Forgotten History: How Zora Neale Hurston was falsely accused to be a sexual predator & her career was destroyed

playahaitian

Rising Star
Certified Pussy Poster
You have to Google the specific words “falsely accused” along with “Zora Neale Hurston” in order to turn up the story. According to a 2002 piece in The New York Times, in 1948, “a vindictive neighbor accused Hurston of sexual relations with her 10-year-old son.

The charges were patently false—Hurston had been in Honduras at the time, and the boy was mentally unstable—but she was indicted, and the story leaked to a Black newspaper, which sensationalized it...

The case was finally thrown out, and, characteristically, Hurston rebounded to work on a final published novel, Seraph on the Suwanee, and a unfinished nonfiction work called Herod the Great that no publisher would touch.”
 

When Zora Neale Hurston Was Falsely Accused of Child Molestation…








18 Votes

I read Alice Walker’s essay “Looking for Zora” when I was in college. I had never heard of Hurston and it would be several years before I actually read any of her work. I’ll admit that I am not a fan of her most famous novel “Their Eyes Were Watching God.” I much prefer her short stories (one of my favorites is “Sweat”).
Since my introduction to Hurston in college, I’ve read her memoir “Dust Tracks on a Road” as well as other books about her life and work. I have found her to be complicated like most of us are. She appears fearless and also insecure. She fought for herself at a time when other women were circumscribed from opportunities. Her racial politics are not mine and she never defined herself as feminist. It turned out that Walker presented (by necessity?) a very truncated version of Hurston’s life, work, and especially her politics.
When I read Robert Hemenway’s “Zora Neale Hurston: A Literary Biography” (1977), I learned for the first time about the sex scandal that eventually led Hurston to leave Harlem for good. The incident is only mentioned in passing.
It’s been on my long list of future projects to learn more about this incident as a way to better understand how black women interacted with the criminal legal system in the early through mid-20th century. Virginia Lynn Moylan’s biography of Hurston’s final decade provides useful information and context about the false molestation charges leveled against her.

In September 1948, Zora Neale Hurston was arrested and jailed after being accused by the son of her former landlady (Mamie Allen) of molesting him and two of his friends. The charges were fabricated as Billy Allen, Hurston’s chief accuser, suggested that the abuse happened while Hurston was in Honduras and upstate New York. Hurston apparently offered to take a lie detector test to prove her innocence but the police did not pursue this.
Hurston only spent a few hours in jail and then was bailed out by her friend and editor Burroughs Mitchell. Zora wanted to prove her innocence and requested a preliminary hearing which took place on September 21, 1948. Moylan (2011) explains what happened:
“During the hearing, District Attorney Frank Hogan presented no evidence other than the lurid testimony of the three boys. Billy claimed that he and his friends had met Hurston and the other adults (whom she had never met) every Saturday afternoon at 4:30 for almost two years in the basement of a West 124th Street building and were paid 50 cents to allow one of the adults to have oral sex with them while the others watched. Only one of the other adults, a black male janitor, was formally charged. The third defendant, a Hispanic mother of four who owned a nearby candy store, was not arrested (p.40).”
Billy Allen, Hurston’s chief accuser, was apparently known in the community as suffering from mental problems. In fact, according to Moylan (2011), “Hurston had advised his mother to take him to Bellvue Hospital for psychological evaluation and treatment, which she did for a time (p.41).” Mayme Allen told the district attorney that she didn’t like Hurston and even resented her. Neighbors told Hurston that Mrs. Allen may have been the instigator of the false accusations as a way to have her son committed. Even after it was revealed in the preliminary hearing that the three young men who had accused Hurston of molestation were actually having sex with each other on Saturdays in the basement, the presiding judge Francis X. Giaccone ruled that the case would proceed to criminal court. Hurston was charged with one count of assault in the second degree, three counts of sodomy, and one count of “placing a child in such a situation as likely to impair morals.”
Because the case took place in juvenile court, the proceedings had been sealed and confidential. Hurston was fairly confident that she would be found not guilty of the charges against her. Then in October, an employee of the court leaked the story of the molestation charges to two black newspapers. Both the New York Age and the Afro-American ran stories about the case. The Afro-American stories were particularly lurid, salacious, and not factual.
Hurston was crushed. She felt betrayed by her own community. She was suicidal. She wrote to her friend Carl Van Vechten: “No acquittal will persuade some people that I am innocent…All that I have believed in has failed me. I have resolved to die.” With support from some of her good friends, Hurston’s spirits rallied and in March 1949, the New York City district attorney announced that his office had decided that Hurston was innocent of the charges. It turns out, however, that as early as November 1948, Billy Allen had already admitted to investigators that he had made up the story after his mother had discovered him having sex with his friends. The District Attorney’s office sat on this confession for months before proceeding to drop the case against Hurston and the other defendant.
The false accusation destroyed Hurston’s reputation and left a major imprint on her psyche. Hurston held a grudge against many including W.E.B. Dubois and Richard Wright who were some of the toughest critics of her work. In a letter to the editor of Opportunity Magazine, Charles Johnson, Hurston railed against both men implicating them in her misfortune:
“Because I openly expressed my scorn of them, they got up what they took to be an unbeatably wonderful scheme to kill me off forever. Only these monumental ‘intellectuals,’ in their ecstasy, did not take the time to find out where I was when they stated the dates for things.”
There is no evidence beyond Hurston’s own words that Dubois or Wright had anything to do with the morals charges against her. But it is indisputably true that neither came to her defense when misfortune struck. This episode in Hurston’s life left lasting scars… A decade later she died in obscurity in Florida.
Note: The following recording of Hurston singing was recently discovered. Listen to her sing “Uncle Bud,” a prison blues song in 1940. One gets a sense of her personality through hearing her voice:
 
