AllState17 said:
So its just gonna happen because he plays defense right?
Name me a single other player in the NFL who does it as consistently as he does it, and has drawn not only fines but now a suspension as well because of that same tackle. I mean, if its just a case of being on d, then its a call we should see somewhat regularly no? Kind of like a facemask or interference.
Name me a single other player and you have a point.
There is no other player in the league that gets this call more often than Roy Williams. He is the reason they initiated this very rule correct?
DJCANDLE said:
"Williams plays a position that engages contact on almost every play. It's gonna happen."
Do you ever see Tiki Barber horsecollaring DE's?
How about Tom Brady chopping down DB's?
Or Carson Palmer blocking in the back?
No. You don't. And you know why you don't? Because they play positions that don't engage these rules.
If I we're to say that "Palmer plays a position that where throwing an interception is possible on every down. It's gonna happen."
By your current logic, you're sitting there telling me that "it's not an offensive thing, show me a player who does the same thing??"
Son, where did I ever state it was an offensive thing? Where? Let's get our weight up in the comprehension department a lil bit.
When you make a tackle, you go with your instinct. Which is what he does. And which my previous point. Not once did I argue that he shouldn't have been fined or suspended, nor did I state that playing on defense is
the sole reason of seeing this call. No where.
If you interpreted it that way, that's a you problem. But it's written there as clear as day.
Again, playing to your vanity, there is no player in the league who gets
called for this more than Roy Williams.
Now, tell me that you've never seen anyone in the league from a defensive standpoint ever pull this move, not even once, I will concede my point entirely. Just once, tell me that Roy Williams is the only player that has ever done this move, regardless of repeated offenses, just tell me one time.
Now i'm going to ask you what the hell anything you said, had to do with what I previously posted?
"Fine and suspend dude if you must, but to call him a weak, and a dirty player because he hasn't learned to break from his instinct?"
AllState17 said:
Until then you are left trying to explain why everybody else on the field who plays defense seem to be intelligent enough to know the rules of the game, while he doesnt. Or better yet, how come everyone else watching the games realize that he does it on purpose, and you seem to be slow in coming to the same conclusion. Listen, he does this on the regular, get it now?
You know, the beauty of the world, is that some people comprehend things faster than others. With that said, I ask you this...
Where in my rant did I ever argue this point? Ever. Show me.
"Fine and suspend dude if you must,
but to call him a weak, and a dirty player because he hasn't learned to break from his instinct?"
Compelling.
