Which One Has To Go? Eddie, Pryor, Martin or Chappelle?

Which One Has To Go? Eddie, Pryor, Martin or Chappelle?

  • Eddie Murphy

  • Richard Pryor

  • Martin Lawrence

  • Dave Chappelle


Results are only viewable after voting.

cashwhisperer

My favorite key is E♭
BGOL Investor
Eddie-Murphy-2007.jpg

MV5BMjA1NzUzMTIzNF5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTcwNTM5ODAyMw@@._V1_UY1200_CR161,0,630,1200_AL_.jpg

3_Martin-Lawrence.jpg

e17d40a6060f6c8d8933150db3f71aa6.jpg
 

datboi

Rising Star
BGOL Investor
They each had a significant impact over the decade.
It's like asking which decade got to go. 70 80 90 or 2000. I would go with the 80s. Martin influence in the 90s from Whats Happening Now, to House Party, Def Comedy Jam and Martin.
 

alexw

Unapologetically Afrikan!
Platinum Member
martin was the funniest comedian alive until he got rich and then his sets turned into trash before he totally quit doing stand up

def comedy jams and you so crazy were masterpieces
gets rich
runteldat and everything thereafter total trash

easily martin here
 

alexw

Unapologetically Afrikan!
Platinum Member
oooooooooooooooooh shit i read the poll wrong
there is no way im picking martin if we're just talking about comedy in general
its chappelle
yeah he maybe the goat of stand up
but that doesnt beat movies and tv shows
 

alexw

Unapologetically Afrikan!
Platinum Member
I meant overall, the culmination of their works.

I think Chappelle Show was as impactful and had as many quotables as Martin's Show. And Chappelle kills Martin in standup.

chappelle show and martin are equal or there's a slight edge to martin as he did more seasons
but you also have to equate movies
and martins movies blow chappelle's out of the water
hell martin has starred in blockbusters
its chappelle man
 

alexw

Unapologetically Afrikan!
Platinum Member
Ehhh, Chris Rock and Martin are a tie for me tho

nah chris rock doesnt belong in the poll
i thought it was a stand up comedian poll and its just a body of work poll
martin was way bigger than chappelle has ever been
murphy and pryor are in a different league that martin almost entered until he had that stroke
 

alexw

Unapologetically Afrikan!
Platinum Member
Martin, his standup is more about his act outs and physicality. I like hearing "bars", clever comedians that make me think "damn why didn't I think of that?!"
so are you willing to give up bad boys, big mommas house, thin line between love and hate, life, and the martin show

bro that shit is legendary
skit comedy and stand up just doesnt reach that
 

cashwhisperer

My favorite key is E♭
BGOL Investor
chappelle show and martin are equal or there's a slight edge to martin as he did more seasons
but you also have to equate movies
and martins movies blow chappelle's out of the water
hell martin has starred in blockbusters
its chappelle man

e16f743f3671d9c365e66cbd38048c1f.gif


Would you rather have Half Baked or Big Momma's House?

I mean, Bad Boys was cool...but I would rather have Chappelle's standup over Bad Boys and any other Martin movies.
 

alexw

Unapologetically Afrikan!
Platinum Member
e16f743f3671d9c365e66cbd38048c1f.gif


Would you rather have Half Baked or Big Momma's House?

I mean, Bad Boys was cool...but I would rather have Chappelle's standup over Bad Boys and any other Martin movies.

man id rather have the def comedy jams over anything chappelle has done as a stand up
id choose big momma 1 over half baked as well
man yall dont know understand how big martin was in the 90s
 

cashwhisperer

My favorite key is E♭
BGOL Investor
man id rather have the def comedy jams over anything chappelle has done as a stand up
id choose big momma 1 over half baked as well
man yall dont know understand how big martin was in the 90s

Oh well, we just prefer different styles of comedy.

But in terms of popularity, I can't say Martin overall has been bigger than Chappelle overall
 

alexw

Unapologetically Afrikan!
Platinum Member
Oh well, we just prefer different styles of comedy.

But in terms of popularity, I can't say Martin overall has been bigger than Chappelle overall
bro i love dave and i think he's top 2 in stand up(i still have pryor above him)
but he hasnt reached the heights that martin has
do you know martin had the #1 comedy film, #1 movie out, and the #1 tv show all at the same gotdamn time in 94 and 95
chappelle has never reached that level
nah man
recency bias is a mofo
 

Strait_Laced

knowledge alone ≠ power
OG Investor
i think martin loses out in this scenario
he had his peak, but once he started having his problems...slowed down quite a bit as far as the funny
'martin show' martin in the 90's was a beast tho
my all time favorite still was when he had to go to the dmv

[then again, i could say the same thing about pryor...there was before fire/after fire pryor, but his status as setting the standard for so many comedians that followed...could in no way take him off the list]
 

sammyjax

Grand Puba of Science
Platinum Member
I meant overall, the culmination of their works.

I think Chappelle Show was as impactful and had as many quotables as Martin's Show. And Chappelle kills Martin in standup.
Man I had to look and see if I quoted you lol wth

I agree w those, I was responding to the i can only think of one Martin quotable thing

For what it's worth I think Chapelle and Martin changed the public vernacular 10 times more than Eddie or Richard, although idk how to weigh that in here
 

alexw

Unapologetically Afrikan!
Platinum Member
i think martin loses out in this scenario
he had his peak, but once he started having his problems...slowed down quite a bit as far as the funny
'martin show' martin in the 90's was a beast tho
my all time favorite still was when he had to go to the dmv

[then again, i could say the same thing about pryor...there was before fire/after fire pryor, but his status as setting the standard for so many comedians that followed...could in no way take him off the list]
thats a good point
martin was never the same after his stroke and pryor wasnt the same either
with both of them you noticed their speech patterns and their physical looks were just off
 
Top