Party for Zora Neale Hurston, Obscure No More
By Ralph Blumenthal
  • Aug. 15, 2002

See the article in its original context from August 15, 2002, Section E, Page 1Buy Reprints

New York Times subscribers* enjoy full access to TimesMachine—view over 150 years of New York Times journalism, as it originally appeared.


On a day hot enough to send the knots in the trees crawling off to sit in the shade, Zora Neale Hurston, the protean folklorist and queen of the Harlem Renaissance, conjured an appearance on a Central Park stage Tuesday for a long-postponed party with 2,000 friends.
''She's smiling on us right now,'' said the actor Russell Hornsby, who turned out with Ossie Davis, Ruby Dee and other stars to salute Hurston in a program of readings at SummerStage called ''Zora's Salon.''

Her words, including Southern folk tales collected by Hurston and read faithfully in dialect the way she had copied them down from her sources, complete with unsparing racial stereotypes of the day, drew occasional groans but mostly easy laughter. Tears, too, for the letters recounting her crushing rebuffs and flirtation with suicide after a hideous libel falsely accused her of child molestation.

''Zora is a goddess,'' said Alyson Solomon, a consultant from Oregon who was sitting with friends from Johannesburg, Budapest and New York, all of whom said they were worshipful Hurston readers.
ADVERTISEMENT
Continue reading the main story


Forty-two years after she died a pauper's obscure death in Florida at 69, none of her books in print, Hurston is emerging as an epic literary figure as her reputation grows under a surge of new scholarship, started by the quest of the writer Alice Walker to find her unmarked grave in 1973.
Hurston wrote seven books, including her acclaimed 1937 novel, ''Their Eyes Were Watching God,'' but at last count 29 books have been written about her, including a groundbreaking 1977 literary biography by Robert E. Hemenway, as well as hundreds of articles, chapters and dissertations.

  • Unlock more free articles.
Create an account or log in

The latest work, a collection of 600 recently discovered letters, is to be published this fall by Doubleday, and a second volume of collected folk tales, ''Every Tongue Got to Confess,'' was put out last year by HarperCollins. In April ''Polk County,'' one of 10 long-lost Hurston plays found in the Library of Congress five years ago, drew raves at its premiere in Washington.

A widely beloved but never easily fathomable figure, Hurston straddled the worlds of social science and art, starting as Barnard College's only black student and protégé of the anthropologist Franz Boas.

