Official 2025 NFL Discussion preseason edition!!!

Aikman had emmit, Irving, novacek, the moose , that offensive line and defense to hide his flaws.. like I said go look at their numbers it’s literally no comparison.. Eli had twice as many td passes multiple 30+ td passes( aikman has none), twice as many Super Bowl MVPs and didn’t have emmit or Irvin as his offensive weapons.. it’s no way you can look at aikman stats and say yeah that’s hall of fame numbers..the most td passes he had in a season was like 22.. yet he had the same amount of ints in a yr.. in fact several seasons he had more int than td passes.. numbers don’t lie.. aikman was considered the best cause the team he was on not for his actual production.. hell his stats make him look like a serviceable qb at best

32,942 yds 165 tds

57,023 366 tds

Now tell me which 1 sounds like they should be in the hall of fame and which 1 shouldn’t be
Don’t start this shit lol. Eli and Aikman played in two different eras. Eli played in a passing era go look at Eli stats next to anyone like Romo or Rivers or Big Ben lol…..

This the Jalen Hurts argument…we gonna discredit him because his GM built a good team around him.

Aikman also played in of the greatest eras ever for quarterbacks….
 
Really,you comparing Troy to Eli


Troy was considered a top five quarterback during his time despite the Cowboys running the ball most of the time....


Nobody..I mean nobody considered Eli a top five let alone a top ten quarterback in his era. Eli was always a middle of the pack quarterback

The only thing I'll give you about Eli was that he played well during the playoffs but that lone shouldn't make him a Hall of Famer.





I think you should be on an All-Decade list,All Pro,have at least 5 Pro Bowls,how well you play at your position for most of your career and playoff success. If,you don't hit four of the five criteria then you shouldn't be in the Hall of Fame.
I agree. I think you should have a complete resume especially in today’s game. All of these guys are gonna have high passing system because it’d a passing league. Game is much faster. So all them empty stats don’t mean shit to me. Hall of Fame should be for the elite.

Eli was ass. He had two great playoff runs…we will always remember. He never had a year where he was even a top 5 QB let alone top 2.
 
Are you still questioning my ideology on the bears season @dtownsfinest ? Under 8.5 wins do it bet it
Naw I don’t trust nothing in shorts. I done seen it every year. They hype people up we will never hear from again……and they bash guys….

I remember they shitted on Dak all training camp long bringing up his interceptions in training camp. Months later he was an All Pro and had his best season. I don’t trust shit this time of the year.
 
Don’t start this shit lol. Eli and Aikman played in two different eras. Eli played in a passing era go look at Eli stats next to anyone like Romo or Rivers or Big Ben lol…..

This the Jalen Hurts argument…we gonna discredit him because his GM built a good team around him.

Aikman also played in of the greatest eras ever for quarterbacks….
Stay out the argument and let that man defend his stance…. Switch these guy stats around and would you say aikman didn’t deserve to go to the hall of fame if he had 57,000 passing yards 366 td and 2 Super Bowl MVPs and Eli deserved to go if he only had 32, 000 166 td passes and 1 Super Bowl mvp? Romo and rivers didn’t win shit unlike somebody name Eli in fact he won it twice and got the mvp.. no hurts isn’t like aikman cause his stats is better his first 5 yrs from throwing td and rushing tds and let’s not combine the 2.. also hurts didn’t throw double digit amount of ints his first 4 seasons like aikman did( he had 9 double digit int seasons).. the fact is hurts could literally say ya give me grief but there’s a cac in the hall of fame name aikman that literally whole career is riding his team coattails.. if ya can give that dude hall of fame status shutdafucup and let me rock
 
Nicki Minaj and Dez Bryant beefing was not on my radar lol. Nicki started the shit. i have no idea why she went after Dez over Jaz-Z shit. She lost her mind.
















This the most retarded shit they was on the same team then she forgot and went on one of her coke rants. :lol: she gotta leave that powder alone. :lol:

Dez went from “have a nice day” to “say bitch….”. :lol:
 
Stay out the argument and let that man defend his stance…. Switch these guy stats around and would you say aikman didn’t deserve to go to the hall of fame if he had 57,000 passing yards 366 td and 2 Super Bowl MVPs and Eli deserved to go if he only had 32, 000 166 td passes and 1 Super Bowl mvp? Romo and rivers didn’t win shit unlike somebody name Eli in fact he won it twice and got the mvp.. no hurts isn’t like aikman cause his stats is better his first 5 yrs from throwing td and rushing tds and let’s not combine the 2.. also hurts didn’t throw double digit amount of ints his first 4 seasons like aikman did( he had 9 double digit int seasons).. the fact is hurts could literally say ya give me grief but there’s a cac in the hall of fame name aikman that literally whole career is riding his team coattails.. if ya can give that dude hall of fame status shutdafucup and let me rock
Dude is a straight weirdo, he try to bring hurts down with mid QBs when he's way better than them. Goes to show hurts living rent free in their head having SB MVP to his name as well. Hell there's nothing else to talk about about because their QB Dak is so shitty they don't even talk about him as much or at all.
 
Back
Top