Justice John Paul Stevens Retires

QueEx

Rising Star
Super Moderator
Obama will get another SCOTUS Pick, in 2010 ???

stevens_350.jpg

Justice John Paul Stevens

  • <font size="3">The oldest member of the United States Supreme Court is Justice John Paul Stevens.
</font size>

  • <font size="3">He turns 90, in April, 2010.
</font size>

  • <font size="3">The present term of the Supreme Court began the first Monday in October 2009 and ends the first Monday in October, 2010 (however, the Court rarely announces decisions after early July)
</font size>

  • <font size="3">An Omen: Justice Stevens has <SPAN style="BACKGROUND-COLOR: #ffff00">understaffed himself with law clerks</span> in the 2009-2010 term, <SPAN style="BACKGROUND-COLOR: #ffff00">something justices do when they're on their way out</span>.
</font size>
 
Re: Obama will get another SCOTUS Pick, in 2010 ???

And let's hope Obama doesn't run from a fight to put someone as progressive as Stevens has been on the Court. Pick is too important to go down that bi-partisan road that Republiklans will never travel anyway.:hmm:
 
Re: Obama will get another SCOTUS Pick, in 2010 ???

I agree, for the sake of having a balance on the Court. However, it would be a hellava lot more significant/interesting if he was having to replace someone from the Roberts-Alito, etc., wing.

QueEx
 
Re: Obama will get another SCOTUS Pick, in 2010 ???

I agree, for the sake of having a balance on the Court. However, it would be a hellava lot more significant/interesting if he was having to replace someone from the Roberts-Alito, etc., wing.

QueEx
Absolutely. Suppose our best chance of that will rest with Kennedy's retirement; which unfortunately probably won't happen until after Obama's term ends.

As for balance, it won't matter to the GOP; they will fight damn near to the death the nomination of any progressive and we can only hope and pray the fratured Dems will coalesce behind Obama's pick.
 
Re: Obama will get another SCOTUS Pick, in 2010 ???

Absolutely. Suppose our best chance of that will rest with Kennedy's retirement; which unfortunately probably won't happen until after Obama's term ends.

Fat chance. I would be totally surprised to see a member of the conservative wing retire in this term, especially because a second Obama term is today, in serious doubt.

I know a lot of people who had hoped that Thurgood Marshall would not have retired during Bush I's term. As you may know, Marshall retired from the Court, in ill health, June 28, 1991 allowing his replacement to be selected by H.W. Bush: enter Clarence Thomas. H.W. was a one termer as Bill Clinton took office January 20th, of 1993. Marshall died 4 days later, January 24th, 1993. Of course, staying in office could have deprived him of the little private life he had left; though some might argue, so what?

Had Marshall not retired, arguably, the conservative-lean on the Court might not exist, today.

As for balance, it won't matter to the GOP; they will fight damn near to the death the nomination of any progressive and we can only hope and pray the fratured Dems will coalesce behind Obama's pick.
I think you're right about fighting to the death. What concerns me, however, is that neither side seems to have the good of the public at interest, just their parochial party-interest.

QueEx
 
Re: Obama will get another SCOTUS Pick, in 2010 ???

Good post Que. Ill agree with ronmch20, President Obama needs to prepare for a fight if he wants to nominate another judge of JPS political leanings to the Court. Personally, I don't think so but i would love to be surprised. I know Jeffrey Toobin wrote a pretty good book on the SC. Ill be paying attention to his articles and interviews to see if he can provide some more incite if you don't post it first Que.
 
Re: Obama will get another SCOTUS Pick, in 2010 ???

It needs a bad ass progressive sista on the court. One of those sisters Clarance Thomas couldn't stand enough to go get a white girl. Somebody bad enough to drive Clarance Thomas the fuck out his mind enough to resign. Then Obama could put another progressive on the court like Rachel Maddow. :yes:

-VG
 
Re: Obama will get another SCOTUS Pick, in 2010 ???

It needs a bad ass progressive sista on the court. One of those sisters Clarance Thomas couldn't stand enough to go get a white girl. Somebody bad enough to drive Clarance Thomas the fuck out his mind enough to resign. Then Obama could put another progressive on the court like Rachel Maddow. :yes:

-VG

Man I know some of them bad asses !!! :lol:

. . . wouldn't wish em on anybody else, but Clarence.

QueEx
 
Re: Obama will get another SCOTUS Pick, in 2010 ???

<font size="5"><center>
Justice Stevens to leave
while Obama in office</font size></center>



Associated Press
April 3, 2010


<font size="3">WASHINGTON — Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens says he "will surely" retire while President Barack Obama is still in office, giving the president the opportunity to maintain the high court's ideological balance.</font size>


<font size="3">Obama's Second Appointment?</font size>

Stevens said in newspaper interviews on the Web Saturday that he will decide soon on the timing of his retirement, whether it will be this year or next. Stevens, the leader of the court's liberals, turns 90 this month and is the oldest justice.

His departure would give Obama his second nomination to the court, enabling him to ensure there would continue to be at least four liberal-leaning justices. The high court is often split 5 to 4 on major cases, with the vote of moderate Justice Anthony Kennedy often deciding which side prevails.

