Comic Heads: For those interested

Who would win a mma fight (weapons allowed, energy powers not)

  • Batman

    Votes: 22 84.6%
  • Shatterstar

    Votes: 4 15.4%

  • Total voters
    26
  • Poll closed .

Solomon Grundy

Support BGOL
Registered
Here's the First tourney matchup. Batman Vs. Shatterstar. Here's the link to the introduction post for those that didn't see it. Feel free to discuss reasons why you cast a vote for whichever character.

http://www.bgol.us/board/showthread.php?t=239771&highlight=comic+heads

Here's the link to the brackets if you want to go straight to that.

http://www.bracketmaker.com/tlist.cfm?tid=262068



250px-Batmanlee.png


Unlike many superheroes, Batman has no superpowers and instead relies on "his own scientific knowledge, detective skills, and athletic prowess."[73] Batman is physically at the peak of human ability in dozens of areas, notably martial arts, acrobatics, strength, and escape artistry. Intellectually, he is just as peerless; Batman is one of the world's greatest scientists, engineers, criminologists, and tacticians, as well as a master of disguise, often gathering information under the identity of Matches Malone. He is regarded as one of the DC Universe's greatest detectives. Rather than simply outfighting his opponents, Batman often uses cunning and planning to outwit them. In Grant Morrison's first storyline in JLA, Superman describes Batman as "the most dangerous man on Earth," able to defeat a team of superpowered aliens all by himself in order to rescue his imprisoned teammates.[74]

shatterstar.jpg


Shatterstar possesses an overall superhuman level of physical and mental power (senses, strength, speed, reflexes, agility, dexterity, coordination, balance, endurance), as a result of the extra-dimensional genetic engineering that created him. He is an excellent strategist and has had extensive training in many forms of the martial arts of Mojoworld; in particular, he is a master swordsman. His bones are hollow, making him far lighter than he looks and further increasing his athletic and acrobatic skills. He also has enhanced learning capabilities, being able to quickly learn and master languages and technology. He customarily wields two swords and on occasion carries other weaponry as well. Shatterstar is able to regenerate damaged or destroyed tissue much faster than an ordinary human. Injuries such as slashes and stabbings heal completely within a matter of hours. Additionally, his body possesses the ability to shift his internal organs within his body, lessening the chances of serious wounds. He also has the mutant ability to channel and generate powerful vibratory shock waves (and perhaps bio-electricity) charges through these blades, though he rarely uses them as they tend to exhaust him, and prefers to depend instead on his martial prowess. It is not clear as to whether his rarely used mutant abilities were removed after M-Day.

Remember, these contests are based on physical martial arts skills only i.e. assume Shatterstar cannot fire any energy blasts, but he and Batman can use hand held weapons. i.e.: swords, knives etc.
 
Last edited:
since you said mma style fight, we can only assume both fighters are given time to prep. Batman + prep time > any opponent
 
too many batman dickriders....

It's really just a matter of history. Batman has taken down Bane, Killer Croc, Lady Shiva, Azrael, Superman, even stole on Darkseid. Shatterstar was bred to fight, but Batman forged himself, therefore is intrinsically motivated to be badass. He wins.
 
Batman should win, but by a slim margin.

Now if you match him up with Black Panther, Batman would get his ass kicked. Black Panther>Batman.

The Black Panther is basically a combination of Mr. Terrific and Batman.
 
Batman should win, but by a slim margin.

Now if you match him up with Black Panther, Batman would get his ass kicked. Black Panther>Batman.

The Black Panther is basically a combination of Mr. Terrific and Batman.

I agree, but the only advantage that Black Panther would have is strength. Every other area they're equal.

Oh and batman>shatterstar with prep
 
Last edited:
batman would mash that dude. and i think shatty is cool, but bats is a better fighter, and he definitely has the mental advantage.
 
too many batman dickriders....

That's one view point. But don't forget, Batman is everywhere, he's been around for a long time. He's well established...a household name. Only people that read Marvel know who Shatterstar is, plus he simply isn't used that often by Marvel. Another one of Rob Liefield's poorly designed characters from the early 90s. I did some research and Shatterstar only has one 4 issue mini series. The only other times we've seen him have been from X-Force. Long story short, we just haven't seen Shatterstar in action enough to know whether or not he could defeat Batman.
 
That's one view point. But don't forget, Batman is everywhere, he's been around for a long time. He's well established...a household name. Only people that read Marvel know who Shatterstar is, plus he simply isn't used that often by Marvel. Another one of Rob Liefield's poorly designed characters from the early 90s. I did some research and Shatterstar only has one 4 issue mini series. The only other times we've seen him have been from X-Force. Long story short, we just haven't seen Shatterstar in action enough to know whether or not he could defeat Batman.


Good stuff here. 45 mins left, but I think this one is a wrap.
 
Back
Top