Re: Zimbabwe bars team of black U.S. trade unionists
<font size="5"><center>Zimbabwe: Mugabe - Virtually Alone And Frightened</font size></center>
Financial Gazette (Harare)
COLUMN
March 21, 2007
Posted to the web March 22, 2007
By Bornwell Chakaodza
Harare, Zimbabwe
Will he get to 2008 given pressure that is mounting both internally and externally?
THE consequences may be significant. Its conduct cannot be other than counter-productive.
I am referring here not only to the exceptionally brutal if not barbaric attack on the leaders of opposition political parties and their torture while in detention eleven days ago but also to the way President Robert Mugabe shot himself in the foot on all fronts by his over-reaction to the international condemnation and indignation over the brutal assault of political activists by the Zimbabwean police.
Yes, President Mugabe's "Go Hang" speech and his reading the riot act to Western ambassadors for their alleged interference in Zimbabwe's internal affaires are indeed tell tale signs of a regime in deep trouble.
I hold no candle myself for some of these Western governments as they have in the past supported and propped up undemocratic and unsavoury regimes in Africa -- purely for their own selfish interests. But in our situation at the present moment, for the government of Zimbabwe to say what they said was, in terms of foreign relations, an extraordinarily inept and naïve thing to do, even for a government not known for its delicacy of diplomacy.
It is bravado to no purpose on the part of President Mugabe. Moreso given the desperate situation in which the majority of Zimbabweans find themselves in.
Zimbabwe is now in a state of economic collapse. The situation is spinning out of control and the international community cannot rightly stand by and watch a once proud and successful country go over the cliff
On top of all this, a humanitarian catastrophe is looming in the light of 2007 being declared a drought year by government, not only as a result of poor and erratic rains across the country but also bad policies and the unending disruptions and invasions on the farms.
There are maize shortages in both South Africa and Zambia -- our traditional suppliers. Even if maize was plentiful in these countries, where will the money to import it come from given the economic crisis that shows no signs of abetting here? A very gloomy prognosis indeed! Zimbabwe is indeed in a real bind here.
It is not only the West, which is gravely concerned about our situation here. President Mugabe's bedrock of support in Africa in general and SADC in particular is turning against him now, thanks to a recent campaign of political repression, which resulted in the injuries of MDC leaders and activists, which were truly awful.
Opinion of African leaders across the continent is now shifting away from ZANU PF and in favour of the majority of Zimbabweans. However slight, this is a welcome development, which has long been overdue.
Ghanaian President and African Union chairman John Kufuor is on record as having said last week that the situation in Zimbabwe is embarrassing to the continent. "We want accountable government", Kufuor bluntly said.
Zambian President Levy Mwanawasa echoed the same sentiments when he said: "Recent political developments in Zimbabwe are of great concern to us" while the South African Deputy Foreign Minister Aziz Pahad said "South Africa urges the Zimbabwean government to ensure that the rule of law including respect for human rights for all Zimbabweans and leaders of various parties is respected".
In a rare and unusual step of censuring a fellow UN member state, the UN Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon said the attacks on opposition political leaders "violate the basic democratic rights of citizens to engage in peaceful assembly ".
Taken together, positions across the world are clearly hardening.
Certainly, the language is changing as amply demonstrated by President Kufuor and others. The emperor is now being stripped of his clothes. More and more leaders worldwide are abandoning the softly-softly approach to human rights violations in Zimbabwe that we had become accustomed to.
Images and pictures of a battered Morgan Tsvangirai and other opposition leaders shown on television around the world have clearly galvanised international opinion. President Mugabe and the ruling ZANU PF may want to continually ignore international condemnations but for how long? Is killing and beating up legitimate opposition leaders sustainable?
ZANU PF is clearly losing the propaganda war. We live in a world in which issues of good governance, rule of law, freedom of expression and freedom of association and assembly have become global standards by which all governments, and I mean all governments, are judged by the extent to which they adhere to these universal values. There is nothing Western or African about the universality of these attributes. It is in this regard that the Zimbabwean authorities should seriously think again on their ham-fisted clampdown.
