Basketball Hall of Fame- Do Andre Iguodala or Robert Horry belong?

Select the players below who belong in the basketball Hall of Fame.

  • Mark Aguirre

  • Penny Hardaway

  • Tim Hardaway

  • Robert Horry

  • Andre Iguoala

  • Mark Jackson

  • Shawn Kemp

  • Alonzo Mourning

  • Charles Oakley

  • Glen Rice

  • Mitch Richmond

  • Ben Wallace

  • Rasheed Wallace

  • Chris Webber


Results are only viewable after voting.

Rembrandt Brown

Slider
Registered








Warriors' Andre Iguodala on Hall of Fame Credentials: 'None of It Matters'
TYLER CONWAY
JUNE 3, 2019

Andre Iguodala has made an interesting Hall of Fame case during his time with the Golden State Warriors. Despite making just one career All-Star team and never reaching an All-NBA pinnacle, he's on the precipice of winning a fourth championship while being arguably the glue that holds the roster together.

Not that any of this interests him.

"I don't care. None of it matters," he told Ethan Strauss of The Athletic regarding his Hall of Fame candidacy. "Does anyone remember any of those speeches other than Jordan's?"

"See, here's how it works. One day, you're replaced. Then it's some other motherf--ker in there. And then there's another motherf--ker. And another after that. Nobody remembers anything. None of it matters!"


From an individual credentials standpoint, Iguodala does not look like a Hall of Famer on paper. He would be just the 31st player in history to make the Hall of Fame with zero or one All-Star selections. A vast majority of those players were selected for non-basketball, international basketball or ABA reasons.

Iguodala has a gold medal as part of the 2012 USA basketball team, but his candidacy will largely be based on these Warriors years.

That's where things get tricky. Without Iguodala, the Warriors almost certainly do not win the 2015 championship. He has a Finals MVP on his mantle to prove it. The 2017 and 2018 banners are probably hanging with or without Iguodala, as injuries limited him during those postseasons.

It's a nearly impossible to parse case because the Hall of Fame is an individual honor. However, the Basketball Hall of Fame is easier to get into than the Pro Football Hall of Fame or Baseball Hall of Fame. If we were talking about Iguodala as a football or baseball player, it would be an open and shut case that he would be on the outside looking in.



As Iguodala adds more team accolades to his career—all while playing an integral role on these teams—his case grows. His made three with 5.9 seconds remaining to seal Sunday's Game 2 victory over the Toronto Raptors may have been the play people point to where Iguodala clinched his spot.

Not that he seems to particularly care one way or another.

 
Deleted the previous thread-- Didn't realize the poll only allowed to vote for one player previously, which defeats the point. You can now select all players who belong in the HOF. My bad to those who had participated.
 
I went with Wallace (defensive monster as an undersized 5 in his prime); Zo and Hardaway (ain’t happening due to his anti gay comments though; the NBA has welcomed him back but only so much).

Iggy has always been solid but not HOF worthy.

He is worthy of consideration for one of the top 10 dunk ever though:

 
I know Mourning and Richmond have been inducted, also, but am including them for a baseline. (I don't think Richmond belongs in there.)
 
No......
I could see the logic for Horry
But anyone who argues for Iggy should be hurt
Sports discussions can get so stupid
 
Charles only had 1 vote so you know non basketball IQ people voted. Charles is the most accomplished on the list . BIG SHOT BOB is a lock,,,,not so Iguodala
 
Dude posted a string list of folks that were winners, changed the game, won chips, finals MVP

And this is the response lol

Who on that list is unequivocally a hall of famer? None of them to me, and I watched all of them play.
 
Last edited:
No fucking way is Iggy a hall of famer. But I said that already.
 
Last edited:
Shawn Kemp n Alonzo Mourning YES

AI n Big Shot Bob Don't think either gray team players tho
 
Iguodala?
tenor.gif
 
I know Mourning and Richmond have been inducted, also, but am including them for a baseline. (I don't think Richmond belongs in there.)

and who the fuck gave Webber more votes than Shawn Kemp ????

Horry as #2 out of all these players is ridiculous.

The NBA's all-time assist leaders are John Stockton, Jason Kidd, Steve Nash, Mark Jackson, Magic Johnson, Oscar Robertson and Chris Paul. I'm not sure why the guy in front of Magic gets so much less respect than everyone else on the list. His placement at #9 below is the most egregious IMO.

And Hall-of-Famer Mitch Richmond tying with one-time all-star Charles Oakley for second from the bottom says something.


Players who belong in the basketball Hall of Fame, according to BGOL:
  1. Alonzo Mourning
    26 vote(s)
    65.0%
  2. Robert Horry
    24 vote(s)
    60.0%
  3. Tim Hardaway
    22 vote(s)
    55.0%
  4. Chris Webber
    21 vote(s)
    52.5%
  5. Rasheed Wallace
    17 vote(s)
    42.5%
  6. Shawn Kemp
    14 vote(s)
    35.0%
  7. Andre Iguoala
    12 vote(s)
    30.0%
  8. Penny Hardaway
    12 vote(s)
    30.0%
  9. Mark Jackson
    11 vote(s)
    27.5%
  10. Ben Wallace
    11 vote(s)
    27.5%
  11. Mark Aguirre
    10 vote(s)
    25.0%
  12. Charles Oakley
    7 vote(s)
    17.5%
  13. Mitch Richmond
    7 vote(s)
    17.5%
  14. Glen Rice
    4 vote(s)
    10.0%
 
Neither belongs but the criteria for induction is so weak now, wouldnnt be surprised if they somehow got in
 
Back
Top