Good post, OP. Bad forum, HNIC.
I'll address the point you keep making about the immigrant Blacks first then I'll get to the others.
You keep mentioning that the immigrant Blacks are more likely to have college degrees, therefore they aren't starting behind. I guess you're ignoring the whole first portion of their life. They get degrees because culturally that's what's instilled in them to get it. That's CULTURE. and yes, they DO starts behind , because we're talking about first generation. So yes, of course I read it.
Secord ,your article talks a lot about Human Capital. That's exactly what I'm saying. At this current time in history, if anyone gets skills that are useful, they will win. Also, it helps if they get married , and stay out of dumb shit. Those are just a few of the things ANYONE can do to avoid poverty, no matter what color they are.
You seem to think I'm saying there's no such thing as racism. No,I'm saying it ain't a major issue to Black people, especially as far as.money
. In reference to my knowledge of west African cultures , you hit it on the head. Racism is not new and it definitely existed IN West Africa and all over the world. It's called cultural differemces and dominance of one or another. And culture goes beyond color. You're not comparing polish to iriish, to wasps , to Jews , who clearly make more money than all other whites. black people are disproportionately represented in entertainment and sports? Is that because those two aren't racist, or is because our culture focused on those industries and kicked shit over anyway. A culture determined makes shit happen. Racism doesn't have to end in order for anyone to succeed. And even with that, by law, there's much less racism here than ever before. You can tell me all day about disparities, it's the conclusions on why. There's just so many variables. And yes, I'm talking Thomas Sowell talking points.
Depends on who you ask.
He would say yes:![]()
He would say no:![]()
That's a good question. You asked about the culture of the immigrants. I'm not saying they're COMING from a superior culture. They're RUNNING from somewhere much worse , so they have a culture of APPRECIATION. Also, the home.country is losing a valuable brain , because of a terrible leader. At home for them, is like being home here for us, EXCEPT, They also have the disadvantage of an even worse infrastructure, government , etc. And on top of all that, they now BENEFIT, from the work OUR ancestors built with our FORMER culture.Then I'm going to ask you the question I like to ask any immigrant who touts their "cultural" superiority. Why is their home country struggling? If West Indians have a superior cultural orientation towards education, why haven't they produced a Singapore? If West Africans have a superior cultural orientation, then why aren't any of the nations on the level of say, South Korea?
The reality is that these immigrants are coming from the educated middle classes in their home countries, and are producing a "brain drain" as well, which is another discussion.
And here's a little more food for thought for your immigrant theories:
“U.S. black descendants and black Caribbean descendants, primarily Haitians, Jamaicans, Trinidadians and Tobagonians, and blacks with Latin or Hispanic heritage, are more economically similar than Latins of various ancestral origin who self-identify as white as opposed to black,” the authors write. For Hamilton, the data show that the experience of being black in Miami is a uniquely difficult one, even accounting for different ethnic or ancestral origins.“In terms of identification, overwhelmingly, Latin Census respondents self-classify as either racially white or ‘other,’ while a small fraction chose a racially black identity,” the authors write. “Self-reported white Latin individuals attain higher economic outcomes, despite having only slightly higher educational attainment than their racially self-reported black counterparts.” Indeed, education appeared to do little to close the wealth gap among Miami households of different ethnicities.
Yes, assuming they have access to a quality education that is exempt from bias. Camille just posted a bunch of articles on this specific issue. Or just go study some Jonathan Kozol.
For someone who is touting education, you are willfully ignoring every single academic source being cited in this discussion.
No offense, but this is the dumbest thing you've have said so far. Do you want to retract it before I eviscerate it?
I said West African history, not cultures. And when you control for culture and education, you still see these vast disparities. That's the point of this discussion.
Read the whole thread. Too many to post.
He drops gems
Here's the whole thread in an article format
![]()
Thread by @michaelharriot: "Everyone's talking about impeachment and Clinton & Johnson as the only presidents ever impeached. But most people don't know WHY Johnson […]"
Thread by @michaelharriot: "Everyone's talking about impeachment and Clinton & Johnson as the only presidents ever impeached. But most peY Johnson was impeached. So let me tell you the story about how not impeaching a racist president is a BIG re […]"threadreaderapp.com