First Edwin Díaz, now Pete Alonso: Where do Mets go from here?
New York Mets President of Baseball Operations David Stearns will have to pivot after letting several players leave in free agency. George Walker IV / AP Images
By
Will Sammon
Dec. 10, 2025Updated 7:27 pm EST
ORLANDO, Fla. — New York Mets officials keep pointing to the calendar, accurately noting that two months remain until the start of spring training.
Plenty of time? Maybe. Either way, they sound confident that before that point, they’ll feature a competitive roster.
Yes, despite losing
closer Edwin Díaz (Los Angeles Dodgers) and
first baseman Pete Alonso (Baltimore Orioles) to free agency in consecutive days.
Advertisement
Give owner Steve Cohen, president of baseball operations David Stearns and the rest of the Mets front office this much: They are disciplined in their process.
How else do you explain letting franchise stalwarts and All-Star players such as Díaz and Alonso walk? In the case of Díaz, their offer was beaten. As for Alonso, they barely bothered to play.
Both cases tell a similar story, though.
The Mets evaluated their core from the past few years and found it wanting. In 2024, their group earned the runway for another chance because of a magical second half. After 2025, the Mets’ front office decided the magic ran out.
The Mets neglected to make Pete Alonso an offer once the range went beyond their comfort zone.Ishika Samant / Getty Images
For Díaz and Alonso, the Mets operated with discipline. With Díaz, the Mets’ latest offer
wasn’t more than what the Dodgers ended up giving him. With Alonso, they
neglected to make an offer once the range went beyond their comfort zone.
Top MLB Stories
With Pete Alonso signing, Orioles prove they're ready to be bold
Rosenthal: The Mets' core is no more. And now their front office needs to deliver
What we're hearing about the Braves, Reds and Blue Jays as MLB's Winter Meetings continue
It sounds like a disciplined approach will continue.
The way the Mets view it, they have two superstar players in Juan Soto and Francisco Lindor, plus an impressive farm system brimming with pitchers. They plan to complement Soto and Lindor with good players. The question remains how, and how good will those players be?
The bigger-name free agent position players, such as Kyle Tucker and Cody Bellinger, may emerge as targets at some point; ditto some of the bigger-name free agent pitchers. The guess is that the Mets are going to wait things out, be opportunistic and try to cash in if a premium player’s market is falling short of projection.
Again, discipline.
In previous free-agent classes, the Mets have taken selective shots and gone all-in on a player or two. Last year, it was Soto. Perhaps this year’s group does not contain such a player to their liking. Perhaps they don’t want to get stuck with a long contract that ages poorly and becomes difficult to move.
Advertisement
In the meantime, expect them to pursue different trade paths.
The Mets need to decide how to best leverage their farm system. Which players do they allow space for in the major leagues? Which ones do they trade? The plan from here is likely to include some combination.
In particular, need-for-need trades involving major-league players are appealing to the Mets, league sources said.
Such an approach may or may not lead to headliners. For example, the Mets hold some interest in St. Louis Cardinals outfielder Lars Nootbaar, league sources said. More speculatively, San Diego Padres outfielder Ramón Laureano would present another match. Those are just a couple of names out of many possibilities.
It’s too early to run down many others; league sources described the Winter Meetings as slow for the Mets, at least on the acquisition side.
It’s a similar situation for the bullpen. The Mets hold interest in free agent reliever Tyler Rogers and continued to check in on free agent Robert Suarez, among others, league sources said. Price matters.
If this is the Mets’ approach, it comes with risks. Rival evaluators say Stearns is good at reading and reacting to markets. He demonstrated as much at the trade deadline, making deals that the industry lauded for relievers Rogers, Gregory Soto and Ryan Helsley, plus outfielder Cedric Mullins. It still backfired.
Yet the style continues. Following such a process requires allowing star players to walk. Not overreacting requires guts and conviction. Time will tell if it leads to success.