I'm not saying CP3 is overrated in comparison to anybody, I am saying he is overrated because he's overrated. Bringing up other player doesn't make him less overrated. This is you trying to move the goal post.
And as far as the players you've mentioned, just for giggles lets see:
Westbrook - took a team with a bad coach and flaws to the finals
Rose - former league MVP
Kyrie - has been hurt most of his career
the only one close to being validated is Wall, yet he is still early in his career
And NONE of them has had the amount of flameouts that Paul has. No team is without flaws, but that choke job against the Rockets last year was beyond embarrassing, fucking humiliating, and CP3 was the best player on the team that choked!!
His Clippers team is flawed?! Stop with the plea coppin bruh, they were flawed enough to go up 3-1 though right?! A PGs job is to direct his team and right the shit, and CP3 failed HORRIBLY with that last year, and many times before that.
Now, show me, based on the list you named, another player on that list, who choked even remotely to the magnitude of a CP3 lead team last year, against a team who's PGs were Prigioni and Jason Terry?!?
Dude is overrated point blank end of story