Montana is my all time fav QB and I was a Dolphins fan (after the Bucs) for much of the 80s...yet and still, you wildin D-Nice.
Brady eclipses Elway because he is clutch in the playoffs and Elway choked for years. TD and Shannon Sharpe got Elway his rings, whereas Brady got his with a bunch of cast-offs. First year they get him marquee talent (but still no running game!) and he goes 18-0.
Like someone said, Marino choked like shit in the playoffs and always took the ball out of the RBs hands, trying to do it all himself.
Marino is still one of the greats, but...
You play to WIN THE GAME! HELLO!!
Four rings, undefeated season, all the single-season passing records?
Cmon man.