Charlie from chocolate factory was supposed to be black

TEN

Tensei - Admin
Staff member
The hero of Roald Dahl's Charlie and the Chocolate Factory was meant to be black, the author's widow has revealed.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-41257684
Liccy Dahl told BBC Radio 4's Today programme her husband had written about a "little black boy".

But Dahl's agent thought the idea a bad one and insisted the character be changed - something Dahl's widow said was a "great pity

She said seeing the 1964 children's book as her husband had intended it would be "wonderful".
A Lego version of Charlie outside Manchester Central LibraryImage copyrightPA

A Lego version of Charlie - with his golden ticket - has been unveiled in Manchester
The programme's interview with Mrs Dahl and her late husband's biographer, Donald Sturrock, took place on the 101st anniversary of Dahl's birth.

Sturrock told Today that Dahl knew both the British and American sensibilities and had "a foot in both camps" - the reason, his widow said, behind Charlie Bucket's original ethnicity.

"His first Charlie that he wrote about, you know, was a little black boy," she said. "I'm sure that was influenced by America."
"It was his agent who thought it was a bad idea, when the book was first published, to have a black hero," said Sturrock. "She said: 'People would ask why.'"

Dahl didn't escape some controversy about depictions of race after Charlie and the Chocolate Factory was published in 1964. In the first edition, Oompa-Loompas were depicted as black pygmies.
But it was decided his description wasn't acceptable and for the second edition they were changed and given "rosy-white" skin. For the first Charlie and the Chocolate Factory movie, film-makers made them orange.

Speaking to Radio 4, Mrs Dahl also revealed her husband had not enjoyed that original film.
"He wasn't very happy about Charlie, the original with Gene Wilder," she said of the film, released in 1971 as Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory.
In contrast, Dahl's widow said his first meeting Sir Quentin Blake, who illustrated his books, was altogether happier.
"You knew straight away," said Mrs Dahl. "I was witnessing a rather amazing union."

Earlier this year it was announced that Dahl - whose birthday is now celebrated as 'Roald Dahl Day"' - will be played by Hugh Bonneville in an upcoming film biopic.
 
It was great pity but she didn't say shit all these years.
mouthshut.jpg~c200
 
It was great pity but she didn't say shit all these years.
who was sticking a camera or a mic in front the HER face all this time? It's strange that someone cares what she says now even now. I can't see how this would've made anything much different, him being a Black boy anyway.

Beyond that, he DEFINITELY based the oompa loompas on little pygmies, and made them stupid.
 
did not know this !
think about it, the book was about a kid in britain during the time of the chocolate factory boom. And where does all the cocoa come from?

At that time, mainly Ghana, so it doesn't really make sense that they wouldve been Pygmies, but Europe was also in the Congo at that time, so I'm sure it all just tied together for a guy who had never been there. "Heart of darkness" and all those Tarzan stories were what he would've been influenced by. So, I don't see how he would've been thinking to make the main character a Black kid, since it was really kinda based on HIM anyway.
 
think about it, the book was about a kid in britain during the time of the chocolate factory boom. And where does all the cocoa come from?

At that time, mainly Ghana, so it doesn't really make sense that they wouldve been Pygmies, but Europe was also in the Congo at that time, so I'm sure it all just tied together for a guy who had never been there. "Heart of darkness" and all those Tarzan stories were what he would've been influenced by. So, I don't see how he would've been thinking to make the main character a Black kid, since it was really kinda based on HIM anyway.

Not debating it...just didn't know......but after reading that Charlie was supposed to be black...made total sense !!!

.
 
Not debating it...just didn't know......but after reading that Charlie was supposed to be black...made total sense !!!

.
Actually it DOESNT make sense. The kid was mostly based off of the author as a child. The author is white.

The cocoa to make chocolate comes from Africa .
 
Actually it DOESNT make sense. The kid was mostly based off of the author as a child. The author is white.

The cocoa to make chocolate comes from Africa .
makes sense in that if charlie was meant to be black...the oompa loompas might also be black...stop analyzing the shit out of everything.....like ur trying to crack the alarm system at fort knox !!!!!!!!!:hmm:

.
 
makes sense in that if charlie was meant to be black...the oompa loompas might also be black...stop analyzing the shit out of everything.....like ur trying to crack the alarm system at fort knox !!!!!!!!!:hmm:

.
How is it analyzing that a guy who made a character based off of himself really meant to make himSELF white?

You tell me how it makes sense that he meant to make himSELF Black?

This isn't deep at all. You were happy when I told you the oompa loompahs were black though Lmao
 
How is it analyzing that a guy who made a character based off of himself really meant to make himSELF white?

You tell me how it makes sense that he meant to make himSELF Black?

This isn't deep at all. You were happy when I told you the oompa loompahs were black though Lmao
I just fucking explained to you what I was thinking and why.....you took it to another tangent...and you're doing it againend of story!!!! Is ur brain to big for your head or something !!!:hmm::hmm::hmm::hmm::hmm::hmm::hmm::hmm::hmm::hmm::hmm:...........................:hmm:

.
 
I just fucking explained to you what I was thinking and why.....you took it to another tangent...and you're doing it againend of story!!!! Is ur brain to big for your head or something !!!:hmm::hmm::hmm::hmm::hmm::hmm::hmm::hmm::hmm::hmm::hmm:...........................:hmm:

.
Youre not making sense at all. I'll slow it down for you.

There's proof that they oompa Loompas WERE black. He changed them later. They were based off characters in africa. There's pictures of his original book and how he described them. He changed it in the 70s. And it wasn't a positive description. He played them as stereotypical slaves. there are copies of those books still around.

There's NO proof that Charlie was supposed to be Black except his wife saying it now. And since he character was based on the author himself or makes NO sense that he wouldve originally intended for it to be a black boy.

If you watch here, his DAUGHTER says that Willy Wonka was based on HIM. So somebody is mistaken. 12:00 mark



Go further and you'll hear them say that even in the movie he wanted to cast HIMSELF instead of Gene Wilder.


I suspect this new story is a way of pandering to the politically correct years after he was already corrected by the NAACP for his original flaw. I bet there's a movie rehash coming out.
 
Last edited:
Youre not making sense at all. I'll slow it down for you.

There's proof that they oompa Loompas WERE black. He changed them later. They were based off characters in africa. There's pictures of his original book and how he described them. He changed it in the 70s. And it wasn't a positive description. He played them as stereotypical slaves. there are copies of those books still around.

There's NO proof that Charlie was supposed to be Black except his wife saying it now. And since he character was based on the author himself or makes NO sense that he wouldve originally intended for it to be a black boy.

If you watch here, his DAUGHTER says that Willy Wonka was based on HIM. So somebody is mistaken. 12:00 mark



Go further and you'll hear them say that even in the movie he wanted to cast HIMSELF instead of Gene Wilder.


I suspect this new story is a way of pandering to the politically correct years after he was already corrected by the NAACP for his original flaw. I bet there's a movie rehash coming out.

tumblr_nbipn2_Gc971rrx588o1_500.gif

You suure ain't no king....
and I can definitely........
understand why you've been exiled !!!
:smh::smh::hmm::smh::smh:

.
 
Back
Top