Cardell Hayes’ conviction upheld by appeals court in Will Smith shooting death
The manslaughter conviction of Cardell Hayes was upheld by a state appeals court on Wednesday (March 27) in connection to the April 2016 fatal shooting of former New Orleans Saints player Will Smith, court records show.
The case against Hayes, himself a high school football standout who played for the local football league, Crescent City Kings, drew national attention since the night of his arrest at the scene on April 9, 2016. Hayes and his attorneys never denied he shot Smith dead that night, but contended in statements and at trial that he fired the shots in self-defense.
The shooting occurred amid a chaotic scene, witnesses described at trial, after a traffic crash prompted an argument. Hayes’ Hummer H2 struck the back of Smith’s Mercedes Benz SUV, and people in both vehicles, as well as others traveling with Smith, got out of their cars. Smith, a team captain when the Saints won the Super Bowl in 2011, was driving with his wife, Racquel, in the front passenger seat, and two friends in the back when the Hummer struck the Mercedes at the corner of Sophie B. Wright Place and Felicity Street.
Racquel was also shot, and the jury also convicted Hayes of attempted first-degree murder in connection to her injuries.
Orleans Parish District Attorney Leon Cannizzaro’s office sought second-degree murder charges, and thus a life sentence, for Hayes. But a split jury, in a 10-2 vote, on Dec. 12, 2016, found him guilty of the lesser offense of manslaughter -- a verdict that drew emotional responses by supporters of both sides.
Orleans District Criminal Court Judge Camille Buras sentenced Hayes to 25 years in prison.
Louisiana 4th District Court of Appeal Judges Terri Love, Joy Cossich Lobrano and Sandra Cabrina Jenkins affirmed the conviction against Hayes in a unanimous decision.
Barker said Wednesday he plans to file paperwork seeking a new hearing in front of all 12 judges in Louisiana’s 4th Circuit Court of Appeal, referred to as an en banc review, to reconsider the three-judge panel’s rejection of Hayes’ appeal.
Cannizzaro, in a written statement, said the panel’s decision was “unequivocal,” in affirming Hayes’ convictions and sentence.
“There was no justification for the brutal killing of Will Smith over a traffic dispute three years ago, and his widow Racquel has today expressed her gratitude for our defense of the trial outcome and the 4th Circuit’s decision,” Cannizzaro said. “We will continue our efforts as needed to ensure that Mr. Hayes serves the complete sentence imposed for his criminal acts.”