Nothing will be achieved by police brutality. It is one thing to detain for whatever reason a legitimate opposition political leader within the framework of the law. It is quite another to mercilessly beat him up for no reason other than to want him dead -- kafira mberi in Shona. The wave of repression that was recently unleashed by the Zimbabwean authorities is choking and appalling to say the least.
Men and women of goodwill in ZANU PF must of necessity stand up and say enough is enough. The repression that is being carried out in their names is frankly unacceptable. The pictures of Nelson Chamisa bursting into tears on his hospital bed and Tsvangirai, Madhuku, Sekai Holland and Grace Kwinjeh battered, dazed and writhing in pain for merely engaging in a peaceful protest must make anyone pause and ask why they are so intent on inflicting such damage on fellow Zimbabweans.
A country grappling with a myriad of other problems does not need these kinds of brutal actions to muddy the already troubled waters.
We want all of us to live in peace. Creating solutions to our problems is what we need from ZANU PF and President Mugabe and not the language of war. The mayhem that we are seeing at the moment is practically damaging everything in this country, be it tourism or investment -- you name it and it is being destroyed.
I do think it is in the interest of ZANU PF to concentrate on weapons of mass salvation and not on weapons of mass destruction. Surely, the sight and sound of suffering of most people in this country must move any ZANU PF leader to precisely do this.
However, much as he dislikes it, President Mugabe must face reality that is staring him right in the face. The reality is that the President is facing an increasingly hostile world, both internally and externally. There are decided limits to his ambition of wanting to stand again in the 2008 general elections. God forbid! And these limits are again both internal (the people of Zimbabwe) and external (involving quite literally the whole of the international community, Africa included).
It is not too late to go the way of Nelson Mandela, Mr President. I mean here the passing of the torch, the passing of the baton well before 2008.
My final point to President Mugabe on this very issue is that the greatest force in life is goodwill, not a brutal police force. You had that goodwill once upon a time. Please show it again for the sake of our Zimbabwe.
http://allafrica.com/stories/200703220543.html
<font size="5"><center>Zimbabwe: Mugabe - Virtually Alone And Frightened</font size></center>
Financial Gazette (Harare)
COLUMN
March 21, 2007
Posted to the web March 22, 2007
By Bornwell Chakaodza
Harare, Zimbabwe
Will he get to 2008 given pressure that is mounting both internally and externally?
THE consequences may be significant. Its conduct cannot be other than counter-productive.
I am referring here not only to the exceptionally brutal if not barbaric attack on the leaders of opposition political parties and their torture while in detention eleven days ago but also to the way President Robert Mugabe shot himself in the foot on all fronts by his over-reaction to the international condemnation and indignation over the brutal assault of political activists by the Zimbabwean police.
Yes, President Mugabe's "Go Hang" speech and his reading the riot act to Western ambassadors for their alleged interference in Zimbabwe's internal affaires are indeed tell tale signs of a regime in deep trouble.
I hold no candle myself for some of these Western governments as they have in the past supported and propped up undemocratic and unsavoury regimes in Africa -- purely for their own selfish interests. But in our situation at the present moment, for the government of Zimbabwe to say what they said was, in terms of foreign relations, an extraordinarily inept and naïve thing to do, even for a government not known for its delicacy of diplomacy.
It is bravado to no purpose on the part of President Mugabe. Moreso given the desperate situation in which the majority of Zimbabweans find themselves in.
Zimbabwe is now in a state of economic collapse. The situation is spinning out of control and the international community cannot rightly stand by and watch a once proud and successful country go over the cliff
On top of all this, a humanitarian catastrophe is looming in the light of 2007 being declared a drought year by government, not only as a result of poor and erratic rains across the country but also bad policies and the unending disruptions and invasions on the farms.
There are maize shortages in both South Africa and Zambia -- our traditional suppliers. Even if maize was plentiful in these countries, where will the money to import it come from given the economic crisis that shows no signs of abetting here? A very gloomy prognosis indeed! Zimbabwe is indeed in a real bind here.
