The problem is she seemed to be providing for lack of better words internet answers. She didn't even seem to even believe anything she was saying. For example, wanting someone who was god fearing but didn't need to go to church every Sunday or just occasionally. At best, she meant spiritual. At worse, she doesn't value that trait at all but it sounds good.
She was attractive but doesn't seem comfortable with who she is. Could have also been women especially attractive women aren't use to being on the receiving end. She didn't know what to say because women don't outright pursue/approach men. And, it's a game show so the men will front unlike in the real world. In the real world, she could have said the most ridiculous shit ever and more than half of those men would still if nothing else try to fuck.