different. There were other things that were formed by other people in different companies that came after us. But it was a particular combination of Derek and I, and Dwayne [McDuffie] and I, and Derek, Dwayne and Michael and I and Jim Owsley that made that possible. You take one person out of that group, it’s not the same, and it wouldn’t have happened. It happened precisely because those people were involved in the way that they were. I think it would have been something else and something totally different or created a character or two. But coming out with a force like that? No. With four books and 100 characters already? No.

Derek really did show up at my door. … And it was really like seeing a ghost. It was like, “What the hell?” He didn’t call, he didn’t say, “I’m on my way.” He just showed up in a way that people do not do anymore. People don’t show up and knock on your door and say, “Hey, how you doin’?” You’d be like, “What?”

Q: In the episode, you talk a lot about what you feel to be your own personal shortcomings in the legacy of Milestone. Would you change anything if you could go back?

A: Of course I would. I equated this in the film to being in a rock band… [and] how hard that is to keep four guys together, thinking the same way, doing the same things. The Rolling Stones are a miracle. They’re still together 55 years. The Beatles lasted 10 years… It’s hard keeping it together. My regret is that I couldn’t separate my own ego from the importance of the mission at that point, or the importance of what we were doing. And my regret is that I left the way I did, and it went down the way it did. I should have stayed and dealt with whatever problems there were head on, however painful they were, whatever form they took. Don’t ever leave, unless there’s no other way out. And it was not the best decision and [I have] a lot of regrets. Some regrets about the way we handled the situation with DC, even me personally, like I probably could have done more, I probably should have said something. Again, this comes back to the dynamics of the people. Once you take one person out of the equation, it changes the dynamic of everything. The Rolling Stones without Keith Richards is not the Rolling Stones… This is the same way. It’s not like I was Keith Richards, but when I left Milestone, the other three guys were kind of limping along. … If I was there, that would not have happened that way. Now it may have eventually killed me to stay, I don’t know, but continuing would have been a much better thing to do, to work it out and figure out a way to keep Milestone going.

Q: What kind of advice would you give your younger self?

A: If I could step back in time, I would counsel my young self the way I counsel my 26-year-old son now — which is [to have] patience. You’re in a hurry, you get everything done, but you learn so much by waiting, seeing how a situation will work out. Don’t react right away. Take your time, assess and then act. Don’t react emotionally to everything that happens, which is what you do when you’re younger. It’s all about your feelings. I would go back and tell my young self, “Don’t have any feelings!”

Q: The episode ends on a great high note that Milestone Media is coming back, and just recently, it was announced that five new Milestone books would come out in 2018. Can you talk more about what fans can expect about the future of Milestone?

A: I was there as part of the announcement… at New York Comic Con. We did a whole Milestone panel where [Robert] Kirkman came up and introduced the Milestone segment of his Secret History of Comicsand we talked about the new titles we were doing and showed the artwork and everything else and a reconstituted Milestone. So, yes, it’s back and it’s very exciting. It’s not the same as it was before. It’s not the same Milestone. Some of the same people are involved, me and Derek, but Dwayne isn’t around anymore and some of the other creative people have not participated as of yet. It’s different. It’s a band with new members. And we’re going to do some stuff that’s very exciting and very innovative and different and great, but it’s not 1992. It’s a different world. We’re all very excited and DC’s excited. Anytime people actually start paying money for something, they mean it. DC’s actually paying money to produce these books and get them done. We’re all really hyped about it.

Q: What are you most excited to bring to a new audience?

A: Even now, with all the comics there are now, there are some exceptions where some of the multicultural characters are written really well. But, for the most part, it’s still run by 55-year-old white guys who want to keep it exactly like it was. They’re jazzing up Superman. They’re jazzing up Batman. But they’re pretty comfortable and keeping it right where it is. That’s why you haven’t seen a whole lot of multicultural characters. That’s why the Black Panther’s such a big effing deal. To a big audience and especially to black people and people of color, it’s a huge deal because nothing much has changed. It’s not like they’ve had a whole lot of choices. It’s not like the Milestone stuff’s been continually in print or you have a Static Shock movie. So what I want to bring to that new audience is the same excitement that we brought to the other audience for the same reason — because not much has changed. The world still needs these characters. The world still needs to be told these stories from this perspective… The new stuff we have is really going to shake people up because it’s still outside of anything that’s being done now in comics. So people are going to be like, “Oh my God, I can’t believe these guys are actually doing this.”

Q: It seems like the comic book audience is hungry for this new material.

A: Yeah, they are. I think they’re hungry to see new characters. As great as the experiment was, and I think it was really cool, seeing old characters like Spider-Man, and even though Miles Morales is a great character, but it’s still Spider-Man, now he’s black. It’s still Captain America, but he’s the black Captain America. Or Superman, but he’s black Superman. That stuff is okay, but it’s not the real thing. Very good story, very good stuff, but it’s not really original characters with an original viewpoint. That’s still missing, and that’s what we’re going to bring back.

Read an interview with Jeffery Moulton, author of The Superhero Response: How 9/11 Changed Our Superheroes and Why It Matters.
 
Back
Top