dear NFL: ABOLISH instant replay

[cranrab]

prior to this evening, i had been a proponent of instant replay.

but after tonight's CRIMINALLY incompetent call which resulted in the nullification of a raider TD, instant replay has proven to be WORTHLESS.

the raider WR murphy caught the ball in the end zone, landed on his feet, and when he fell to the ground the ball was jarred loose.

but you could see that he had COMPLETE control of the ball IN HIS HANDS because the LACES NEVER MOVED.

the officials reviewed the play and nullified the TD.

 

[doggish_098]

if that call is correct then you can argue that if i dive over the goal and lose the ball when i hit the ground that shouldnt count either.

 

[cranrab]

if that call is correct then you can argue that if i dive over the goal and lose the ball when i hit the ground that shouldnt count either.

similar, but even WORSE.

because the WR murphy LANDED WITH TWO FEET DOWN.

it wasn't until after he was tackled and turned face down by the defender that the ball hit the turf and came loose.

nevermind the fact that he had already caught the ball (no bobbling, no juggling), and landed with both feet clearly in bounds.



disgusting.

 

[360KNOWLEDGE2]

prior to this evening, i had been a proponent of instant replay.

but after tonight's CRIMINALLY incompetent call which resulted in the nullification of a raider TD, instant replay has proven to be WORTHLESS.

the raider WR murphy caught the ball in the end zone, landed on his feet, and when he fell to the ground the ball was jarred loose.

but you could see that he had COMPLETE control of the ball IN HIS HANDS because the LACES NEVER MOVED.

the officials reviewed the play and nullified the TD.

Yeah, I was shocked when the Refs overturned that play. Pure BS

 

[Lord Vicious]

if that call is correct then you can argue that if i dive over the goal and lose the ball when i hit the ground that shouldnt count either.

If you even break the plane with possession.....it's good.It doesn't matter what happens after you hit the ground/if the ground causes a fumble.(which by NFL rules is not possible)