It is not only the West, which is gravely concerned about our situation here. President Mugabe's bedrock of support in Africa in general and SADC in particular is turning against him now, thanks to a recent campaign of political repression, which resulted in the injuries of MDC leaders and activists, which were truly awful.
Opinion of African leaders across the continent is now shifting away from ZANU PF and in favour of the majority of Zimbabweans. However slight, this is a welcome development, which has long been overdue.
Ghanaian President and African Union chairman John Kufuor is on record as having said last week that the situation in Zimbabwe is embarrassing to the continent. "We want accountable government", Kufuor bluntly said.
Zambian President Levy Mwanawasa echoed the same sentiments when he said: "Recent political developments in Zimbabwe are of great concern to us" while the South African Deputy Foreign Minister Aziz Pahad said "South Africa urges the Zimbabwean government to ensure that the rule of law including respect for human rights for all Zimbabweans and leaders of various parties is respected".
In a rare and unusual step of censuring a fellow UN member state, the UN Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon said the attacks on opposition political leaders "violate the basic democratic rights of citizens to engage in peaceful assembly ".
Taken together, positions across the world are clearly hardening.
Certainly, the language is changing as amply demonstrated by President Kufuor and others. The emperor is now being stripped of his clothes. More and more leaders worldwide are abandoning the softly-softly approach to human rights violations in Zimbabwe that we had become accustomed to.
Images and pictures of a battered Morgan Tsvangirai and other opposition leaders shown on television around the world have clearly galvanised international opinion. President Mugabe and the ruling ZANU PF may want to continually ignore international condemnations but for how long? Is killing and beating up legitimate opposition leaders sustainable?
ZANU PF is clearly losing the propaganda war. We live in a world in which issues of good governance, rule of law, freedom of expression and freedom of association and assembly have become global standards by which all governments, and I mean all governments, are judged by the extent to which they adhere to these universal values. There is nothing Western or African about the universality of these attributes. It is in this regard that the Zimbabwean authorities should seriously think again on their ham-fisted clampdown.
Nothing will be achieved by police brutality. It is one thing to detain for whatever reason a legitimate opposition political leader within the framework of the law. It is quite another to mercilessly beat him up for no reason other than to want him dead -- kafira mberi in Shona. The wave of repression that was recently unleashed by the Zimbabwean authorities is choking and appalling to say the least.
Men and women of goodwill in ZANU PF must of necessity stand up and say enough is enough. The repression that is being carried out in their names is frankly unacceptable. The pictures of Nelson Chamisa bursting into tears on his hospital bed and Tsvangirai, Madhuku, Sekai Holland and Grace Kwinjeh battered, dazed and writhing in pain for merely engaging in a peaceful protest must make anyone pause and ask why they are so intent on inflicting such damage on fellow Zimbabweans.
A country grappling with a myriad of other problems does not need these kinds of brutal actions to muddy the already troubled waters.
We want all of us to live in peace. Creating solutions to our problems is what we need from ZANU PF and President Mugabe and not the language of war. The mayhem that we are seeing at the moment is practically damaging everything in this country, be it tourism or investment -- you name it and it is being destroyed.
I do think it is in the interest of ZANU PF to concentrate on weapons of mass salvation and not on weapons of mass destruction. Surely, the sight and sound of suffering of most people in this country must move any ZANU PF leader to precisely do this.
However, much as he dislikes it, President Mugabe must face reality that is staring him right in the face. The reality is that the President is facing an increasingly hostile world, both internally and externally. There are decided limits to his ambition of wanting to stand again in the 2008 general elections. God forbid! And these limits are again both internal (the people of Zimbabwe) and external (involving quite literally the whole of the international community, Africa included).
It is not too late to go the way of Nelson Mandela, Mr President. I mean here the passing of the torch, the passing of the baton well before 2008.
My final point to President Mugabe on this very issue is that the greatest force in life is goodwill, not a brutal police force. You had that goodwill once upon a time. Please show it again for the sake of our Zimbabwe.
http://allafrica.com/stories/200703220543.html