"I will surely do it while he's still president," Stevens told The Washington Post.

But Stevens, who was named to the court by Republican President Gerald R. Ford in 1975, says he still loves the job, and says he continues to write the first draft of his own opinions.

Stevens says if it ever gets to point where he stopped doing that, it would be a sign he wasn't up to the job anymore.

Stevens is the second-oldest justice in the court's history, after Oliver Wendell Holmes. He is the seventh-longest-serving justice, with more than 34 years on the court.


<font size="3">Justice Ginsburg, Pancreatic Cancer</font size>

Another liberal, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, had surgery last year for early-stage pancreatic cancer. While Ginsburg has been her usual energetic self, including frequent speaking engagements and a teaching stint in Europe, long-term survival rates for pancreatic cancer are low.

Ginsburg, 77, has said she intends to serve into her early 80s, and she has hired her clerks for the court term that begins in October 2010.

Justices are reluctant to retire in bunches, mainly because they want the nine-member court as close to full strength as possible.

Stevens also is nearing two longevity records. When he joined the court, he replaced the longest-serving justice, William O. Douglas, and would need to serve until mid-July 2012 to top that service record. He would surpass Holmes as the oldest sitting justice if he were to remain on the court until Feb. 24, 2011.

"I do have to fish or cut bait, just for my own personal peace of mind and also in fairness to the process," Stevens told The New York Times. "The president and the Senate need plenty of time to fill a vacancy."



http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5jp9jrwkjig6vQnONc-Zyk9lChX8wD9ERVRMG0
 
Re: Obama will get another SCOTUS Pick, in 2010 ???

Who Will Replace Justice Stevens on the Supreme Court?
Who Will Replace Justice Stevens on the Supreme Court?Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens, 89, is almost certainly going to retire at the end of the month. Bloomberg think they know who's lined up to replace him. Here's your guide to the rumored candidates.

Elena Kagan is currently US Solicitor General, and is also a lady. Which will probably freak the Republicans out, as they like them a nice old white guy where possible. She has plenty of experience arguing in front of the court, and was previously the dean of Harvard Law School. However. When they Republicans decide to oppose whoever Obama suggests because they just hate everyone and everything that is not Republican, they will probably pick on the same things that they picked on in opposing her Solicitor General-ship. Namely: she opposed on-campus military recruiting at Harvard.

Diane Wood is also a lady. She's a federal appellate judge on the 7th US Circuit Court of Appeals in Chicago and Bloomberg say she's "developed a reputation there as an intellectual jurist willing to take on her more conservative colleagues," which is probably valuable experience for the Supreme Court. She worked in the Clinton administration, so there's bound to be some non-controversy the Republicans can dig up on her.

Merrick Garland, who is on the US Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit is a man and also the most conservative of the potential replacements. He went to Harvard Law, and helped prosecute Timothy McVeigh. Who knows what the GOP will find wrong with him — he also served under Clinton — but they will certainly find something.

Of course, it might be none of these. The Bloomberg article also mentions "Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano, Governor Jennifer Granholm of Michigan and then-Chief Justice Leah Ward Sears of the Georgia Supreme Court," as well as Martha Minow, the current dean of Harvard Law.
http://gawker.com/5508960/who-will-replace-justice-stevens-on-the-supreme-court
 
Re: Obama will get another SCOTUS Pick, in 2010 ???

<font size="5"><center>
Justice John Paul Stevens
to retire from court in June</font size></center>



Washington Post
By Robert Barnes
Washington Post Staff Writer
Friday, April 9, 2010; 10:56 AM


Justice John Paul Stevens, the longest-serving member of the current Supreme Court and the leader of its liberal wing, announced his retirement today, giving President Obama his second chance to make a mark on the nation's highest court.


Stevens, who will turn 90 on April 20, said in a letter to "My dear Mr. President" that he will leave the court at the conclusion of the current term at the end of June. Stevens said he was announcing now so that the president would have time to make a nomination and the Senate to confirm in time for the start of the court's new term next October.

It will be Obama's second Supreme Court appointment after Justice Sonia Sotomayor, who was named last year to replace retiring Justice David Souter.

Stevens was appointed to the high court by President Gerald Ford, and joined the court on Dec. 19, 1975. His retirement is not a surprise and the White House has been preparing for the opening. Aides and Democrats close to the process name three people as likely frontrunners for the job: Solicitor General Elena Kagan, who Obama made the first woman to hold that post, and two appellate court judges, Diane Wood of Chicago and Merrick Garland of Washington.

Kagan and Wood were interviewed by Obama last spring before he nominated Sotomayor to the court.


http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/04/09/AR2010040902312.html
 
comm_kennedy.jpg



Anthony Kennedy is the one that needs to retire. He is 73. He has been the swing vote on the right/left, conservative/liberal. corporatist/populous issues. Stevens and Breyer in the past were noted for persuading him on many issues and as of late, since Breyer's retirement he has vote with the right. Hopeful if Obama wins another term, he will retire and the right wing slant of the court will been shifted after 30 years of Reaganism.


It needs a bad ass progressive sista on the court.


clarence_thomas_widec.jpg

"Who Put A Public Hair On My Coke Can?"

anita_hill.jpg
 
Back
Top