Born in Alabama and raised in Eatonville, Fla., Hurston landed in New York in 1925 with $1.50 in her pocket and was soon drawn to the black cultural blossoming known as the Harlem Renaissance. ''The Negro was in vogue,'' said Langston Hughes, her on-again, off-again confidant and collaborator. The novelist Rudolph Fisher put it another way: ''Negro stock is going up, and everyone's buying.''


Hurston counted herself one of the progressive ''New Negroes'' and slyly proclaimed herself ''Queen of the Niggerati.'' She feuded with Richard Wright and the Communists, drove a red convertible, packed a gun at times for protection and once knocked out a masher who propositioned her in an elevator.

An avid anthropologist (and shrewd grant-getter), she returned to Eatonville and her Southern roots in 1927 to hunt down folk tales, convinced that folklore is the art people create before they know there is such a thing as art. The tales suggested to her that ''the Negro's outstanding characteristic is drama,'' and she wrote: ''Who has not observed a young Negro chap posing up a street corner, possessed of nothing but his clothing, his strength and his youth? Does he bear himself like a pauper? No, Louis XIV could be no more insolent in his assurance.''

She haunted ''jook joints,'' or bawdy houses, and with Guggenheim fellowships went on lone expeditions to Haiti studying voodoo. She traveled to Honduras searching for lost Mayan cities. She married three times, short-lived attachments, and carried on other romances about which little is known. She published her first novel, ''Jonah's Vine Gourd,'' a semi-autobiographical account of her philandering preacher-father and the rest of their family, in 1934 and followed that with ''Mules and Men,'' her first collection of folk tales. Then came ''Their Eyes Were Watching God,'' an autobiographical love story destined to become -- too late for Hurston -- a perennial best-seller and standard school text.

Inured to struggle, financial and artistic, she was often rebuffed by publishers. She distanced herself, too, from some of her more radical contemporaries, insisting she was not ''one of the sobbing school of Negrohood.'' Some accused her of accommodating white injustice, but her letters make clear that she was often burning with indignation over racial mistreatment.

Her lowest moment came in 1948, when a vindictive neighbor accused Hurston of sexual relations with her 10-year-old son. The charges were patently false -- Hurston had been in Honduras at the time, and the boy was mentally unstable -- but she was indicted, and the story leaked to a black newspaper, which sensationalized it. ''My race has seen fit to destroy me,'' she wrote, contemplating suicide. The case was finally thrown out, and, characteristically, Hurston rebounded to work on a final published novel, ''Seraph on the Suwanee,'' and a unfinished nonfiction work called ''Herod the Great'' that no publisher would touch.

The free Central Park reading, a ''Spoken Word'' presentation of the City Parks Foundation, was developed by Alexa Birdsong, executive producer of SummerStage, based on the new books of folk tales and letters. She engaged Jill Newman, an independent producer, as co-curator, and they persuaded the director Lloyd Richards to pull it together on short notice, in conjunction with an afternoon forum on Hurston's legacy that included her niece Lucy Hurston, also a writer.

An unexpectedly large audience of about 2,000 showed up on a night of record heat that some of Hurston's tall tales seemed meant to address: ''I seen it so hot dat de li'dwood knots wuz crawling off in de shade. . . . It wuz so hot once uh cake of ice walked away from de ice house and went down de street and fainted.''
ADVERTISEMENT
Continue reading the main story


With the stage set like a living room evoking a period salon, Mr. Davis and Ms. Dee opened by reading some of Hurston's collected folk tales. One went: ''Once there was a Negro. Every day he went under the hill to pray. So one day a white man went to see what he was doing. He was praying to God to kill all the white people; so the white man threw a brick on his head. The Negro said, 'Lord, can't you tell a white man from a Negro?' ''
The actor Avery Brooks, recognizable from his roles in the ''Star Trek'' and ''Man Called Hawk'' television series, read another folk tale called ''Why Negroes Have Nothing.'' Unflinchingly rendering the racial epithets in the original text, which drew some disapproving clucks, it tells how God granted all the nations what they asked for but the Negro replied, ''Ah don't want nothin' and went back tuh sleep.''

