I also think they jumped the shark on her character development too soon.One of the critiques I heard was that her character's sort of become a caricature of itself, and I can see what the critic was getting at.
@playahaitian - like we talked about a year or two back ... one thing we both dug was that scene with her sister near the end of the 1st season. More serious in tone with the sister questioning why she'd come around, being estranged and all.
I'd like to see more about that. More on her / their backstory.
I have enjoyed the guest stars / cameos ... but give us more of Poker Face herself, seeing as she arrives sometimes 12 - 20 mins into the episode.
If they took it slow and showed a more grounded side of her like you said, the character could've had more realistic directions to move.
But instead, it seems like they're throwing everything at the wall trying to make something stick: Steve Buscemi on the CB radio, leggy outfits to push a sex appeal that is just barely there to me, another pointless fling (this time with a main character), etc.
Her connection with the Sister would take the Columbo shtick out of the equation for at last a breather. Shit, her friend got murdered and literally changed the course of her life. Go back to that town for some closure. Another missed opportunity to show some depth and still be entertaining.
I'm not a good writer, but someone with say so and real skill just sat back and let the "meh" work its way into this series.
*I may be reaching, but I think that other show "High Potential" put some pressure on the direction of this season.*