Colorado's transfer portal exodus is historic, expected and risky
By CHRIS HUMMER6 hrs
Share96 Comments
Deion Sanders told us this would happen.
In the “everything is content” world that is the Coach Sanders experience, fans and media members alike received a candid peek into Sanders’ first team meeting with the Colorado Buffaloes. Not only did Sanders claim he’d bring in his own luggage (aka players) to Boulder – Louis Vuitton, of course – but he straight up told his newly inherited roster he planned to recruit over the majority of them.
“When I get there, it’s going to be changed,”
Sanders said. “So, I want y’all to get ready to go ahead and jump in that portal and do whatever you’re going to get, because the more of you jump into (the portal), the more room you make because we bring in kids that are smart, tough.”
Jump they did.
A staggering 46 scholarship players from Colorado's 2022 roster have entered the transfer portal since the 2022-23 portal cycle opened,
including more than a dozen during a portal barrage Monday after the team's spring game.
Colorado had just over 80 scholarship players to start last season. Only 20 of those players
were left on the roster by the end of Monday evening.
Let me repeat that again: TWENTY.
Between graduation, professional declarations and transfers (many of whom were cut), more than 70% of the team’s scholarship allotment from last season has now departed. That’s historic turnover. We’ve never seen anything like this in college football.
This is only possible because of recent rule changes. The transfer portal allows for teams to turn over their roster quickly. And an NCAA policy change, which green-lights teams to sign up to their 85-scholarship maximum each season instead of being limited to 25 initial counters a cycle, gives new coaches nearly unlimited flexibility to turn over the rosters they inherited. Armed with historic freedom, Coach Prime is testing the limits on how far you can push the idea of a one-year roster makeover.
Rebuilds usually take years, so it’s great, conceptually, to take over a team and sign all your own recruits in a single swoop. If you could bring in your own players all at once, it’d greatly reduce the time it takes to turn a 1-11 roster into a contender. However, that assumes there are enough good players out there to fill your roster the way it needs to be filled. Right now, I’d really question if that’s the case for Colorado.
This is not to say the Buffaloes haven’t had their portal successes. They have! Colorado’s 2023 transfer portal class ranks No. 1 nationally. The Buffaloes have signed 29 players so far, a group that includes multiple plug-and-play starters and the No. 1 player in the portal rankings,
Travis Hunter. It’s an excellent class, one that will only continue to grow – Colorado is in the mix for several top portal targets like Georgia’s Marcus Washington, Florida State’s Derrick McClendon and Old Dominion’s
Chazz Wallace – well beyond that 29-player group.
The issue is you eventually run out of players to add.
To call the number of starting-quality Power Five talent in the spring portal cycle “limited” would be kind. It’s been slow. While there are good players to add, Colorado isn’t the only one fighting for a small number of quality additions. They’re competing with aggressive, more established teams for players at critical positions like offensive line, defensive line and wide receiver.
The Buffaloes will win some of those battles. Sanders is a proven cult of personality who can pull off the seemingly impossible in recruiting. How else does he land
Travis Hunter (twice) and
Cormani McClain in back-to-back cycles? But will they win enough to make up for the program’s massive scholarship hole? That’s doubtful.
Sanders may be fine losing the major of players who’ve bounced from his program – only seven of the 32 scholarship players from Colorado’s 2022 class remain,
per The Athletic – but depth matters in college football.
Experienced starters like
Montana Lemonious-Craigand
Tyrin Taylor would’ve helped Colorado this year. Promising young players like wide receiver
Jordyn Tyson and linebacker
Aubrey Smith certainly would’ve aided the program long term. Instead, they and so many others have departed or were forced to depart.
This strategy might ultimately work for Sanders. He’s an elite recruiter and now has room to add quality transfers and make a run at a massive and impactful 2024 class. But there are great risks to this approach, too. Depth matters in college football. Continuity does, too. Sanders is taking both ideas and tossing them aside much like he did with most of the roster he inherited.