But he also drew laughs with Hurston's portrait of a windy preacher. And he read a Hurston letter that showed her indignation over white injustice: ''I know the Anglo-Saxon mentality is one of violence. Violence is his religion.''

Other selections were read by the actors Kevin Jackson, Kerry Washington and Lillias White. Vincent Patmore Lewis, first violinist of the Metropolitan Opera, provided an improvised accompaniment.

''She was a hustler,'' said Asha Bandele, a poet and editor at large of Essence magazine who participated in the Hurston literary forum. ''She did whatever she had to do, but she never hustled her soul or creative spirit.''

 

Zora Neale Hurston’s Lost Decade
The Harlem Renaissance writer’s obscure and impoverished final years are being rehabilitated.
EVE OTTENBERG APRIL 8, 2011
Zora Neale Hurston in 1938. (Photo: Library of Congress)
PUBLISHED IN
APRIL 2011

For Zora Neale Hurston the 1950s were years in which she struggled to survive. The story of her last 10 years might sound like a gloomy tale, but in Virginia Lynn Moylan’s Zora Neale Hurston’s Final Decade (University of Florida) this is not at all the case.
True, at age 60, Hurston – the author of the 1937 novel Their Eyes Were Watching God who first made her mark in the Harlem Renaissance in the late 1920s – had to fight “to make ends meet” with the help of public assistance. At one point she worked as a maid on Miami Beach’s Rivo Alto Island.
But Hurston was still active and productive during her final years, and did not end up at the extreme of literary catastrophe (exemplified by Edgar Allen Poe, who died an alcoholic in a gutter), though in 1948 she was falsely accused of having molested a 10-year-old boy – a scandal that nearly drove her to suicide at the beginning of this last decade. (Her passport proved she was in Honduras at the time of the alleged crime.)
Though she would have been loath to admit it, Hurston suffered because she was black and a woman – two factors that stood in the way of her being able to publish her work. But despite repeated rejection, she kept writing, especially about her historical research on the Hebrew king Herod.
Since her death, Hurston’s reputation has received two major rehabilitations. The first was a 1975 Alice Walker essay in Ms. magazine, “In Search of Zora Neale Hurston,” and the second the 2005 TV movie version of Their Eyes Were Watching God, produced by Oprah Winfrey and starring Halle Berry. Now that Hurston’s place in the pantheon of American writers is secure, it is unsettling to see her in Zora Neale Hurston’s Final Decade, going hat-in-hand to publishers and employers at an age when she should have been enjoying her retirement and resting on her laurels.
Moylan, an educator and independent scholar, observes that universities all over the world had her books in their syllabi, yet none offered her a teaching position. So she became a substitute teacher at a local high school in Florida, wrote freelance articles for newspapers that paid sporadically and moved frequently due to poverty.
Hurston was in some ways a conservative. She fought with Richard Wright and fell out with her old friend Langston Hughes. Both conflicts concerned their leftist politics and sympathy to communism. As Moylan points out, Hurston was a devotee of the meritocratic philosophy of Booker T. Washington.
Hurston wanted her people to pull themselves up by their bootstraps. On the subject of blacks who emulate whites, she wrote in 1934: “Fawn as you will. Spend an eternity standing awe-struck, but until we have placed something upon his street corner that is our own, we are right back where we were when they filed our iron collars off.”
Hurston, the anthropologist and folklorist, who studied at Barnard with Franz Boas, Ruth Benedict and Margaret Mead, never lost her focus on the uniqueness of African-American culture. She bucked the conventions of the black literary establishment and had her characters speak in black dialect.
Hurston was also a contrarian politically. She vocally opposed school desegregation and, as Moylan writes, “blamed the NAACP, President Dwight D. Eisenhower and the Brown decision for what she perceived as the ‘hate-filled, stinking mess’ in which southern blacks and whites found themselves.”
Yet years earlier, in 1945, Moylan writes that Hurston had criticized American foreign policy for supporting “democracy abroad while ‘subjugating the dark world completely’ through its sanctioning of Jim Crow at home.” Hurston must have known very well that Jim Crow had more to do with that “hate-filled, stinking mess” than the NAACP, but in the heat of journalistic combat could not admit that. Instead, she belittled the idea of a court order that would compel someone to associate with her who did not want to. She seems not to have considered the perspective of ordinary mortals, who might in fact need a court order to go to a better school.
Moylan argues that regarding education, Hurston was a black separatist, and devotes pages to defending Hurston’s diatribes against Brown v. The Board of Education. Though at first it may seem jarring, this is in fact one of the most nuanced sections of a much-needed book, one that illuminates the last, nearly destitute years of a great writer’s life, years previously cloaked in obscurity. These years have been “a period that might appear outwardly unprofitable,” Hurston wrote in a 1957 letter. “But … I have made phenomenal growth as a creative artist. … I am not materialistic… If I do happen to die without money, somebody will bury me, though I do not wish it to be that way.”
And on Jan. 28, 1960, Hurston died in the St. Lucie County Welfare Home.
 

In 1948, false accusations of child molestation all but erased the reputation and career Zora Neale Hurston had worked for decades to build. Sensationalized in the profit-seeking press and relentlessly pursued by a prosecution more interested in a personal crusade than justice, the morals charge brought against her nearly drove her to suicide.

But she lived on. She lived on past her accuser’s admission that he had fabricated his whole story. She lived on for another twelve years, during which time she participated in some of the most remarkable events, movements, and projects of the day.

Since her death, scholars and the public have rediscovered Hurston’s work and conscientiously researched her biography. Nevertheless, the last decade of her life has remained relatively unexplored. Virginia Moylan fills in the details--investigating subjects as varied as Hurston’s reporting on the trial of Ruby McCollum (a black woman convicted of murdering her white lover), her participation in designing an "anthropologically correct" black baby doll to combat stereotypes, her impassioned and radical biography of King Herod, and her controversial objections to court-ordered desegregation.
 

SEX ACCUSATION HURT HURSTON
SUN-SENTINEL

Privacy Policy

Zora Neale Hurston, a black folklorist, novelist and anthropologist of the 1920s and 1930s, was largely ignored during her lifetime.

She was born sometime between 1891 and 1901 and grew up in Eatonville, Fla., the first all-black town in America.

In 1925, she earned a scholarship to Barnard College. There, she became a leader in the Harlem Renaissance, a period of outstanding literary creativity among black artists.

She returned to rural Florida in 1927 to collect folklore, continuing her research in places such as Miami and New Orleans.

She wrote plays, short stories, magazine articles and seven books about the American South. Her books included Their Eyes Were Watching God, Mules and Men, Spunk and Dust Tracks on a Road, her autobiography.

But by the time her last book was published, she had run into trouble.

In 1948, Hurston was arrested in New York and charged with molesting a 10-year-old boy.

Although the case was later dropped after Hurston proved she was in Honduras when the alleged attack occurred, a national black newspaper had printed the charges on the front page. Hurston was devastated.

During the last years of her life, she was unable to complete a manuscript.

In 1959, she moved to Fort Pierce, where she struggled to support herself by teaching and free-lance writing. Her health declined as she suffered from stomach ulcers and finally a stroke.

Hurston died, forgotten and penniless, of heart disease in the St. Lucie County Welfare Home on Jan. 28, 1960.

Thirteen years later, Alice Walker, author of The Color Purple, found Hurston's unmarked grave, bought a headstone and worked to resurrect her memory.

Since then, Hurston has been inducted into the Florida Artists Hall of Fame, joining other writers such as Ernest Hemingway, Marjorie Kinnan Rawlings and Tennessee Williams.
 

Hurston drew criticism from some African American intellectuals, including novelist Richard Wright, for writing dialogue in rural African American dialect and for presenting her characters in ways that other writers and critics considered backward or inappropriate.
 
How come I've never heard of this accusation and I've taken several literature and Black Literature classes?

Not one professor ever mentioned this part of her life.
 

Hurston drew criticism from some African American intellectuals, including novelist Richard Wright, for writing dialogue in rural African American dialect and for presenting her characters in ways that other writers and critics considered backward or inappropriate.
Remember this.

That did make reading her work challenging sometime but I liked the realism it lent to the characters.
 
Back
Top